Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Do you think our government is doing as much as it can for victims of PTSD?

who's talking here?

0311Wife 1
PenguinsRule 1
je ne sais quoi♠ 1
♥ 1
FarmerA 3
MacSays_ShutUrCockGarage 1
A-Fish-Called-Wanda 1
Sasha 4
Delfine 1
Babygurl 2
JustMe44 6
Erin Marie 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Do you think our government is doing as much as it can for victims of PTSD?

Yes Vote
 
 16.1% (5)
No Vote
 
 58.1% (18)
Other (Please Explain) Vote
 
 25.8% (8)
je ne sais quoi♠ --- 18 years ago -

Other. I have no idea. 

A-Fish-Called-Wanda --- 18 years ago -

I put "Other". Simply because, I believe there are people who abuse it, and then there are people who don't speak up about it. 

♥ --- 18 years ago -

I said NO! 

Babygurl --- 18 years ago -

I put "Other". Simply because, I believe there are people who abuse it, and then there are people who don't speak up about it. Exactly! 

JustMe44 --- 18 years ago -

There are so many programs in place to assist those who might be suffering from PTSD but the problem is that many will not seek the help. It is so important that they are honest on their post deployment surveys and to seek assistance when needed especially if they are transitioning out of the service. If there is no documentation that you are suffering then VA has nothing to go back to review to assist you and possibly for you to receive additional benefits. It is also important for the spouse to help them indentify that they are having a problem and to seek assistance. 

Erin Marie --- 18 years ago -

Noooooope. 

FarmerA --- 18 years ago -

The first time my brother came home he was honest with his post deployment survey. His command told him that counseling wsa for weak people. He ended up paying out of pocket....I'm not joking. sad. 

JustMe44 --- 18 years ago -

Whoa, is he a Marine? No one should ever have to pay, Military One Source will set you up with 6 free counseling and if they feel someone needs more then they will get a TRICARE referral. Unsat!! 

FarmerA --- 18 years ago -

Whoa, is he a Marine? No one should ever have to pay, Military One Source will set you up with 6 free counseling and if they feel someone needs more then they will get a TRICARE referral. Unsat!! He was a cpl at the time and didn't want his command to know, if they even would have found out. He was afrade of getting in trouble. 

JustMe44 --- 18 years ago -

I am sorry that he had to do that. Is he still in? If so, I hope that he is an advocate for seeking assistance. Although the CMC states that there should be no “weakness” associated with mental health, I know there still is. There are ways around the command to get assistance, people of trust who has the confidentiality status. 

0311Wife --- 18 years ago -

I have no idea. I am not an expert in the field. 

FarmerA --- 18 years ago -

I am sorry that he had to do that. Is he still in? If so, I hope that he is an advocate for seeking assistance. Although the CMC states that there should be no “weakness” associated with mental health, I know there still is. There are ways around the command to get assistance, people of trust who has the confidentiality status. yes he is still in and doing great! it was just a very hard adjustment for him last time. He went over with the first wave when this got REALLY bad. He left when his son was 6 weeks and came home when he was 9 months i think. That period would be hard on anyone, I don't see how you military folks do it! stronger than I am thats for sure! 

JustMe44 --- 18 years ago -

That is great news that he is doing good. Yes, us Military wives are unique in that fashion, sometimes too strong and too proud to ask for help for fear that someone will look at us as weak.. :)) 

Sasha --- 18 years ago -

Although everything correlates or goes full circle ... I think health care should not be 100% mandated by the government. PTSD or any other disorder, disease or sickness should be taken well care of by the medical profession. Doctors hands shouldn’t be tied behind their backs because government dictates when and how to treat for this or that. Ugh, like I mentioned, it is all related but medical treatment should not have anything to do with the government. 

JustMe44 --- 18 years ago -

Sasha, How do you propose the Military to handle this issue? Considering that the Military is a part of the government? I agree to a point on the government dictation of the medical profession, but a lot of the funding comes from the government, so if you are going get their money then you have got to expect them to have a lot of say in what happens. 

Sasha --- 18 years ago -

How do you propose the Military to handle this issue? Eeerr you are really making me ponder on this issue. It's like not being able to register your car until you get car insurance but you can't get insurance until you register your car. You make a great point. In my (odd) thinking ... it shouldn't be a military issue ... it should be a medical issue. Yikes, don't know if in your mind (and in reality) these two can be separated. Maybe there should be an entity formed by medical professionals in this field (neurosurgeons, psychologists, psychiatrists, therapists, counselors) that will convene to find treatment/cure for PTSD and well, this leads us to funding ...eerrr! 

Sasha --- 18 years ago -

Okay, there you go. The program is government funded but the decisions on who clearly needs the medical treatment is up to the doctors based on a medical criteria (check off list if you will) and they are also in charge of weeding out the system abusers. The government ‘blindly’ puts the trust on the medical staff to properly allocate the monetary funds, and yes, a system close to ‘check and balances’ should be instated. 

Babygurl --- 18 years ago -

Okay, there you go. The program is government funded but the decisions on who clearly needs the medical treatment is up to the doctors based on a medical criteria (check off list if you will) and they are also in charge of weeding out the system abusers. The government ‘blindly’ puts the trust on the medical staff to properly allocate the monetary funds, and yes, a system close to ‘check and balances’ should be instated. I really like how you put that. 

Delfine --- 18 years ago -

We all know the government isn't doing enough 

MacSays_ShutUrCockGarage --- 18 years ago -

Not even close. 

PenguinsRule --- 18 years ago -

I dont know if they are. There are a good ammount of people that "claim" to have it. Which makes it harder for the ones that actually do. 

JustMe44 --- 18 years ago -

Okay, there you go. The program is government funded but the decisions on who clearly needs the medical treatment is up to the doctors based on a medical criteria (check off list if you will) and they are also in charge of weeding out the system abusers. The government ‘blindly’ puts the trust on the medical staff to properly allocate the monetary funds, and yes, a system close to ‘check and balances’ should be instated. This does sound good and wished that it could work. Our country has a huge need in those professional fields. We were not prepared for this. Heck during Vietnam there was no treatment for PTSD and the same could be said for desert storm. We have now been in Afghanistan for almost 7 years and over 5 in Iraq and the need for help with TBI and PTSD is through the roof. When there are people who believe that PTSD isn't an issue and think that whoever says they have it are faking or abusing the system, makes it harder for people with need help to come forward. Let me get off my soap box 

Sasha --- 18 years ago -

There are a good ammount of people that "claim" to have it Have you evaluated these individuals yourself? (not being withchy, just curious) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground