We did it with both my boys. Started it around 6 weeks, and it took about a week with each (each night was better than the last) until they stopped crying at all when they went to bed. By 8 weeks they were both sleeping through the night.
With my younger one we did when she was tiny but her dad would swaddle her and hold her real tight and she would finally give up struggling and just fall asleep in his arms.
I didnt let my daughter cry it out, IMO if a baby is crying, something is wrong.
My daughter also hardly ever cried.
I know people who let their baby cry for hours, and just ignore them. I feel like thats neglect.
He is almost eight months.
OH my 8 month old goes to sleep with a 4oz water bottle if she is cranky and a binky of she isn't. But she is pretty good about going to sleep now.
Well my 8 month old needs to be swaddled, with a binky, his head in my chest and my arm over him to fall asleep and he still fusses for about 30 minutes to fall asleep.
When DH left we fell into a lot of bad habits because it didn't matter it was just us but I know the longer I wait to fix the habits the harder it will be on him.
My daughter was Horrible about that. She came out spoiled I think. Numerous nights I had to let her cry it out. Worked for the better. She
is 5 now and don't have any trouble.
The "cry it out" method does not mean to let them cry all night...although some people think it does. I can't imagine leaving my baby to cry for hours!
I could not bear to do anything even close to crying it out until my son was older...around 9 months. He always had a very consistent bedtime routine....bottle, bath, book, bed. I actually realized that I needed to put him to bed EARLIER than I was. We would do the bedtime routine, I would hold him or rock him for a minute or two, lay him down, then leave. The first few days, I went in after 5 minutes, patted his back a bit to soothe him, then left (I was in there less than a minute and I never talked to him...just shhh'd or hummed to him). I kept repeating that (for him it never took more than 2-3 times a night and he was out (so maybe 20 minutes of crying/fussing total). I increased the amount of time I let him cry before going in to soothe him as the days went on. It didn't take him very long before he would just lay down and fall asleep on his own.
Prior to doing this...he would ALWAYS have to be nursed to sleep, so I think it went quite well. Now that he is older (16 months) he does fuss sometimes when I put him down, but it is never long before he is sound asleep. I think he is just worried he is going to miss out on something exciting :)
Even the so called experts of sleep training including Dr. Ferber don't recommend CIO before 6 months.
I personally don't believe in CIO and won't encourage it.
However I don't believe FIO fuss it out is quiet the same ,baby is just whining and fussy maybe mumbling ,etc itself to sleep.
i did with the older two around 6 months, it worked for me, and they never cried for more than 15 minutes. my youngest (22 months) has been spoiled more, and he still gets up almost every night. he's also stubborn, and would have probably cried all night. hubs hated to hear him cry, so he would get him up. but i fixed him after hubs left, and now he goes right to sleep.
I always gave them their night time bottle or nursed sitting in the rocker and they would fall asleep and I would put them in their cribs. I really cannot stand a baby crying and they both grew up normal and nothing wrong with rocking a baby to sleep. Be the time they were two, they got a story and then fell asleep.
I always gave them their night time bottle or nursed sitting in the rocker and they would fall asleep and I would put them in their cribs. I really cannot stand a baby crying and they both grew up normal and nothing wrong with rocking a baby to sleep. Be the time they were two, they got a story and then fell asleep.
Ditto for my 1st 2 but #3 is almost 4 and still doesn't fall asleep on her own and doesn't sleep through the night.
But all 3 were parented to sleep in the same way.
we co-sleep with all 3 until they were mobile(crawling) the it was in a crib. They all did occasionally co-sllep after that for part of the night,etc.
My husband and I just took "parenting classes" at onslow. (Reserve your laughter. We're expecting our first and he's never so much as HELD an infant.) I believe in the "self soothe" method after a certain age (no earlier than 6 months), but they actually gave us pamphlets that said you should not let your child self soothe in the first year because it interferes with the "trust" your child is building with you. It also says trust is the firstt thing a parent teaches a child, i'd say the trust is established before 8 months.
but they actually gave us pamphlets that said you should not let your child self soothe in the first year because it interferes with the "trust" your child is building with you. It also says trust is the firstt thing a parent teaches a child, i'd say the trust is established before 8 months.
I actually agree with them but I'm just an AP hippie.
I actually agree with them but I'm just an AP hippie.
I'm expecting my first, so my opinion isn't entirely valid until after July. I wouldn't try "crying it out" before 6 months.
For me whatever works for people is good for them. My kids do not have trust issues, or feel abandoned or what not because we let them cry it out so early on. We have never had issues with them getting out of bed or needing to sleep with us etc. I think what may work for some may not work for others.
Personally, I wouldn't change what I did, it was hard at the time but I am glad we did it that way!
Good luck with what you decide!
We did not do the CIO, I couldn't stand to let her cry like that. L has ever really been one that needed to as long as she had her bottle with her, she was content and would sleep.
My husband and I were probably what some may consider "harsh" since we didn't do pacifiers, bottles in bed, bottles after age of 1, letting the baby sleep in our bed/room and so on.
I think a baby can only be "babied" so much before it becomes a lasting issue. My good friend "babied" their child to a beyond well-meaning point and that child who is now 4 still has a pacifier, gets coddled when going to bed, doesn't sleep through the night, has extreme abandonment issues and the list goes on...UGH!!!
However, I know that they love their little girl so I don't fault them for doing what they did/do, I'm just thankful I don't have to deal with the repercussions of it! =)
My good friend "babied" their child to a beyond well-meaning point and that child who is now 4 still has a pacifier, gets coddled when going to bed, doesn't sleep through the night, has extreme abandonment issues and the list goes on...UGH!!!
I think I would seriously go crazy if my kids were like that!
I think I would seriously go crazy if my kids were like that!
Welcome to my world.LOL
well the only "issues" we have with A is she doesn't fall asleep on her own and she doesn't sleep through the night.
She's not 4 yet either.
LOL I know some people blame it on "babying" (attachment parenting,co-sleeping,etc) but I parented all 3 girls the same way and the 1st 2 were sleeping through the night by 12-14 weeks.
We think A may have a problem regulating melatonin levels.
She is also very restless in her sleep too.
The only reason I had to try to let my son CIO (which, if you read my previous post is probably not what most would even consider crying it out) was because he was waking up every 90 minutes at night and could NOT fall back to sleep on his own. His pediatrician recommended a few books, I read through them and developed a plan that was comfortable for me (no long periods of crying, being able to go in and reassure him, etc). He was able to learn to fall asleep on his own (something he had not been able to do before). The lack of sleep was killing me and he was miserable too.
You have to do what feels right for you as a parent. I did read some research about how stressful crying it out for long periods of time can be on young infants. I think all of the true experts recommend waiting until they are older.