Maybe I am dbal. I didn't read that article, but I read the original one about a child who was a boy, but wanted to be a girl who was not let into a girl scout troop.
lol I must be the only one who completely disagrees with allowing a boy into Girl Scouts. Oh well.
I really think the adults make a bigger deal out of it than the children.
I think 7 is way too young to decide if they want to be transgender and it is something the parents push into their heads.
At 7 I thought I was going to be a princess AND drive a train. My 5 year old thinks he is Batman...
This is what children do. I think the parents brought too much attention to it and now the child will end up suffering. Now if he was a teenager and still felt this way, I would be more sensitive to it. At 7, I wouldn't think much of it. I really wouldn't put my child in Girl Scouts at that age either, but I guess it's his/her right?
I really think the adults make a bigger deal out of it than the children.
I disagree. I think your average kid is going to be confused and flabbergasted by this. It won't make sense or seem right to them. That's just what I think though.
No, I mean by labeling the child transgender. They are making a big fuss out of something that may just be a phase. It's hard to judge so young. Sexuality shouldn't be a big thing to a 7 year old.
No, I mean by labeling the child transgender. They are making a big fuss out of something that may just be a phase. It's hard to judge so young. Sexuality shouldn't be a big thing to a 7 year old.
And for arguments sake, if little Tommy decided he didn't want to be Tanisha afterall, then people have just exposed the children involved to stuff they shouldn't even have to think about, especially as a kid. I guess I'm just a little tired of people expecting parents to expose children to adult issues for the sake of being politically correct.
I must be the only one who completely disagrees with allowing a boy into Girl Scouts.
No, I agree with you. Bottom line is that child has a penis and his birth certificate states he is male. Girl Scouts is supposed to be an all female organization.
And Boobsy I agree with you on the fact that a child of 7 years old cannot possibly make a decision like that. My 7 year can barely decide what he wants for breakfast in the morning.
It's not something I would encourage or discourage. I think forcing him into a Girl Scout Troop to prove a point is wrong. I don't know how I feel about him being excluded though. I think it's a little harsh. Then he will feel bad about himself. I really think the parents should not have put him in that position in the first place.
No, I agree with you. Bottom line is that child has a penis and his birth certificate states he is male. Girl Scouts is supposed to be an all female organization.
There are so many organizations that aren't gender specific that the parents could have taken the child to be involved in. Why choose something that is gender specific? I think the parents are pushing the transgender issue.
Wow, as a parent who had a troop with 14 teen girls, wow, I'm not sure what to think.
I do know taking a boy, no matter how he presents himself, along with 13/14 yr old girls on a weekend camping trip probably wouldn't have gone over very well with the girls parents!!
I don't have an issue with the GS allowing a transgendered child in.
I agree with Boobsy about labeling a child too young though. It could just be a phase. I saw part of some talk show where the parents were paying for sexual reassignment surgery for their teens. That's just extremely irresponsible, IMO.
For those of you who are opposed to him being in the Girl Scounts...
Are you against the little girls who sign up for baseball with the "boy" teams or the little girls who sign up for wrestling with the "boy" teams in high school, or the "boy" track teams, etc, etc, etc?
There was a little boy today in my daughter's ballet class, should I have been offended?