Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Madonna's Adoption

who's talking here?

MrsH 1
HappyMomma 3
♥ 3
Jules 1
Ella Mafayo 1
The Original LM 2
Scentsy M*W* 3
Susie Homemaker 1
Missin' SC 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Madonna's Adoption

I was just reading a story on CNN.com about how Madonna's adoption petition was rejected. The rejection was based on a residency requirement and the judge's belief that the child was in good hands at an orphanage. Do you believe that a child would be better off in the orphanage rather than living with a parent or parental figure? Just wondering on other views of this.

Better off w/ an orphanage Vote
 
 13.3% (2)
Better off w/ a parent/parental figure Vote
 
 86.7% (13)
Other (please explain) Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
HappyMomma --- 17 years ago -

I was just reading a story on CNN.com about how Madonna's adoption petition was rejected. The rejection was based on a residency requirement and the judge's belief that the child was in good hands at an orphanage. Do you believe that a child would be better off in the orphanage rather than living with a parent or parental figure? Just wondering on other views of this. 

HappyMomma --- 17 years ago -

I feel that the child wouldn't necessarily be better off with the orphanage but can see the judge's say about residency requirements. 

Scentsy M*W* --- 17 years ago -

No child, in my opinion, would be better off in an orphanage. Every child deserves to feel the love of a single family. 

♥ --- 17 years ago -

I said better off at an orphanage. I don't believe for a minute that Madonna parents each and every one of those kids. SHe has staff that does it for her. She has enough children. The celebs are only doing it for the publicity. 

HappyMomma --- 17 years ago -

I do in a way agree, TM. This wasn't just about Madonna, but I saw her story and it made me wonder. 

MrsH --- 17 years ago -

I don't believe for a minute that Madonna parents each and every one of those kids. SHe has staff that does it for her. Probably but I would think that Madonna's staff is better able to care for those kids than an orphange in some crappy third world country. 

The Original LM --- 17 years ago -

I think the child needs a family... However, I don't think she should adopt another child until her divorce is finalized at least! 

Scentsy M*W* --- 17 years ago -

Probably but I would think that Madonna's staff is better able to care for those kids than an orphange in some crappy third world country. Yep. If any of you have ever been in an orphanage you may feel different. Even if I had a nanny(or whatever you want to call it) looking after me 24/7 it would still be MUCH better than living in some crappy orphanage. 

♥ --- 17 years ago -

Probably but I would think that Madonna's staff is better able to care for those kids than an orphange in some crappy third world country. Oh, I'm sure they can. That's not a family though. That's just buying things. 

Scentsy M*W* --- 17 years ago -

Oh, I'm sure they can. That's not a family though. That's just buying things. It's closer to a family then being in an orphanage... lol I'd rather be bought things and spoiled on a daily basis rather than being in an orphanage. Call me materialistic. Honestly, being in an orphanage is just a step up from being homeless. 

♥ --- 17 years ago -

I'd rather be bought things and spoiled on a daily basis rather than being in an orphanage. Maybe so and I'm sure most people would, but the problem is that she is looking at the baby as a posession. I can certainly see why they denied her. Babies aren't like a new car or house. 

Susie Homemaker --- 17 years ago -

I think being adopted by a person, then parented by a staff is unacceptable. Why even adopt at all? It might be better than an orphange, but the child isn't being raised by parents, he/she is being raised by a nanny. 

Ella Mafayo --- 17 years ago -

See, this whole conversation depends on the definition of 'better off.' In terms of financial support, nutrition, education, and one to one time with a caring adult (nanny or Madonna, either one), then the child would be better off being whisked away by The Material Girl. However, if you consider cultural heritage more important, or if you think that the lifestyle that comes with being mega-super-rich is detrimental (think Paris HIlton), then you might say that being in the orphanage is better. There's a lot of psychological damage that "can" come along with being the child of a super-famous-and-mega-rich parent. (It's not a guarantee that every rich kid will grow up spoiled and emotionally stunted, but it's fairly common.) And then there's this argument. Not that it has any bearing on the situation at hand, but why do these famous people continually go outside the U.S. to adopt a child when there are so many children here, living in poverty and becoming victims of an endless cycle of foster care? She could just as easily provide a good home to an unwanted child born in America as she could for one born in Africa. Same with Brangelina and all those other famous people who go outside our borders. America's adoption laws need to be re-evaluated to make it EASIER to adopt, not harder, and these rich-and-famous folks need to keep their charity closer to home, in MY opinion. Their money, their business, but still....if they're looking to score 'points' with me for being a good person, they'd score higher by adopting a poor American child. 

Missin' SC --- 17 years ago -

However, I don't think she should adopt another child until her divorce is finalized at least!  I didn't know she was getting a divorce. Bout time Guy Ritchie got out of that nightmare lol 

The Original LM --- 17 years ago -

I don;t necessarily think she is a bad person, but I don't see why she is trying to adopt now. She's going through a divorce and has been "seeing" young men, that don't stick around. 

Missin' SC --- 17 years ago -

I don;t necessarily think she is a bad person, but I don't see why she is trying to adopt now. She's going through a divorce and has been "seeing" young men, that don't stick around.  Have you seen him interviewed with her right next to him? She totally embarrasses him, cuts him off, and tries to speak for him. You can always see the irritation in his face. 

Jules --- 17 years ago -

Amy, it's cheaper and faster to adopt elsewhere - that's why they do. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground