Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: The return of an engagement ring

who's talking here?

HappyMomma 4
PenguinsRule 3
xstupidlovesongx 2
Shannon 1
Hawkeye's♡Honey 2
JustMe :P 1
•°oAshley★ 1
§wt†Áddict 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: The return of an engagement ring

If an engagement is called off, do you think the engagement ring should be returned?

Yes Vote
 
 65.2% (15)
No Vote
 
 34.8% (8)
HappyMomma --- 19 years ago -

If an engagement is called off, do you think the engagement ring should be returned? 

HappyMomma --- 19 years ago -

Just wanted to see other's opinions on it. There's a court case in TN about this. I believe that it should at least be offered, as the ring was given on the thinking of marriage. 

PenguinsRule --- 19 years ago -

depends on who called it off .. if it was the girl who called it off then yeah it should be returned. if he called it off then she should keep it and then pawn the damn thing 

Hawkeye's♡Honey --- 19 years ago -

depends on who called it off .. I agree...that is the usual courtesy, but as far as law goes it varies from state to state. 

HappyMomma --- 19 years ago -

They said that the ring that's in question with the court is a $35,000 ring. What if the calling off was a mutual decision, that they both decided that marriage wasn't for the two of them? 

PenguinsRule --- 19 years ago -

if it was mutual then it should be returned and the guy should either try to return it to the store or sell it to get all if not some of his money back. 

§wt†Áddict --- 19 years ago -

Would you return a gift to a friend if you stopped talking? I say keep the sucker, regardless of who ended the relationship. 

xstupidlovesongx --- 19 years ago -

I Think It Depends On Who Calls It Off. Like If The Girl Calls It Off Then She Should Return The Ring If The Guy Does Then The Girl Should Keep It . 

HappyMomma --- 19 years ago -

Okay, throw another scenario in there. Say, the guy calls off the engagement because the girl was cheating on him and he just found out? 

§wt†Áddict --- 19 years ago -

Sue her...lol. 

xstupidlovesongx --- 19 years ago -

My Friends Sister Got A Ring And Then Cheated On Her Man And Left Him. Afterwords She Tried To Get Half Of His Things Just Cuz They Were Gonna Get Married. She Isnt Very Smart. But If I Was A Guy And Got Cheated On Then Yeah Id Get The Ring Back. 

JustMe :P --- 19 years ago -

I Think It Depends On Who Calls It Off. Like If The Girl Calls It Off Then She Should Return The Ring If The Guy Does Then The Girl Should Keep It I agree completely! 

•°oAshley★ --- 19 years ago -

Ugh my husband went through something like this. His fiance cheated on him while he was in Iraq, she gave the ring back (or I should say, his mom went and got the ring back from her) and then when he got home from Iraq a few months later, Zales wouldn't let him return it because 1)it was past their 90 policy and 2)the slut had gotten it resized Makes me angry because when we met, fell in love, he couldn't afford MY engagement ring because he couldn't sell or exchange the whore's ring for what it was worth. I hated looking at that ring so we tried Craigslist and LYS, but didn't get any good offers. He finally traded it in last week for 1/4 of what it was worth so I could finally have an engagement ring after being married to him for a year! lol. He says it was worth trading it in just to get the bad karma out of the house, but now i'm afraid to wear my new ring because part of it was paid for by the slut's ring, know what I mean? Oh well, had she not been a big trashy whore I would have never met my husband, so I guess I shouldn't complain. It just sucks that guys save up and spend money on a nice ring, and then get stuck with trying to sell it later. That's my rant. lol 

Shannon --- 19 years ago -

every court case that I have seen on tv says the ring has to be returned. 

PenguinsRule --- 19 years ago -

Think It Depends On Who Calls It Off. Like If The Girl Calls It Off Then She Should Return The Ring If The Guy Does Then The Girl Should Keep It i said this in the begining 

Hawkeye's♡Honey --- 19 years ago -

every court case that I have seen on tv says the ring has to be returned. It varies from state to state. Some states say it is a gift and can be kept and others say it is to be returned because it is given with the promise to marry...no marriage no ring. It just depends.....I agree with Fallen though it should depend on whoever breaks it off. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground