My son's girlfriend got caught with a cigarette and lighter at school yesterday. She is only 15 and claims she took the cigarettes from her dad. She was suspended for 3 days. Her mom asked me what her punishment at home should be. Any suggestions?
I don't know if I'd punish her, but she'd know the 3 days out of school weren't going to be a vacation. The school already punished her, and, along the line of what Morgan said it'd be somewhat hypocritical to punish her at home for something her parents do.
Tiki...I thought it would be hypoocritical too, but then I thought, it is legal for the parent to smoke. I told my son's gf's mom that she should make her pick up cigarette butts at a local park or something. Tough call though...
Make her spend those 3 days researching the effects of smoking on one's body, then the 3rd day have her write an essay about 6 pages of what it does to you.
I'd ask her to write a 20 page report on the effects of smoking...healthwise, and how much money it will cost too, to support a pack a day habit.
I'd also have her scrub the bathrooms with a toothbrush.
But that's just me.
My whole family smokes except for me, and go fig, I'm married to a smoker. And it grosses me out.
Make her spend those 3 days researching the effects of smoking on one's body, then the 3rd day have her write an essay about 6 pages of what it does to you.
I agree with MSV. 20 pages is a little excessive IMO.
See if she can volunteer at a Cancer center for a few hrs while she's suspended.
uh, huh that too, she needs to see it first hand on what it does to one's body.
I was caught at 11, but I had bought them, my only punishment was that my daddy marched my happy arse into the store, and asked for the manager and said "do you see her?, She's 11, you ever sell cigarettes to her again I will make sure you don't have a job" I might have been grounded too but I don't remember that part.
She definitely needs to be punished. She stole 2 items belonging to her father and she's not legally of age to smoke. Brought contraband to the school which violates their policies.
She definitely needs to be punished. She stole 2 items belonging to her father and she's not legally of age to smoke. Brought contraband to the school which violates their policies.
That's were the 3 days of suspension takes play. Well, she is grounded I know that for sure. ( Good thing for me because I can't stand that my son sees her).
I thought it would be hypoocritical too, but then I thought, it is legal for the parent to smoke.
It is legal--but it's not fair that the family has to suffer from second hand smoke, that's just asking to kill your family.
I think that out of school suspension is pointless--it's a vacation. At my old high school, we had in-school suspension. I never had it, but I heard that it was awful.
she should make her pick up cigarette butts at a local park or something.
That is gross.
I don't understand the logic behind punishing a child, forcing them to smoke. You don't want them to smoke.
It's not healthy.
The more they smoke, the chances increase of them becoming addicted.
It's like telling a child not to play on the highway, but punishing them by putting them there if they are caught.
It's just a matter of which car will get them.
Chain smoking a carton would actually make the child very ill, and next time they decide to light up, they'll probably think twice.
I remember being caught at 14...YEARS ago and my dad making me smoke a pack in front of him...made me sick and I never smoked again.
I don't understand the logic behind punishing a child, forcing them to smoke. You don't want them to smoke.
It's not healthy.
The more they smoke, the chances increase of them becoming addicted.
It's like telling a child not to play on the highway, but punishing them by putting them there if they are caught.
It's just a matter of which car will get them.
agree, and
making them smoke an entire carton??
If the child ever did get cancer, I would feel like it was partly my fault if I did something like that. NO THANKS
I remember being caught at 14...YEARS ago and my dad making me smoke a pack in front of him...made me sick and I never smoked again
Same thing happened to one of my brothers years ago. Today he smokes a pack a day and has a smokers hack you wouldn't believe. So it doesn't always work.
You could always not punish the child, and then they'll realize that what they did wasn't so bad, continue stealing and smoking, end up in jail and with cancer anyway.
You could always not punish the child, and then they'll realize that what they did wasn't so bad, continue stealing and smoking, end up in jail and with cancer anyway.
I never said not to punish them, I said make them write a report, I agreed about visiting a cancer center, but I don't agree with smoking a carton and I said why above.
They suspended her?!?!!
HOLY COW!!!
At my school it was a well known fact that quite a few of the kids smoked... and they did it in the bathrooms. Heck there were teachers that would join them!
It was nasty but I don't recall anyone ever being suspended...