Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Water Boarding debate

who's talking here?

Meganbcrazy 5
do you really care who i am 2
*Jazz* 1
♠QueenB♠ 1
SodaPopAndRitalin 1
**GO Yanks** 1
MacSays_ShutUrCockGarage 1
okichabbii 1
MsSam 1
MeaniePoopyPants 2
billiejean Doop 1
♥Lady M♥ 1
shero2k 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Meganbcrazy --- 18 years ago -

Water boarding is a technique in which an individual is bound and gagged (or in some cases has a towel draped over their face. The feet are elevated above the head and water is poured onto a person's face. It is supposed to simulate the feeling of being drowned, and can cause the body's gag reflex kick in as if they were actually drowning. It is a very controversial form of torture. Some even say it is not torture, that it is an interrogation process. I am interested on weather you view it as torture or not? And whether you feel as if the US should be allowed to use this in their 'interrogations'?  

♥Lady M♥ --- 18 years ago -

I am interested on weather you view it as torture or not? I say it is. Actually saw this on tv (yes I know it's "tv") during one of the Prison Break Episodes when the guards at Sona were attempting to get information out of the female member of "The Company". Drawing a blank on her name right now. 

MsSam --- 18 years ago -

Since I don't agree with the U.S.'s current "foreign policy", I'm going to go out on a limb and say NO. But, I'm not in the military, I don't know much about interrogation and the techniques, and I really can't present a good argument against it. 

Meganbcrazy --- 18 years ago -

I must add that the Department of Defense has said that they see it as torture, and the Military is not supposed to use it in any interrogations. But the CIA is not a part of the military, and it has been rumored (not confirmed) that they use this. I have also read that it is a productive form, as individuals only last an average of 1-2 minutes before they talk. But it is also said that because it is such a harsh form that many prisoners will talk just to stop the 'interrogation' making the information unreliable. 

MacSays_ShutUrCockGarage --- 18 years ago -

I say it's torture. But I am just over the fence about it. On one hand, we get all up in arms when an American is tortured, so it shouldn't be ok for us to torture anyone. On the other hand, some valuable information could be gathered via certain interrogation methods. Right now, I think the policy is flawed, and until it's changed I can't agree with waterboarding. 

Meganbcrazy --- 18 years ago -

I agree that our policy is flawed. I guess I am on the fence as well. I mean the person is not drowning, and it has been proven effective in certain occasions. But where is the line drawn? I would assume that the person being interrogated is there because he/she has been suspected of having information. But it also has been shown in the past that sometimes it is a case of mistaken identity. 

okichabbii --- 18 years ago -

It was fine and people actually thought it was 'cool' when it was done on the movie G.I. Jane (yes a movie and not a real plot) but we knew it was happening in real life then, before that and its happening now. Why is everyone so caught up on this now??? People are acting like water boarding was just thought of recently, how come its an issue now??? One theory and it covers many of the issues that have been happening lately that are affecting our troops. Many politicians were W.W.II veterans and sadly they are getting out of office and even passing away. Those seats are now filled with 'every other type' of politicians, like the idiotic Mayor of Toledo, Ohio and all the 'crazies' from the city council of Berkeley. 

SodaPopAndRitalin --- 18 years ago -

Her name is Susan. 

Meganbcrazy --- 18 years ago -

I know it is not a new technique, however because of it's recent discussions I made me wonder, where does one draw the line? Actually from what I have read water boarding was used since the Italian inquisitions in the 16th century. So no water boarding is not new. But with new politicians about to be elected, it would be important to reflect on what your own personal views on the subject are. 

♠QueenB♠ --- 18 years ago -

I'm all for waterboarding. Do you remember the reporter that was kidnapped in Pakistan? They sawed his head off alive on camera. The rest of the world doesn't play the game according to our standards. Waterboarding doesn't cause irreversable damage. If it can saved lives, then by all means, do it! Yes, I get the whole "were American's and should set the example" arguement, but waterboarding is hardly torture compared to what our enemies would to do us, if given the chance. 

shero2k --- 18 years ago -

Do what is needed is all I say! I told my neice the other day about being kidnapped, raped, or molested. I told her do what she has to do to survive/live. 

Meganbcrazy --- 18 years ago -

I do remember that reporter. I think that torture isn't completely effective. It has some major flaws and is inhuman. Yet then part of me believes that in SOME circumstances that one life tortured to save possible thousands of other innocent life almost makes it worth it. 

**GO Yanks** --- 18 years ago -

to me torture consists of inflicting large amounts of mental or physical pain, I dont thing water boarding falls in that catagory.. I know I would rather endure that than other forms.. I think that too much light is shone on us as Americans.. If we do it to our special forces and black ops for training, than I dont think it is torture... Putting rules in a WAR is hypocritical to me. I mean come on it is like saying.."hi, I am gonna attempt to shoot and kill you and your friends but oh yeah If you catch me give me a warm bed and 3 meals a day!?!?!?" "oh and We have reason to believe you are hiding a bomb that could take out half our country, and kill millions..please tell us where its at..we'll give you a cookie!!??" War is war............ 

MeaniePoopyPants --- 18 years ago -

LMAO. For those of you who watch Prison Break, I'd rather be waterboarded than endure a battery to the nuts! There's no need to refry the beans! 

*Jazz* --- 18 years ago -

JULES. rofl 

MeaniePoopyPants --- 18 years ago -

LMAO Jazz. Hubby and I couldn't stop laughing our asses off when T-Bag said that. 

do you really care who i am --- 18 years ago -

If hte person who is being interrogated is one who we know , knows somthing that could save millions of inocent lives hells yea cut off both big toes. 

billiejean Doop --- 18 years ago -

festus, evertime i see yer name i thank it says fetus. 

do you really care who i am --- 18 years ago -

sure ok lol 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground