We are in the process of buying a home where we are moving to. The home is owned be a real estate agent that happens to work at the same office as my agent. I won't go into all the other dilemas we have had but I would like your opinion on this one.
Today the VA went out to the home to do their appraisal. Another agent that works at the same office (who I think was a listing agent on the home as well) gave the VA appraiser some new comps in the area on the home that we are looking to buy, that she felt equalled the value of the home.
I personally feel that this is a conflict of interest and we are not being properly represented. I paid $350 for a home inspection and the seller got a copy for free! Now the VA goes out there (another $350 fee that is out of my pocket) and an agent who is also a friend of the seller is giving the appraiser her own set of comps.
What is your opinion? I am a little upset about this.
if you have already made an offer, and it's been accepted, I don't really understand what giving a new set of comps for the area would do. Unless they are lower, of course.
This home was SEVERLY overpiced. It was priced about $30,000-$50,000 over the average given the market analysis I received prior to making my offer. The seller has been nickel and diming everything and trying to find ways to stick us. The nagged the life out of my home inspector and complained about how long he was there and her friend gave my VA inspector her own set of comps.
(sorry for the frustration)
I thought that it was a normal thing that they do when selling or renting out houses. They did it when we bought our house and when we rented it out. We used a VA loan to buy our house.
You can get your own comps to see if it is reasonably priced or not...try using the website zillow.com. Type in the street name only and the city or zip you are buying the house in and it should pop up a list of homes that have sold or are on the market and you can make up your own mind about it.
The seller isn't supposed to receive a copy of the appraisal unless you authorize them to see it.
Maybe you can contact the VA and explain the situation and have a new appraiser come out and redo the appraisal without the other people being there?
No. And I will never look at my pups the same way again! I guess I better get a new sticker for my car...mine said bad azz shorthairs. My kid is in private school and could get kicked out for something like that, so I razored the bad azz off! LOL Now I have pubie dogs!!!
No. And I will never look at my pups the same way again! I guess I better get a new sticker for my car...mine said bad azz shorthairs. My kid is in private school and could get kicked out for something like that, so I razored the bad azz off! LOL Now I have pubie dogs!!!
LMAO!!!!! Oh my gosh.. I am so sorry but this is funny! I know I have learned sooooooooo many terms on this site, but I thought since I knew about "shorthairs" everyone else did too! haha!
VA does not do the Appraisal. They use VA approved appraisers. The realtor can GIVE the appraiser all the comps they want, but that does not mean they will use them. The appraiser is required to search for Comparable Properties that are the most similar to the Subject Property, out of sales within a certain set of standards.
It;s usually properties similar to the subject in size, location, appeal, effective age, etc., within three miles of the subject, that have closed within the past six mmonths.
It's not uncommon for an agent to own a property and have their office sell it. As long as everything is at "Arms Length" meaning everyone is dealing from equal bargaining positions.
Zillow.com bases their figures off of tax values. Tax Value and MARKET VALUE are not the same, and tax value is normally not a good indicator of Market Value.
As for your appraisal, the appraisal belongs to the bank. It doesn't matter who pays for it, it belongs to whoever is listed as Client on the Report. In this case VA, Broker, Lender.
Gee, Cookie, it sounds as if you're involved in the business in some way, and actually know what you're talking about, rather than pulling advice out of a hat. Keep that up and you'll upset the natural balance of the LU.
Gee, Cookie, it sounds as if you're involved in the business in some way, and actually know what you're talking about, rather than pulling advice out of a hat. Keep that up and you'll upset the natural balance of the LU.
Oh, I'm sorry. You're right, from now on I'm just gonna kick back and let people get bad advice ;)
You're right, from now on I'm just gonna kick back and let people get bad advice
Much better. Now for your penance.
You will write the following 500 times:
"I promise not to give good advice based on personal knowledge EVER again on the loo."