Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Is infant circumcision a violation of a child's rights?

who's talking here?

MrsH 1
Mater*Chef_Amy 1
♠QueenB♠ 5
KΛΤIΞ♥™ 3
Stephanie 4
♥ Mrs.B ♥ 1
SAonaSM 3
In4TheLongHaul 1
*KrYsTaL* 3
truthiness 1
Hippie_Momma(Sharon) 16
~*LM*~ 8
!~Gina~! 3
Muse Heather 6
MacSays_ShutUrCockGarage 10
A-Fish-Called-Wanda 13
MeaniePoopyPants 4
Aussiechk 1
billiejean Doop 2
FlippyFloppies 6
MizzKitty 3
M.A.D.R.E 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Is infant circumcision a violation of a child's rights?

Read this in my Psychology Today...thought I'd post it here.

Yes Vote
 
 15.4% (6)
No Vote
 
 82.1% (32)
I don't know. Vote
 
 2.6% (1)
SAonaSM --- 18 years ago -

Read this in my Psychology Today...thought I'd post it here. 

*KrYsTaL* --- 18 years ago -

I don't think so but that's just me. Both of my kids are done and I don't regret having it done. 

MrsH --- 18 years ago -

I never thought about it that way. 

FlippyFloppies --- 18 years ago -

LOL no, but my son is going to be a WHOLE man as opposed to all those mutilated ones out there..... *tongue in cheek over here* 

MeaniePoopyPants --- 18 years ago -

I voted I don't know, because I'm on the fence. On one side, sure. It can be debated that it's violating a child's rights. But then where do you draw the lines? Vaccinating? Ear piercings? Breastfeeding vs formula? All of my boys are cut, but I don't pretend it's not a form of mutilation. 

MizzKitty --- 18 years ago -

What about piercing a baby's ears? 

In4TheLongHaul --- 18 years ago -

son is going to be a WHOLE man as opposed to all those mutilated ones out there..... That is funny. As far as a child's rights, since when did we give them any. Isn't it what momma says goes lol 

Hippie_Momma(Sharon) --- 18 years ago -

yes, but you all knew that would be my answer. ;) 

*KrYsTaL* --- 18 years ago -

lmao. 

Muse Heather --- 18 years ago -

What about piercing a baby's ears? i dont think that ear piercing constitutes surgery, which is why they can do it at the mall. 

~*LM*~ --- 18 years ago -

I voted I don't know, because I'm on the fence. On one side, sure. It can be debated that it's violating a child's rights. But then where do you draw the lines? Vaccinating? Ear piercings? Breastfeeding vs formula? All of my boys are cut, but I don't pretend it's not a form of mutilation. I agree with this. 

Hippie_Momma(Sharon) --- 18 years ago -

What about piercing a baby's ears? My girls all have pierced ears my thoughts on this is earrings can be removed and holes grow up. A foreskin doesn't grow back. 

MeaniePoopyPants --- 18 years ago -

A foreskin doesn't grow back.  Serious (hypothetical) question - with the technolgy we have, could someone have "foreskin" transplanted to their penis? 

SAonaSM --- 18 years ago -

Here is an opinion for "yes"... Circumcision is a procedure that medical associations worldwide agree is not justified. It is a culturally sanctioned cosmetic amputation. Circumcision excises a normal body part with several functions: protecting the penis, enhancing the body's immunological resources, and providing specialized erogenous tissue. Parents cannot really know what their infant son would want, so the best decision is to leave the healthy foreskin alone. For parents to take away so intimate a part of their son's body without his consent, barring true medical need, is wrong.- Steven Svoboda 

~*LM*~ --- 18 years ago -

I know that this isn't nearly the same thing, but people who believe in the right to choose, cite the fact that it is their body for the basis of their arguement. It is the child's body, shouldn't we give him the right to choose what happens to it? 

MeaniePoopyPants --- 18 years ago -

Circumcision is a procedure that medical associations worldwide agree is not justified. But since they get paid, doctors sure are quick to do it! 

A-Fish-Called-Wanda --- 18 years ago -

If it's a violation, then you might as well not introduce ANYTHING to your child, because you will be violating their rights. What about a mother's right to carry the child for the pregnancy, and to raise the child as she and the father sees fit? That's what evolution is about. We don't birth children, and put shoes on them and tell them to "enjoy life and be careful, peace out!" 

Hippie_Momma(Sharon) --- 18 years ago -

Serious (hypothetical) question - with the technolgy we have, could someone have "foreskin" transplanted to their penis? Umm I don't know I do know that many men who were circed as a baby and regrets it can do foreskin restoration. http://www.cirp.org/pages/restore.html 

*KrYsTaL* --- 18 years ago -

A foreskin doesn't grow back. Serious (hypothetical) question - with the technolgy we have, could someone have "foreskin" transplanted to their penis? I was thinking the same thing. They can do anything these days. Hell if they can make a penis, then I am sure they can do that too. 

FlippyFloppies --- 18 years ago -

But since they get paid, doctors sure are quick to do it! We are a greedy nation.... 

Muse Heather --- 18 years ago -

lol, someone used the argument once that jesus was circumcised and that if it's good enough for him, it's good enough for their son. hello, according to legend, jesus was crucified too, but no one is sending their sons to Galgotha. 

MeaniePoopyPants --- 18 years ago -

Umm I don't know I do know that many men who were circed as a baby and regrets it can do foreskin restoration. That seems odd. I've heard stories of un-cut men who were later circ'd and wished their parents would have done it earlier. 

A-Fish-Called-Wanda --- 18 years ago -

lol, someone used the argument once that jesus was circumcised and that if it's good enough for him, it's good enough for their son. hello, according to legend, jesus was crucified too, but no one is sending their sons to Galgotha. Nooooooooooooooooooooooo........... 

SAonaSM --- 18 years ago -

Here is an opinion for "no"... I don't think it's a violation of a child's rights any more than the other decisions parents make. Parents decide a lot of things for their children-what vaccinations to get, what schools to go to, what religion, if any, the children should be raised with. There are those who were circumcised at birth and think they're missing something important. There are also a lot of people who wish they had been circumcised at birth. It can be done later, of course, but it's much harder on the person and much more expensive, and the results are often not as good as when done in infancy.-"Joe Smith" 

Muse Heather --- 18 years ago -

If it's a violation, then you might as well not introduce ANYTHING to your child, because you will be violating their rights. but if your kid doesnt like peas, or piano lessons, you dont make them carry on with the behavior do you? a circumcision is irretractable. 

A-Fish-Called-Wanda --- 18 years ago -

but if your kid doesnt like peas, or piano lessons, you dont make them carry on with the behavior do you? a circumcision is irretractable. That's not what I am saying. I am saying that you might as well not introduce anything, because that would be considered maybe something you are into or something you like, versus the child. Which, as some of these idiots these days would consider, being unfair and unjust to a child. I am going to do whatever the hell I choose to do with my kids. You don't pay my taxes, clean my toilets, or pay child support for my kids, then guess what? You can suck a big fat co*k, because I won't listen to what you have to say. (that was not intended for you, Heather.) 

MizzKitty --- 18 years ago -

I didn't want to have our first son circumcised, but my husband insisted. He had known men who had it done as adults and wished they'd been circumcised as babies. He was circumcised and thought it best for our boys to be, as well. Since he's the one who has a wiener and not me, I let him make the call on that one. 

Hippie_Momma(Sharon) --- 18 years ago -

But since they get paid, doctors sure are quick to do it! Actually the rates of circumcisions are declining because many insurance companies are not paying for it because it's considered unnecessary cosmetic surgery. The AAP American Academy of Pediatrics does not recommend routine circumcision, the decision is left to the parents for personal reasons 

Muse Heather --- 18 years ago -

I am saying that you might as well not introduce anything, because that would be considered maybe something you are into or something you like, versus the child. ah, i see. i lean more to introduce everything. if a have a son, i will introduce him to the idea of circumcision when he is old enough to understand it. we have religious books of all kinds in our home for when K gets old enough to understand the differences, and i try to cook all kinds of different styles of food. 

Hippie_Momma(Sharon) --- 18 years ago -

I'll throw this thought out for people to chew on it's to make you think not get pissy. You would not circumcise your baby girls so why your sons? 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground