Smack him back so he knew what it felt like. Then I would make him apologize to the kid and take him home immediately.
lol You sound like my husband. I hate it when he does that.
If M hits us he'll do it back (obviously not hard at all) Just so he knows how it feels and it's not nice.
It depends. First of all, Where did he see that to think it was okay? Second, I would make sure he knew it had hurt the child. I would most likely not spank him for it because to a 4 yr old that won't make sense. The punishment should fit the crime. I think time out for the allotted 4 min and I would make him apologize for doing that.
really? in public and all?
Yup.
i would agree(i would give my child a hard pop in the hand though, i don't do face smacking) because a simple "sorry" now a days isn't so sincere. They just want to get out of trouble.
you failed at parenting?
No douche, MY kid got smacked.
My son was standing on the foot swing thing and the other kid (whom my kids had already played with a bit) walked over and kind of pushed my son twice, but I thought he may just be pushing him on the swing thing. Then he just hauled off and windmill smacked my son in the face and went to walk away. I yelled at him "NO, WE DO NOT HIT!!!! Where is your Mommy?" and made him go tell her what he did.
Obviously not hard enough to knock him down and leave a mark on his face. Geezus people.
i know that... i dunno how i feel about hitting my kids in pubic....
i dont have kids, so i really dont know what i would do
but i know, when i see people do it, i think it looks sooo bad
you failed at parenting?
No douche, MY kid got smacked.
hey no need for name calling. you said WHAT IF YOUR... then i responded. YOU FAILED AT PARENTING. meaning the kid's parent. You didn't say it was YOUR kid, so I knew it must've been YOUR kid that got the smack down.
Question: what did that parent(s) do to the child afterwards?
i know that... i dunno how i feel about hitting my kids in pubic....
i dont have kids, so i really dont know what i would do
If he's just generally acting out I will take him to the bathroom and give him a spanking. It takes him to do something pretty bad for me to just hit him right then and there.
but i know, when i see people do it, i think it looks sooo bad
That's your opinion. Maybe when you have kids you will change your mind. Never know.
You would smack him in the face?
If he smacked somebody else in the face - yes. Not for like regular punishment though.
Mine have been smacked in the face. For talking bad mostly and once or twice for giving ME the mean mug evil eye. If the face is doing the wrong, well then put the punishment there ;)
That's your opinion. Maybe when you have kids you will change your mind. Never know.
yea, maybe...
im not like totally against spanking... im just not sure about the public part...
once, someone called the cops on my aunt cause she spanked my cousin in public, thats scary
hey no need for name calling. you said WHAT IF YOUR... then i responded. YOU FAILED AT PARENTING. meaning the kid's parent. You didn't say it was YOUR kid, so I knew it must've been YOUR kid that got the smack down.
Sorry. I thought you were saying it towards me.
Question: what did that parent(s) do to the child afterwards?
You know I'm not quite sure. She did have him sitting on the bench (where she had been the whole time) for the last 10 minutes we were there, but no apology. When my kid does hit I make him apologize. Plus my kid has never hit like that, it's usually when they all get running around and rough housing that he will get too rough and kind of hit or kick or grab. kwim? If he ever just unprovoked hit someone in the face like that I just might woop him all the way to the car!
once, someone called the cops on my aunt cause she spanked my cousin in public, thats scary
Sad that people can't even punish their own kids without fear of persecution. I could understand if she were totally beating the kid but I don't think a quick spanking is beating.
Mrs Z, I don't spank mine in public. I take them to the bathroom and most of the time the threat of the bathroom is enough to get them to fix their behavior. When we end up in the bathroom, 9 times out of 10 I don't spank them. It's just a way to get them out of the situation so they can understand why it's not okay
Sad that people can't even punish their own kids without fear of persecution.
Has anyone heard of this new kids consitution thing that is trying to be passed? A friend was telling me about it, apparently kids will be able to pick their religon, education etc. and if they don't agree with how their parents dicipine them they can get an advocate and sue their parents? I have looked into it yet but I sure hope she was wrong.
Sad that people can't even punish their own kids without fear of persecution. I could understand if she were totally beating the kid but I don't think a quit spanking is beating.
it was in Cali... lol
yea, it sucked! he just got spanked twice, that was it!
Has anyone heard of this new kids consitution thing that is trying to be passed? A friend was telling me about it, apparently kids will be able to pick their religon, education etc. and if they don't agree with how their parents dicipine them they can get an advocate and sue their parents? I have looked into it yet but I sure hope she was wrong.
if it's true, I sure hope it doesn't get pass. i follow the concept of "if you live under MY roof, you follow my rules!"