Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

IN other news...

who's talking here?

dmc... 9
BlueEyes 4
Nurse_Misty 1
The Original LM 1
Erin Marie 10
Susie Homemaker 16
charlys 2
Mary Katherine Gallagher 2
Maureenie 8
chatty cathy 1
Dreamer 5
Skoocharoo 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Maureenie --- 16 years ago -

Senate to vote on taking up 'don't ask, don't tell' repeal

Washington (CNN) -- The outcome of a key Senate vote Tuesday on whether to begin debate on legislation that includes a repeal of the military's "don't ask, don't tell" policy remains too close to call.

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nevada, needs 60 votes to bring the bill to the floor, and Republicans are threatening a filibuster that would prevent the 59-member Democratic caucus from doing so.

The Republicans appear united against the measure, including some GOP senators who favor lifting the Pentagon's requirement that gays and lesbians keep their sexuality a secret.

In particular, the Republican opponents are upset that Democratic leaders are limiting the debate and could refuse to allow GOP amendments to the broader National Defense Authorization Act that includes the "don't ask, don't tell" provision.

GOP senators also dislike Reid's plan to add an immigration-related provision to the defense bill. Reid wants to tack on a measure that would provide a path to citizenship for students and soldiers who are children of illegal immigrants.

"I am opposed to illegal immigration, and I am deeply disappointed that Washington politicians are playing politics with military funding in order to extend a form of amnesty to certain illegal immigrants," Republican Sen. Scott Brown of Massachusetts said in a statement issued hours ahead of Tuesday's vote.

One of Maine's two moderate Republican senators, Susan Collins, said Tuesday she would join a GOP filibuster unless Reid agrees to open the debate.
Video: Lieberman: 'Don't ask' 'un-American'
Video: Gaga: If you don't like it, go home
Video: Gaga: Senators, repeal 'don't ask'
Video: 'Don't ask, don't tell' on the line
RELATED TOPICS

* Don't Ask, Don't Tell
* Gays in the Military
* Olympia Snowe
* Susan Collins

"I find myself on the horns of a dilemma," Collins said on the Senate floor, explaining that she supported repeal of the "don't ask, don't tell" policy but "cannot vote to proceed to this bill under a situation that is going to shut down debate and preclude Republican amendments."

She called for an agreement that guarantees "full and open debate" with senators allowed to file amendments, adding: "Now is not the time to play politics simply because an election is looming in a few weeks."

In response, Sen. Carl Levin, the Michigan Democrat who is chairman of the Armed Services Committee, said Reid had assured the Senate that the bill would be open to debate and amendments once it reaches the Senate floor.

"Until you get to the bill, you're not in a position to work out such agreements" on debating amendments, Levin said.

Reid has said he wants the Senate to take up the bill now, but no final vote would take place until after the November 2 congressional elections.

However, Republicans want an agreement in place before the vote to open debate that ensures they can propose their desired amendments.

Reid's spokesman indicated Tuesday that the majority leader would not budge on his plan.

"Today's vote isn't about an arcane Senate procedure," said the spokesman, Jim Manley. "It's about a GOP pattern of obstructing debate on policies important to the American people."

In a statement Tuesday, Reid defended his plan to add the immigration provision -- called the DREAM Act -- to the defense bill, telling critics including GOP Sen. John McCain of Arizona that the intent is to make sure that anyone qualified to serve in the military can do so.

"The Defense Department's strategic plan explicitly states that passage of the DREAM Act is critical to helping the military shape and maintain a mission-ready all volunteer force," Reid's statement said.

"Sen. McCain should know better than anyone that patriots who step up to serve our grateful nation should be offered a path to citizenship, and that anyone who volunteers to serve should be welcomed regardless of their sexual orientation," the statement continued.

Without the support of Collins and Maine's other Republican senator, Olympia Snowe, Democrats are unlikely to muster the 60 votes needed to proceed with debate on the defense authorization bill. In another blow to Democratic hopes, Republican Sen. George Voinovich of Ohio also said he would join his party's filibuster.

The legislation, which is a broad defense policy bill, would not rescind "don't ask, don't tell" until after the Pentagon completes a review of the repeal's impact on the military. The review is due in December and would serve as the basis for certification by the president, defense secretary and chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff that the military could handle repealing the policy.

On Tuesday, the general nominated to head the Marine Corps told a Senate committee that he believes responses from Marines on repealing the "don't ask, don't tell" policy have been mostly negative so far.

Gen. James Amos said he had heard that at Marine bases and in Marines' responses to an online survey, the feeling "is predominantly negative." He added, however, "I don't know that as a fact."

In written answers to the Senate Armed Services Committee, Amos said he opposes repeal of the "don't ask, don't tell" policy now because it could disrupt cohesion due to "significant change during a period of extended combat operations." At the same time, Amos made clear that he would oversee a repeal if ordered to do so.

"The Marine Corps is probably one of the most faithful services you have in our country," Amos said. "And if the law is changed by Congress and signed by the president of the United States, the Marine Corps will get in step and do it smartly."

At a rally Monday in Maine, pop star Lady Gaga called on both Collins and Snowe to join Democrats in overcoming the expected GOP filibuster attempt. To loud cheers from the crowd, Gaga said she was proposing a new law titled, "If you don't like it, go home," which would remove homophobic straight soldiers from the military instead of gay soldiers.

"If you are not honorable enough to fight without prejudice, go home," she shouted.

Both Snowe and Collins oppose the "don't ask, don't tell" policy, and Collins was the sole Republican vote in the Senate Armed Services Committee in support of getting rid of it.

However, both signaled they would join the filibuster unless Reid changes his approach to the defense authorization act.

Snowe said the Senate should be allowed a full debate on the measure and questioned why the repeal provision is being put forward before the military has completed its review.

"We should all have the opportunity to review that report, which is to be completed on December 1, as we re-evaluate this policy and the implementation of any new changes," Snowe said in a statement.

Many Republicans complain that Congress should not step in until after that military review is completed.

McCain, the top Republican on the Armed Services Committee, said approving a repeal provision before finishing the review process would amount to an insult to military personnel.

"The most fundamental thing we could do to honor the sacrifice of our troops is to take the time to hear their views," McCain said Tuesday.

Defense Secretary Robert Gates and Adm. Mike Mullen, the Joint Chiefs chairman, have said publicly they support repealing "don't ask, don't tell."

The military already has working groups looking at how to implement the change if ordered. The groups are looking at issues such as housing to entitlements and even personal displays of affection. 

Maureenie --- 16 years ago -

So they voted to not even talk about it... Another productive vote in the Senate. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

Yep, I read that earlier. :/ Way to go, Senate. 

dmc... --- 16 years ago -

way.too.much.to.read.

sorry lol

I know the military is still talking about it. Actually, they are still getting groups together to talk about it. Until the military figures out what they want to do, there's not much else that can be done by the Senate, or anyone else. 

Erin Marie --- 16 years ago -

Because people are going to listen to Gaga. LOL 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

I know the military is still talking about it. Actually, they are still getting groups together to talk about it. Until the military figures out what they want to do, there's not much else that can be done by the Senate, or anyone else.

Yep, you're right. I didn't know the military was still talking about it. That's something, at least. 

dmc... --- 16 years ago -

Yep, you're right. I didn't know the military was still talking about it. That's something, at least.

my husband got an email last week or the week before about being on some committee or something. He said he just clicked 'delete'. He doesn't have time to mess with that right now. 

Dreamer --- 16 years ago -

I think they should leave it like it is, Don't Ask, Don't Tell. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

my husband got an email last week or the week before about being on some committee or something. He said he just clicked 'delete'. He doesn't have time to mess with that right now.

Oh yeah, I got a survey in the mail asking what I thought about DADT a few weeks ago. I thougth it was silly that they were asking me, and I tossed it. 

Erin Marie --- 16 years ago -

dh didn't do the survey and he believes in DADT. Lol 

Erin Marie --- 16 years ago -

At least he said he didn't when I asked him. He might've done it since then. :shrug: 

dmc... --- 16 years ago -

Oh yeah, I got a survey in the mail asking what I thought about DADT a few weeks ago. I thougth it was silly that they were asking me, and I tossed it.

they sent surveys out to some spouses, wanting to know if it would affect you to see a same sex couple in housing. Ummmmm, last I checked, it wasn't legal in many states. And about family readiness. Really weird to include spouses, but whatever.
His request was nothing like that, however. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

The surveys are silly. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

they sent surveys out to some spouses, wanting to know if it would affect you to see a same sex couple in housing. Ummmmm, last I checked, it wasn't legal in many states. And about family readiness. Really weird to include spouses, but whatever.
His request was nothing like that, however.


Yeah, I figured whatever they were asking your DH about was way different.

I think they just need to change policies with DADT. I don't think they should be able to kick someone out for being suspected of being gay. I read an article about an Air Force woman who got discharged for being gay, and was 3 years away from retirement. That sucks. 

dmc... --- 16 years ago -

Unless they are actually going to listen to what is written on the surveys, they are a big fat waste of time and money. 

Erin Marie --- 16 years ago -

LOL, I wouldn't care seeing same sex couples. It's different when you're actually IN the military though. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

Unless they are actually going to listen to what is written on the surveys, they are a big fat waste of time and money.

Agreed.
I thought it was dumb to ask spouses anyway. 

Erin Marie --- 16 years ago -

Unless they are actually going to listen to what is written on the surveys, they are a big fat waste of time and money.

For real. No one cares. 

Dreamer --- 16 years ago -

They should ask everyone in the US for a real survey as to how many are for or against it. 

Maureenie --- 16 years ago -

Yeah I didn't understand the spouse survey either...

My husband has a skewed view of it but I understand where he is coming from. I'm just glad he isn't so homophobic like he used to be. He has come so far! 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

They should ask everyone in the US for a real survey as to how many are for or against it.

Why? That's dumb.

I think the military needs to re-evaluate the whole policy and adjust it where necessary. 

Erin Marie --- 16 years ago -

My husband doesn't want it changed at all. It's been going perfectly fine, there is no need to fark it up. But he isn't all freaked out where he's going to get out of the military or anything. 

Dreamer --- 16 years ago -

I don't think that because there are people who do not approve of homosexuality that they are homophobic. They are probably just religious and it's not an acceptable lifestyle to them. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

My DH doesn't really care. *shrugs* I just think, like I said earlier, they shouldn't be able to kick people out for being gay. It doesn't affect their ability to do their job. 

Erin Marie --- 16 years ago -

They are probably just religious and it's not an acceptable lifestyle to them.

There's definitely a lot of those. 

dmc... --- 16 years ago -

Yeah, I figured whatever they were asking your DH about was way different.

it irritates him because it's like since he's stationed up here, he has no job to do. So he can do all the MC stuff they can task him with, and still get his job done. Yeah, ok.

He didn't want to be on it. He doesn't want it repealed. Not because of anything to do with the gay issues. He just doesn't think ANY branch of the military is ready for gays serving openly. He also doesn't feel that the MC barracks will work out, not how they are currently set up. 

Maureenie --- 16 years ago -

I don't see what the opinions are of the US population. Ones opinion shouldn't be considered when it comes to anothers rights. 

Erin Marie --- 16 years ago -

Opinions regarding DADT should only be the opinions from those in the military. I don't give a crap what others think. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

I don't see what the opinions are of the US population. Ones opinion shouldn't be considered when it comes to anothers rights.

ITA.

He didn't want to be on it. He doesn't want it repealed. Not because of anything to do with the gay issues. He just doesn't think ANY branch of the military is ready for gays serving openly. He also doesn't feel that the MC barracks will work out, not how they are currently set up.

That makes sense. That's my feeling too, that the military would need to make a lot of changes before gays could serve openly. It sucks, but that's the way it is right now. 

charlys --- 16 years ago -

Oh crap, I have to mail that survey in still.

They already have a precedent for getting a gay couple into housing....they will just add the "partner" as a "dependant", just like they would if Mom had to come and live with you. So they can do it, even if Gay marriage isn't legal. I think if they are going to do it that way, the fed should just own up and make it legal and take the flak (but as we all know NO politician is going to do something that risky and will get him voted OUT)

Edit to add---And all the questions about family readiness, what does anyone being Gay and serving openly have to do with my family's readiness for deployments, military life etc? 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground