Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

If you were a high schooler or parent of a high schooler, how would you feel about this?

who's talking here?

HappyMomma 1
dmc... 1
bugaboo 2
supercalifragilistic 2
Ella Mafayo 4
TheBoneCollector 1
Kim 1
freddy 1
SeriouslyInaneBabble 1
addictedtosweettea 1
tb 1
Erin Marie 1
Scentsy M*W* 2
mad&ajdmommee 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Ella Mafayo --- 17 years ago -

Are these 'projects' too much? Are they not enough? Is this program a step in the right direction for American schools? NC graduation requirement might be dead in the water Discuss! 

HappyMomma --- 17 years ago -

When I was in high school, we were the first graduating class required to do a high school graduation project. That being said, alot of the students failed on the first shot, because the teacher judges weren't sure of what was expected. We had 3.5 years to complete the project. It began as a freshman and was presented halfway in the senior year. Did it suck? Kinda. BUT, I think it helped with long term. 

dmc... --- 17 years ago -

I've known quite a few students to do this, and none of them complained. My dad has been a mentor for at least 2 seniors over the years. He's always had a good time, too. 

addictedtosweettea --- 17 years ago -

We were required to keep a portfolio we started our freshman year that outlined 12 exit outcomes. We had to have this portfolio completed by the end of our senior year, we had to have 4 examples of educational and community volunteer experience in each outcome to graduate. We also had to give an hour long presentation on the subject of our choice to an audience of at least one teacher, one school board member, one community member and an expert in our field of choice. I did mine on the evolution and technology of the Ocean Liner. We also had to present our portfolios at that time as well. I feel that this experience readied me for college and job interviews. It was a great experience and I think it should be mandatory in every school. 

Scentsy M*W* --- 17 years ago -

I think it's a great idea to have a required project in order to graduate. I know MANY kids that should have never graduated and just skated by without putting in nearly half the efford others did, but they were still able to graduate. In my opinion, that isn't fair. I do not think they should be REQUIRED to find a mentor, though it is a good idea. 

Ella Mafayo --- 17 years ago -

I commented in the JD news article, but here's my 2 cents worth: While it's ridiculous to keep promoting those kids who are BARELY functional at reading and writing, and then turn around and make them take on this monster of a task. I don't think school really prepares them for something of this magnitude anymore, does it? But, at the same time, I don't buy the whole "It's too much work for a poor overwhelmed student" argument. I hhave had to turn in a research paper...sometimes TWO papers...every single 8 week semester for the last two years. Not 3 or 4 page baby papers...12-15 page papers with 5-10 scholarly research sources. If I can work at home, raise and home school 2 kids, cook, clean, do laundry, and still manage to get these papers finished and achieve "A" grades, I think a high schooler can handle ONE paper over the course of a whole school year. I think they should keep the program. 

Ella Mafayo --- 17 years ago -

I do not think they should be REQUIRED to find a mentor, though it is a good idea.  One of the commenters had a good point though. We're preaching volunteerism to these kids, but there seems to be a shortage of adults who can provide this mentorship. Maybe there's not so much of a 'shortage' as there is a lack of avenues for students and mentors to connect. If I had a skill, I'd certainly be willing to do this, but the average adult in a community probably isn't aware that mentors are NEEDED. The schools need to do a little more 'advertising' for mentors if they want this program to succeed. 

supercalifragilistic --- 17 years ago -

I was a mentor for a White Oak High School student this past fall. It was interesting, though a little too easy, IMO, for the students to submit documentation/information regarding the work required. 

Erin Marie --- 17 years ago -

I had to do 40 hours of community service to graduate and a report on an issue going on in the world. Mine was against animal testing and my partner had to do for animal testing. We then had to debate about it in front of the class. 

Kim --- 17 years ago -

I think it sounds good, in theory. How does it work if your child changes schools midway? For example, D will start H.S in one location, and finish in another. 

supercalifragilistic --- 17 years ago -

The schools need to do a little more 'advertising' for mentors if they want this program to succeed. That is very true. Perhaps they could contact a local Chamber of Commerce and get hooked up. 

Ella Mafayo --- 17 years ago -

I think it sounds good, in theory. How does it work if your child changes schools midway? For example, D will start H.S in one location, and finish in another.  I would imagine that, since it's not due until the senior year (I assume) that the student would just carry his or her ideas and work to the new school. Keeping in contact with the mentor might be the only trouble one would encounter with moving. 

bugaboo --- 17 years ago -

My son has to do the senior project. I think it is just to much for them to handle on top of doing all of there regular work.Trying to get someone to mentor them is really hard when you don't know to many people.I think the 20 pages of what to do and what not to do is rediculus(sp) 

SeriouslyInaneBabble --- 17 years ago -

At what point is the line drawn between "too much work for the poor overwhelmed student" and "not prepared for the real world situations and deadlines that come up?" Also, what happens if someone transfers from one state that didn't have the senior project to NC halfway through their senior year? How would THAT work? They'd get half a year to work on their project or they don't graduate? 

bugaboo --- 17 years ago -

My son did not get the paperwork for this project till Jan. I think it should of been handed out at the begining of the school year. What I don't like they can be passing all of their sujects then it comes down to this and they don't pass it then they fail the year. 

Scentsy M*W* --- 17 years ago -

Also, what happens if someone transfers from one state that didn't have the senior project to NC halfway through their senior year? How would THAT work? They'd get half a year to work on their project or they don't graduate? I'm sure they make exceptions for those students. 

tb --- 17 years ago -

I graduated in 2003 and my class was the first one from my high school (in Maine) that had to complete a project in order to graduate. There is no reason that anyone should not be able to graduate because of this--we were given the project during our sophomore year, so if you couldn't pass, you didn't deserve to graduate. 

freddy --- 17 years ago -

both my boys are SR. this year, and they had to do it, it was ok, but if your teacher does not like your topic, you have to fine another one, it was rough trying to find a topic she would approve of, she let some one do build your own gun, but would not let my son do how to solve a rubic cube 

mad&ajdmommee --- 17 years ago -

I grad a few years back and the closest thing to this that we had was our senior memory book thing in English. We did have a program that you could enroll in a class that allowed you to work outside of the school in like an internship and you would have to meet with your teacher once a week or the teacher would come to where you were and evaluate you. I worked at a primary school with a 2nd grade class since thats what I wanted to go to college for. 

TheBoneCollector --- 17 years ago -

I graduated in 2003 and we had to do a senior project. You had to get a mentor, write an 8 page paper, and deliver a 10 minute presentation. It honestly wasn't that hard. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground