I have a question for the pro-lifers, if you feel like answering :).
Theres just something that doesn't sit well with me about the pro-life movement. I don't understand how the life of an unborn baby is considered worthy of legal protection, but the life of a child working as a slave to make a pair of Nike shoes isn't. Our society, like it or not, profits off of elevating the statues of OUR lives as something worth more than the lives of those whos sacrifice and hard work we profit from.
I don't understand how one can be pro-life and purchase a conflict diamond as an engagement gift. Or buy a shirt made in a factory by a child whos life expectancy is only 30.
?
Theres just something that doesn't sit well with me about the pro-life movement. I don't understand how the life of an unborn baby is considered worthy of legal protection, but the life of a child working as a slave to make a pair of Nike shoes isn't. Our society, like it or not, profits off of elevating the statues of OUR lives as something worth more than the lives of those whos sacrifice and hard work we profit from.
Because it's not taking a life. As much as it sucks, what would their life be like without that pitance of a pay? I'm not saying that it is right, but it's a fact of life.
And what you are asking, is really apples and oranges
All Life Is Precious. The unborn can't protect itself but a child that can speak can say something to someone to get help.
Do you honestly think a child living in an oppressed country has the ability to ask the nearest adult, who is most likely the one oppressing them, for help?
Because it's not taking a life. As much as it sucks, what would their life be like without that pitance of a pay? I'm not saying that it is right, but it's a fact of life.
And what you are asking, is really apples and oranges
No, it's not. If the life of an unborn child is precious enough to protect, how is it okay for the life of a slave child to be okay with our society as long as someone is profiting from it?
the life of a slave child to be okay with our society as long as someone is profiting from it?
I never said it was ok as long as someone is profitting, except in the sense that would their life be like without it. And last I heard, that's is why we have child labor laws on our country. If I buy something made in a sweatshop, and I'm sure along the line somewhere I have, then how am I ending a life? If I have an abortion, then I am ending a life. It's two completely different things. And again, in an ideal world, it would be great if no kid had to work in a sweatshop, but it's not an ideal world.
Personally...if you are adult enough to make a baby...then make the right decision..if you feel you aren't ready for parenthood there's adoption. I was teenage mother who still finished high school and graduated college with a child...it can be done.
I never said it was ok as long as someone is profitting, except in the sense that would their life be like without it. And last I heard, that's is why we have child labor laws on our country. If I buy something made in a sweatshop, and I'm sure along the line somewhere I have, then how am I ending a life? If I have an abortion, then I am ending a life. It's two completely different things. And again, in an ideal world, it would be great if no kid had to work in a sweatshop, but it's not an ideal world.
This still doesn't make any sense. You are protecting the life of an unborn child because it has value enough to be legally protected. You are supporting countries and people who oppress children who are already born and suffer their entire lives because "it's not an ideal world". In an ideal world, there would be no suffering...no abortions, no child labor. Most of what we purchase doesn't come from this country, so our child labor laws are a moot point.
I want to know what makes one more valuble than the other.
Kids in sweat shops isn't right either, but here is the thing all the world leaders and most people care about these days is the ALL MIGHTY DOLLAR. Thus they are profiting from abortions and kids in sweat shops and so much more.
Kids in sweat shops isn't right either, but here is the thing all the world leaders and most people care about these days is the ALL MIGHTY DOLLAR. Thus they are profiting from abortions and kids in sweat shops and so much more.
Say what?
And before you say their lives would be better, I did an entire term paper in college on the effects of sweatshops on these third world economies and such
again, BECAUSE ONE IS NOT CAUSING AN OUTRIGHT END OF LIFE!!!!!!! And how much more would they suffer without that job they are "slaving in".
The children wouldn't have to work in a factory their short lives. Are you insinuating that child labor and slavery in other countries is acceptable? If conditions were better and people did not profit from child slavery, it could be argued that their lives would be longer, healthier, and happier. How is it okay to value the life of an unborn child over the life of a child slave?
horrible comparison. It is illegal to do business with nations who support child labor. Yes, Nike was suspected of it, confirmed it, however you politically want to say it. So was Kathie Lee Gifford!!
Pro Lifers get compared to this? Next it will be child abuse (which can also be compared to child labor laws).
What gives anyone the right to kill a baby?
And before you say their lives would be better, I did an entire term paper in college on the effects of sweatshops on these third world economies and such
On the economies. Money never makes oppression okay.
What gives anyone the right to kill a baby?
What gives anyone the right to tell anyone ELSE what to do with their life? Beliefs and opinions and social norms are different EVERYWHERE you go. Your beliefs do not trump the beliefs of others, just because you might be a part of the most 'popular' group.
We don't like the way other countries run their lives, but we have to realize that most citizens of these poor countries do the best they can with what they have.
Whatever happened to "Judge not lest ye be judged"?
I guess thats why it is legal here but I dont think it should be compared to child labor laws.
I am comparing the value of an unborn childs life to the value of a child slaves life.
I am comparing the value of an unborn childs life to the value of a child slaves life.
interesting perspective then. I hadnt thought of it as their value of life so to speak. Very interesting perspective.
I am comparing the value of an unborn childs life to the value of a child slaves life.
It only matters to most if
a) they are American
or
b) they are doing something that conflicts with their religon.
I don't understand how one can be pro-life and purchase a conflict diamond as an engagement gift. Or buy a shirt made in a factory by a child whos life expectancy is only 30.
The countries this is happening in needs to step up and protect its citizens. As for costs of products made overseas vs here... if the unions would stop with their hideous dues and insane salary requirements (sorry, $76hr to build a car? LOL) companies could afford to stay here in the US and make their products here. Plus how many Americans say "they'd never do that job"? I've seen it on here alot, one a few months ago whose father refused to work for less than $20/hr. Umm if you need a job, you'll work.
Do you have diamonds or buy anything that's made internationally?
I am comparing the value of an unborn childs life to the value of a child slaves life.
I think I'm hearing your argument as, "Why is it better to let a child be born into a poverty stricken life in a 3rd world country than for the parents to be provided with an abortion / birth control if they so choose?" Is that about it? I agree, if so...the righteous get all upset about providing abortions to people in these situations and then turn around and come door to door, hat in hand, asking for money for these 'poor underprivileged souls.' It's a little backwards, if you ask me.
True, it is HARSH to believe that it is better to end a pregnancy than let a child live that kind of life, but I think the world is FULL of sad realities, and this is just one of them.
We'd be even MORE upset if we knew how many cultures in the world practice child abandonment and death by exposure to rid themselves of kids they can't afford.
I've seen it on here alot, one a few months ago whose father refused to work for less than $20/hr. Umm if you need a job, you'll work.
I posted a job opening up in here today and got no response whatsoever!