I have a thought or two:
1) I'm not impressed with Duke; he's a racist (Just like I'm barely impressed in "Rev" Jeremiah Wright (Obama's pastor); the dude's a racist as well. It goes both ways, regardless of the color of your skin.).
2) Throwing money at a problem doesn't make the problem go away.
Throwing money at a problem doesn't make the problem go away
What are you saying? America constantly throws money at Third World nations and the issues are still there.
I am not impressed with Duke either, but I think there is a lot of merit in what that particular article says.
That was my point. :)
The issues will remain and Third World countries will remain Third World countries because we're only dealing with the symptoms and not the disease.
i think he has a few good points. our money would probably be better spent reforming american health care that being in the hands of of a govt that is more corrupt than our own. i dont have the first idea on how to deal with the corruption of africa's govt without just taking over. we can make them the healthiest people in the world, but their govt is still going to control them and keep them poor. but, on the other hand, i dont think we should completely refuse to help those that are worse off than we are.
So, I read the article, and I am sure I am in your stupid category, but I am going to throw my opinion in there anyway.
I can understand how people are frusturated, because in all reality, we are throwing money their way. Yes, we have enough problems of our own, to take on other countries problems. I couldn't agree anymore.
But, what I did find a little disturbing, was how he talked about the Africans and the AIDS epidemic. First off, he did state that the Africans could barely feed, educate, and provide medical health care for their families.
So, then he turns around and says that they spread the AIDS by rutting like animals, knowing that they could become "infected", makes me question him.
This, in a sense, could be debatable. If the people there can barely educate their people, how do you expect them to know about the disease itself. How could you point out the symptoms, diagnosis, prevention... etc... They don't even go to school. It's not like they are sitting in a class, as we had when we were children and teenagers, and were shown videos, given pamphlets, lectured and so forth.
If they don't have money, how could you provide condoms and other means of safety precautions?
I agree with the majority of this article, but I believe he was a bit heated, and went all out without thinking everything through.
The problem with countries like that is the person who controls the "fear" controls the country. If you have the biggest guns and the most violent soldiers then nobody is going to try to stand up. Then, the only thing that tyrants want is more power. How do they get that? By controlling the people more, exploiting them by using them as slave laborers to harvest whatever the "cash crop" is at the time- herion, marijuana, crack, diamonds, gold, oil, etc. Then that tyrant is going to fill his coffers and who gives a fluck about the people? Nobody. As long as that tyrant/warlord isn't bothering any other countries and starting wars elsewhere; nobody is going to mess with him. It's been going on since the beginning of time and it's going to keep continuing until the end.
As far as throwing money at the problem... that's only going to make it worse. I would much rather go to McDonalds and buy a value meal for a homeless person than give them cash. You're not helping the problem in that case, you're enabling it. This is the same theory. If you're going to help then donate time and service, not cash. We (the U.S.) never gets paid back on it's loans. There are so many countries that owe us money and then side against us that it's not even funny. I think money could be better spent in the U.S. focusing on our problems. I'm all for helping out other people, really I am. I'm a huge fan of Oprah (not necessarily for her girl's school) and Charlize Theron b/c they have a mobile clinic that goes b/t 4 different villages in S. Africa and offers tons of health services. If more "celebrities" and millionaires would be benevolent enough to spread their good blessings on others, then maybe it would work better. Okay, so that part was optimisting and prob not going to happen, but it would be nice. I know that most people are inherently selfish. Hence the reason people BEG, DEMAND, and EXPECT the U.S. to help them out b/c we're so "rich" (lmao), but when we need help they turn their backs. I understand the importance of foreign diplomacy, but seriously, sometimes it's aggravating to be doing all of the giving and not receiving anything in return. Okay, that's all.
I hope it didn't sound "stupid".
But, what I did find a little disturbing, was how he talked about the Africans and the AIDS epidemic. First off, he did state that the Africans could barely feed, educate, and provide medical health care for their families.
So, then he turns around and says that they spread the AIDS by rutting like animals, knowing that they could become "infected", makes me question him.
This, in a sense, could be debatable. If the people there can barely educate their people, how do you expect them to know about the disease itself. How could you point out the symptoms, diagnosis, prevention... etc... They don't even go to school. It's not like they are sitting in a class, as we had when we were children and teenagers, and were shown videos, given pamphlets, lectured and so forth.
Yeah, that part irked me the wrong way too. Again, the problem is not with the "people" themselves. They can only go by what they are allowed and it's very little b/c of their gov'ts or lack thereof.
I believe that if someone is going to debate an issue, try to raise a point, he needs to put as much fact as passion into how he presents himself. To me, the passion was undeniable. But, the facts were meshed, and took away from the point that he was trying to make.
I would rather agree with someone who has a vast amount of passion, but can view logically at the same time.
Relish, I absolutely don't put you in the dee-dee-deeeee category, for the record.
I agree with you on your point about education. HOWEVER, is it the job of Americans to educate other countries about this, considering the downhill spiral our own country is on with regards to education and healthcare?
I am not a fan of David Duke by any stretch of the imagination, BTW.
But I do agree with several points on many of his rants.
chef_amy...I have to find a really interesting article about how American government is now very interested in part of Africa, due to them having an untapped oil supply.
We've not cured what ails Darfur, but we're there sniffing around for oil.
I have GOT to find that article.
HOWEVER, it is the job of Americans to educate other countries about this, considering the downhill spiral our own country is on with regards to education and healthcare?
Is that the "try to be a bigger person" type of statement? lol I don't disagree. I think that if people have knowledge they should share it. I'm ALL for that. I just don't think that throwing money at a corrupt gov't is going to help. Send in educators and medical personnel and I can back it up. KWIM?
HOWEVER, it is the job of Americans to educate other countries about this, considering the downhill spiral our own country is on with regards to education and healthcare?
No. It is not our duty, as Americans, to guide and teach other countries, when we have kids dropping out of high school, because they just "don't want to go".
I am a firm believer, that if you have the time, money, and dedication, than by all means, go for it. That is an individual decision, and does not put Americans in 1 category.
It actually gives Americans OPTIONS and choices. Which is one of many things this country stands for and believes in.
See, if you think about a tit-for-tat thing though, it pretty much makes sense about the oil as long as we're fair in how we pay somebody back. If we can trade useful information with somebody who needs it, provide medical assistance and other benefits, as well as pay discounted prices in exchange, why would that be a problem? Other than the greedy warlords, which is why they need to be run out of the countries.
We have problems at home with inflation, esp with gas prices. Unfortunately, the US isn't self-sufficient when it comes to oil, etc. We have to work on that problem as well. I have a problem seeing why it's not fair that we receive some kind of recompense for providing others with humanitarian aid.
No. It is not our duty, as Americans, to guide and teach other countries, when we have kids dropping out of high school, because they just "don't want to go".
I am a firm believer, that if you have the time, money, and dedication, than by all means, go for it. That is an individual decision, and does not put Americans in 1 category.
It actually gives Americans OPTIONS and choices. Which is one of many things this country stands for and believes in.
Relish, yous my hero.
Even if we do take up the Banner of Educating Other Countries, what makes people think the Other Countries will listen?
That's true. You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make him drink. They (in general terms, not any one type of "people") will accept anything you want to give them and never learn, thus needing help later on. That's why I think we should receive some type of "restitution" for our "services".
Chef, do you believe that restitution should be by force and theft, or by other countries GIVING the resources to us.
If another nation came in and stole from us because they aided us in some fashion, would you be so quick to think the same?
Have I ever said anything condoning force or theft in any post I have ever done on ANY page ever? No, I don't believe in that. I think that it should be by MUTUAL AGREEMENT. Like customer service. You want something, I have it, you pay for it. End of story.