No specific case, just a general question. I say yes, except in self-defense or by accident. If a twelve year old hits his sister with an axe, I say he gets the chair.
Should a 12 year old be tried as an adult in murder cases? I say yes.
Absolutely not! They don't fully understand the consequence's of the act at that age.
If they do treat them as a adult. Give them the same right's adult's have then. JMO.
I have to disagree with charging them as a adult.
Yes he should be but you know they won't. They will get the least harsh punishment and it makes me sick. The system sucks.
I found out the other day that I used to live in a sick and twisted town (even though psychos are everywhere). When I was in high school (4 years ago) I had this kid in the same grade as me that murdered his 2 sisters and his mom and tried to say someone broke into their house and did it. He eventually got caught and pleaded insanity and now is in a psych ward. Sick f'er should have gotten lethal injection.
A kid that graduated before me molested little boys (god know what he did, I don't want to know) He was supposed to get 14 years but because his rights weren't read to him they cut it 7 years then he was out of jail and on probation by the time he graduated high school. So he was in jail maybe 2 years and 1 of those years wasn't even a solid year. Because he was convicted while in high school as a senior they decided to let him finish school and graduate and any days he had of from school or vacation from school was spent in jail.
Then just a couple days ago there was a house fire. Come to find out the mom, 53 the two sons 20 & 17 and a girlfriend were murdered and the house was set fire. That's all we know right now.
Makes me sick what this world has come to
I would have to say that I think that it is too young to treat them as an adult because of puberty and the changes that it makes in the body. However, if they were 16 then yes. 12 is still very young.
I guess it depends on the circumstances, but, in most cases, I would have to say yes. If he/she KNEW between right an wrong, and most 12 your old kids do.
But, it really would depend on the situation.
I knew this would happen. Except for a select few, LU'ers only like to talk about issues that could potentially affect them. Welfare, marriage, abortion, and LU crazies.
I was wondering why this didn't take off. Who's to say this couldn't affect one of us?
A) Imagine it's YOUR child that is the murderer?
OR
B) Imagine it was a family member that was murdered by said 12 year old.....
What are your opinions now?
It's not that hard to try and imagine yourself in these situations. I know we all have SOME sort of creative imaginations, no? LOL
I like topics like this
It makes you really think. Especially with school shootings and things like that now a days. I'm a mom and I know my kid knows right from wrong. I just could not imagine my kid on death row.
Who's to say this couldn't affect one of us?
I meant in their own minds. People can rarely believe their loved ones are capable of heinous acts, even when faced with irrefutable proof. If it were K that did the killing or got killed, I still support the death penalty. HOWEVER, if K actually killed someone, and I was actually faced with the death of my only child, I might feel differently.
Who's to say this couldn't affect one of us?
I meant in their own minds.
That was more of a rhetorical question--not necessarily directed at you H ;)
I still support the death penalty. HOWEVER, if K actually killed someone, and I was actually faced with the death of my only child, I might feel differently.
I feel the same. When I was typing my hypothetical questions, I started to consider if C was the murderer and how devastated I would be to see him facing the death penalty. Perhaps part of that would be linked to a sense of guilt regarding my parenting...
It is proven that children can be rehabilitated to society after a henious act like murder with a much better chance of working, than an adult. At the age of 12 yrs. old, to me they are still a child. I believe a lot of therapy and also a punishment is due. They would not be walking out on the streets n a year.
However, sexually related crimes involved with murder have the tendency to be repeated over and over again. I do not think anyone, child or adult, once they have committed a sexual crime, can enter back to society without a repeat of that crime.