Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Ponder this

who's talking here?

mommy2 1
HappyMomma 1
*Jazz* 1
Louise 1
threemonths 1
Lady Maine_iac 1
Hippie_Momma(Sharon) 1
~*Jolene*~ 1
Nicole AKA HoNeY mUsTaRd 4
MeaniePoopyPants 4
shero2k 1
Ivana 4
wifenmom 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Ivana --- 18 years ago -

Do you think it is wrong for a person to qualify for and accept food stamp benefits and have the money to buy a new car and new clothes? I am wondering what everyone's views on this are. 

Nicole AKA HoNeY mUsTaRd --- 18 years ago -

oh good golly 

threemonths --- 18 years ago -

Here we go..... I think it's wrong. 

mommy2 --- 18 years ago -

You could always look up one of the fifty other threads if you want to know what everyone thinks on this. 

~*Jolene*~ --- 18 years ago -

Last year we were on food stamps because we were in really bad shape. We were on them for about 6 months and then were good after that. During that time my girls did grow so I had to buy them some new clothes. I rarely buy myself anything so that didn't happen. I don't think if you buy clothes then you shouldn't be on foodstamps BUT if your comnstantly out shopping and buying crap that isn't necessary then NO I don't think you should have them. 

Nicole AKA HoNeY mUsTaRd --- 18 years ago -

you are asking if it is wrong? Well it is legal obviously BUT I think a person who does this is a person who obviously has their priorities messed up and little to no self respect and sense of personal responsibility. Also I would never want my children to think that is is alright to live off of the US government and tax dollars when they are capable of working and providing for their families. 

Ivana --- 18 years ago -

You could always look up one of the fifty other threads if you want to know what everyone thinks on this. As tempting as that sounds, I think I will pass. I do not want to look through all of those. 

Ivana --- 18 years ago -

if your comnstantly out shopping and buying crap that isn't necessary then NO I don't think you should have them. That is what I was referring to. I do think it is wrong for someone to get assistance from the government yet eat at resturants and go shopping weekly. 

MeaniePoopyPants --- 18 years ago -

Ivana, I actually began my paper on this exact topic (limited to WIC and the military community - i.e. driving expensive SUVs, having luxuries like horses/trucks/trailers, etc.) but because my paper is actually supposed to be a factual essay (and there are no statistics that I was able to find that confirmed the abuse of government assistance) I switched to the transgender pregnant "man." Fun topic! My WIC essay will be my opinion based argument later in the semester. I think it is VERY wrong - morally, ethically, financially, and socially. What are we teaching our youth? That it's OK to use vouchers to feed them, but mom can carry a nice purse? Taxpayers DO bear a portion of the gov. assistance program burden. Also, when someone who either doesn't qualify/morally can't accept WIC has to buy formula, for example, they pay $10/can. The formula manufacturers provide the exact same cans to the gov. for about an 85% discount (too lazy to go get my binder with the exact stats!) Do people need help? ABSOLUTELY. I was on WIC for a few months with my twins. I nursed them and then they were on formula for a few months and then went to milk before they were one. When I was on WIC, truthfully, I was embarrassed and ashamed. I wasn't able to financially provide for my children, even for a short time, and it broke my heart. I felt like a failure as a parent. My family of seven on my husband's E5 pay qualifies for assistance now, but I REFUSE. So, I drive an old ass van (nearing 10 years old, 117,000 miles) we don't eat out all that much (and rarely, if ever, all together!) I don't have the nicest furniture, absolutely don't have designer clothes (think barn attire!) but I AM able to provide my children with extra curricular activities, a roof over their head, food in their bellies, and a warm bed to sleep in. We struggle at times, like many Americans. But we overcome the struggle and don't allow the government to step in and have to feed us. 

Louise --- 18 years ago -

I do think it is wrong for someone to get assistance from the government yet eat at resturants and go shopping weekly. Our tax dollars hard at work...Turn them into welfare fraud.. 

Ivana --- 18 years ago -

Okay, then do you think it is the same as qualifing for financial aid? Would that make a parent less responsible if they took it? What about free and reduced lunches in schools? 

Nicole AKA HoNeY mUsTaRd --- 18 years ago -

Okay, then do you think it is the same as qualifing for financial aid? Which type of financial aid are you referring to? Pell Grant, Scholarships, GI Bill, Loans? All of them but Pell I would say yes bc you either earned them, pay them back, or paid for them. The Pell Grant I have mixed feelings about, and we do qualify for reduced lunches but I didn't fill out the form and pay full price bc we are able to 

MeaniePoopyPants --- 18 years ago -

Ivana, I am not a good person to ask. I qualify for everything, and don't use it. It would help us out so much to use the free lunch program, but we don't. I make my kids lunch. Same thing every day ~ sammich, chips, Little Debbie Crapcake, and the flavored water Minutemaid. Financial aid for what? School? Don't use that either. I have paid for all of my schooling and books out of pocket. I WILL be using my GI benefits though. 

MeaniePoopyPants --- 18 years ago -

But no, I don't think that using financial aid for education is a bad thing. Personally, I think that EVERYONE should be able to obtain a higher education, regardless of financial status. Harvard is on the ball with this one ;) 

Lady Maine_iac --- 18 years ago -

I think if the government can't pay the military more than the poverty level, and someone is on food stamps because of that, and they also are frugal enough to afford all those new things, (if they have all this new stuff, they have a pile of debt, too, you just can't see their credit report), I think they should be able to use those services. The problem is usually too much pride. the people who need it most are too proud to accept it. And there's a problem with that, too. 

Hippie_Momma(Sharon) --- 18 years ago -

Some eating etablishments do take the food stamp card. 

*Jazz* --- 18 years ago -

I agree wholeheartedly with Jules. There is a time and place for assistance. But, please don't abuse. 

MeaniePoopyPants --- 18 years ago -

Jazz, another mom in my class (she has six kids, I think - twins included) wrote her paper on the abuse of assistance too, and she was on it for a time. I agree - time and a place! (That doesn't mean a LIFETIME!) LOL!!! 

Nicole AKA HoNeY mUsTaRd --- 18 years ago -

I think if the government can't pay the military more than the poverty level, and someone is on food stamps because of that, and they also are frugal enough to afford all those new things, (if they have all this new stuff, they have a pile of debt, too, you just can't see their credit report), I think they should be able to use those services. maybe I am just too naive but I think that my husband makes more than enough to support us, and if we ever ABSOLUTELY had to be on food stamps then I would not use my frugality to buy new shiny toys but food so that I could be proud to support my family without assistance. I am not saying that I think it is right that Actresses and Football Players make more than the military bc I think that is bologna, but I also think that those who say they cannot survive on military pay aren't trying hard enough 

HappyMomma --- 18 years ago -

I hate when I used to work at Wal-Mart when I was younger. Each time the food stamps would come out, you'd see people there with all the name brand clothing and fancy jewelry coming to buy their groceries. I was 16 paying taxes to support these people. 

shero2k --- 18 years ago -

WIC destroys lives 

wifenmom --- 18 years ago -

I have read everyones posts and just wanted to put my opinion out there on the matter. I feel military especially should be able to get WIC. They do a lot for this country and dont feel they get as much as they should for there services. If you have a big family and have a hardship or struggle with things i dont see why you wouldnt want to get some help. I would think getting any little bit of help would be less stressful and you shoudlnt be ashamed to ask someone for some help if its a time when you could use it. I do agress with you all, i dont think its right for somone to be in something like WIC and go around in name brand clothes and flashy new things but lots of thrift stores like Goodwill have name brand clothes that look brand new so who is to say where they got the items from. Now lots of women breast feed there babies for months and months which dosnt cost you anything extra but what happens when you are unable to breast feed for whatever reason or have multiples or something. You wanted to but just couldnt, then i feel they should be able to get help with the cost of formula. Like i said its just my opinion, everyone has there reasons for getting on it or not getting on it. I say take any little bit you can just dont abuse the privelage. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground