Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Gated communities

who's talking here?

dmc... 5
ndnjumpingbean 1
dbal 7
billiejean Doop 1
Mermaid 3
Erin Marie 1
ncnative 1
charlys 3
♥LifeIsLove♥ 1
*~Rebel Princess~* 1
Maureenie 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

dbal --- 16 years ago -

Would you rather live in a gated community? If so, why? 

charlys --- 16 years ago -

Been there, done that

A) No solicitors
B) Usually more and better amenities, pools, clubs etc.
C) More of a sense of community as people get to know their neighbors at HOA meetings and planned events.

Downsides are almost always a strict HOA but even ungated communities can have those. 

dbal --- 16 years ago -

Any neighborhood can have amenities. Most of the gated neighborhoods around where I'm at right now are just neighborhoods that have a gate for access. 

dmc... --- 16 years ago -

The one we lived in up here was actually pretty great. If they were ALL like that, I might actually prefer to live in one. I just know they aren't, therefore I'd prefer not to, simply because I prefer no HOA at all. 

dbal --- 16 years ago -

The reason I was asking is some of the neighbors in my parent's neighborhood want to have their street gated. More people don't want it done than do.
Arguments against are:
*maintenance of the street is no longer the city, it's all homeowners expense resulting in HOA being higher.
* false sense of security- the mailman, ups, fedex and any other delivery person will have code. As well as anyone in the neighborhood's friends, their kids friends, etc... 

*~Rebel Princess~* --- 16 years ago -

I lived in a gated community in CA. I loved it because it was pricey and there wasn't any riffraff to deal with. 

dmc... --- 16 years ago -

it's all homeowners expense resulting in HOA being higher.


How much do they pay in HOA fees now? How large is the community?

Sorry, when you were talking gated, I was thinking a Gate Guard, not just a gate. I don't think I'd even look at a place that simply had a gate.

We still had solicitors even with a gate guard. All they have to do is be doing business with one of your neighbors and *BAM* they are in your neighborhood banging on your door trying to cut your trees or sell you windows. 

Erin Marie --- 16 years ago -

I've never lived in one. Only one similar that I've lived in is base housing.

I can see why living in a gated community would be better than a regular neighborhood. It's common sense. 

Mermaid --- 16 years ago -

We live in a gated community & I love it. BUT gates only keep out honest people. There's a walk-thru just around the corner from the gate & the gates can easily be rammed by a vehicle. It does provide a false sense of security to a lot of people.

Our community isn't manned yet because it's still a new subdivision with a lot of construction going on. Once it's 75% completed is when they'll hire guards; otherwise dues would be insane. Right now our dues are reasonable & include all lawn maintenance, alarm, clubhouse, gym, pool, tennis courts, sprinkler system (yay no more insane water bill in the summer!), cable & bug service. 

dbal --- 16 years ago -

DMC , it's not that big of a neighborhood. Maybe around 50 houses. Their HOA is only around $200 so it's not bad. The gate would cost around $20,000 to put in and that's just the gate, not a fence around the neighborhood. All a gate is going to do is keep cars from coming in, won't stop foot traffic. 

billiejean Doop --- 16 years ago -

I wouldn't. I can live in just as safe of a neighborhood anywhere else, and it's MUCH less expensive. The HOA thing would be a drag, but even our "house" (lol, bean! ;) is subjected to the HOA dues and covenants. 

dbal --- 16 years ago -

RP, pricey doesn't necessarily mean better. Riffraff comes in all forms. There are a lot of people with money in the town I am from and there are quite a few of them that are liars, thieves, druggies, etc... They just have money :( 

dbal --- 16 years ago -

 

charlys --- 16 years ago -

I agree with DMC just a gate doesn't offer nay added security, I am used to gates with a guard (HHI, Bluffton and Beaufort in SC have quite a few like that) 

Mermaid --- 16 years ago -

DMC , it's not that big of a neighborhood. Maybe around 50 houses. Their HOA is only around $200 so it's not bad. The gate would cost around $20,000 to put in and that's just the gate, not a fence around the neighborhood. All a gate is going to do is keep cars from coming in, won't stop foot traffic.


They need to figure in the cost of maintenance as well. My sister lives in a 1 street neighborhood that is gated. There are about 30 homes and their HOA dues are almost $3000 a year BECAUSE of the gate. They have 3 small ponds in the middle of the street and a gate - that is it; HOA dues include nothing else.

The yard guys, pizza guys, paper boy, you name it hit it with their vehicles and it breaks the gate.

Our subdivision that we live in is gated, but it's run by LandArc Land Management and they have their own gate guy. He's out here at least twice a week fixing the gates because someone has either gotten impatient or tried to sneak in behind another vehicle & gotten hit. 

dmc... --- 16 years ago -

we didn't pay our HOA dues in our last house (it was a rental, landlord paid them), but even if we did, it would still have been cheaper then what we pay where we are now. The only thing extra we have here is more land and a septic.


If I were going to do a gated community, it would need to be a manned gate with LOTS of amenities. More then just a pool and tennis courts. And it wouldn't be that expensive every month either. 

ncnative --- 16 years ago -

It would be nice to not have non-residents cruising/speeding down your street. I don't thin it would be worth the trouble and expense though. 

ndnjumpingbean --- 16 years ago -

i saw that, doop!!

i wouldn't want a gated community or hoa just because when i buy a house, i want it to be MINE. no one telling me who can visit me, or when to mow my grass, or how many Christmas lights i can put up and leave up til Easter. 

Maureenie --- 16 years ago -

Back home all the apartments have gates. Some are trashey and filled with crime, drugs and all that and some are nice.

And as someone pointed out, people have the codes. I used to deliver pizza when I was younger and I had all the codes for the gated communties. You want pizza? Gimme the code or drive your happy a$$ to the gate. Most people give the code. 

Mermaid --- 16 years ago -

If I were going to do a gated community, it would need to be a manned gate with LOTS of amenities. More then just a pool and tennis courts. And it wouldn't be that expensive every month either.


Yep. Besides what I mentioned above it's got a women's gym, men's gym, huge clubhouse with a giant kitchen, game room, tanning, billiards, card room, lounge, fireplace, big screen tv's. Then there are 4 tennis courts, 2 kid's playgrounds, 7 lakes, bicycle/running path.

Includes all lawn maintenance & landscaping (they do the weeding, mulch, trimming, etc), sprinkler system, bug service, cable, alarm company, newspaper, garbage pick-up. Our HOA dues are about what you would normally pay for lawn service.

I can't wait til it's manned. The sister neighborhood of this one that is for ages 55+ finally got enough residents to be manned a few months ago. The maintenance people were painting the inside of our guard house a couple of weeks ago, so I'm hoping ours will be before the end of this year. 

charlys --- 16 years ago -

That's why we bought our retirement property where there's no HOA, etc and never will be. I can do whatever I want. 

dmc... --- 16 years ago -

where we lived had:

I have never been to all of it, so some I've never seen lol

4 basketball courts
at least 2 tennis courts
stables
2 pools
golf course
marina
club house
restaurant
Inn

I do not know what all the club house has in it, since we only went there 1 time for an event.

They took care of their own roads. We were NEVER snowed in, even when there was still 3'+ of snow out there. Dh couldn't always make it to work, but he could always get out of our neighborhood. lol They salted and plowed the roads, all night long if need be.

They did not do yard work, though, but that was fine since most of the yards were small.

They also paid garbage as far as I know.

HOA dues were only $110 a month. Not that bad at all, considering.

There was also:

I don't even know how many children parks

dog park

running/walking path

daycare center

That's what I can think of now. I know there is a creek, river, and ponds. There was also a park with a nice party area.

24 hour manned gate - you either had a sticker, a pass (that was only good for that year, they changed colors every year) or a name/address of where you were going and they kept a log

Police department
fire department

If you needed 911 help, it was right there in the Harbor. 

♥LifeIsLove♥ --- 16 years ago -

I'd rather live on a private island free of crazies! Lol! 

dbal --- 16 years ago -

They need to figure in the cost of maintenance as well. My sister lives in a 1 street neighborhood that is gated. There are about 30 homes and their HOA dues are almost $3000 a year BECAUSE of the gate. They have 3 small ponds in the middle of the street and a gate - that is it; HOA dues include nothing else.

They already voted against it.
It's not worth the trouble. A lot of people didn't realize that the county stops maintenance on the street once the gate goes up.

Plus as I stated before the code to get in the gate is given to the mailman, UPS, FEDEX, and any other delivery person, neighbors' friends, their childrens' friends and so on. So it's not really that private then. Sure you keep out random people from driving in, but what's stopping anyone from parking somewhere else and walking.
I'm not saying it's all bad, but it's not as great as some people think it is.

**I'm not referring to neighborhoods with lots of amenities, just a regular neighborhood. 

dmc... --- 16 years ago -

there's a neighborhood down the road with one of those arms (like at RR tracks). It's always up. I just really don't see the point in that one, and wonder how much they paid for it. lol 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground