Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Homosexuality POLL 3

who's talking here?

MrsH 3
*~LittleMissPerfect~* 1
Fulu McVooDoo 9
Krystal in NC 1
Boobsy McNicehiney 1
GardenWitch 2
SusieH 5
chattycathy 4
Champ 5
Meee 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Homosexuality POLL 3

If people are born gay, the cause is scientifically known, AND can be rectified in utero (say with a vitamin or medication) would that be ethical in your opinion? Would you prevent your child from being "born gay"?

Yes I would Vote
 
 43.8% (14)
No I wouldn't Vote
 
 56.2% (18)
chattycathy --- 14 years ago -

Yes, I would. I want my child to have as normal a life as possible. I would hate for my child to endure a lifetime of discrimination and confusion. And I want grandbabies.

While I may not 100% agree with gay marriage( I also don't disagree), I think everyone has a responsibility to treats others with respect regardless of their race, creed, demographics, and sexual orientation. Many people on both sides feel it's okay to discriminate against each other and its wrong. 

Boobsy McNicehiney (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I really don't know, but most likely.

I am all for equality and rights, but when you know something will make it that your child is not the "norm" your opinion changes. I'd rather them be like the majority and not have to face people who would give them a hard time for being different. There are so many things a child could get teased for, if you can control it, why wouldn't you? 

MrsH --- 14 years ago -

Ditto to what CC said.
IF that were the case I would treat it as I would any other birth defect that is treatable in utero. I would want my child to have the most uncomplicated life possible. 

Champ --- 14 years ago -

No, somehow I see this as a fine line if your child ever found out no choice would be right one, but assuming it could be changed in embryo it could be changed when the child or adult was at an age to decide for themselves. 

Fulu McVooDoo (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Suuuure :-) 

Fulu McVooDoo (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

 

GardenWitch --- 14 years ago -

C was able to find a circle of open minded and/or gay friends even in high school. The only bigots she ever encountered that caused problems were there in Jacksonville.

And dh's christian baptist family that say one thing to her but are too embarrassed to even mention meeting her gf on facebook where all their uptight baptist friends might see it ( she brought her partner to dinner when she visited last week.) But that's my beef with them. She's ok with their embarassment. In fact I think she enjoyed putting them on the spot by bringing the gf!

CC, many gay couples have biological kids the same way many infertile couples do. Surrogates, donors or AI are all common practices now. 

Fulu McVooDoo (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

My son is metrosexual. We hope he redirects during puberity though. Lol if not, ill just tell him to check the elton john costume at the door before he visits and no talking with exageration or lisps. Ha ha 

chattycathy --- 14 years ago -

CC, many gay couples have biological kids the same way many infertile couples do. Surrogates, donors or AI are all common practices now.

I'm well-aware. 

Fulu McVooDoo (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Yeah clearly i missed that part Loo. Would i changed the gayness? Yes of course. Make a new poll for aborting gay babyness in utero. Lol j/k 

SusieH --- 14 years ago -

No. It's such a slippery slope, IMO. I don't think anything should be changed in utero unless it's life threatening. I'd never change my child. Can you imagine trying to explain that to your child? He/she would probably feel like they weren't good enough. 

Fulu McVooDoo (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

What is there to explain if it was done in utero? 

Fulu McVooDoo (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

This sounds like a good debate with so-called transgenders as well. 

chattycathy --- 14 years ago -

I think the transgender stuff is bizarre. Gay, I'm okay with, but the rest is kind of like, take it out back and put the freak out of its misery.

Harsh, I know. 

Fulu McVooDoo (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Im over the transgender bullshalarky myself. 

Champ --- 14 years ago -

I think the transgender stuff is bizarre. Gay, I'm okay with, but the rest is kind of like, take it out back and put the freak out of its misery.

Harsh, I know.


I'm very open minded, and "it doesn't affect me, so I shouldn't care".... but

I knew a "man" who went through sex change, boobs, the whoe nine yards (even hair transplanted) and "she" liked women. I was just very huh?! what's the point?

kind of a big subject change 

GardenWitch --- 14 years ago -

At the MOST a child being gay only directly affects you for a few years. Most parents don't even find out until the child is away from the home and has had some freedom to experiment with what makes THEM happy.

There's no horribly expensive medical bills associated with a baby being born gay, (as there are in known birth defects) or any changes to be made to your lifestyle. It's THEIR entire adulthood you would be changing.

Shouldn't that be THEIR choice? 

SusieH --- 14 years ago -

What is there to explain if it was done in utero?

If you had your child's sexual preference changed, you wouldn't discuss it with them?

I don't understand the transgender issue. I've tried and I just don't. I can't imagine feeling like I was born in the wrong body. Eh, as long as they're happy, I suppose.


Shouldn't that be THEIR choice?

I was thinking that, too. 

Fulu McVooDoo (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Gw are you prolife or prochoice? Just curious. 

chattycathy --- 14 years ago -

Did anyone ever watch the transgender surgical center on one of those discovery channels? Very bizarre. I think most of those folks have much deeper issues than being born the wrong sex. 

Fulu McVooDoo (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Not unless I was asked Susie. 

SusieH --- 14 years ago -

if people are born gay and it can be pinpointed and easily corrected it would, by definition, be a deformaty/mutation.

People that say they wouldn't change their baby in that way.....most likely you took prenatal vitamins, colic acid, had the strep test and would have taken the medecine if it was positive etc. Its the same type of theory...giving your child the healthiest start.


I see your line of reasoning, but a 'mutation' that doesn't pose a life threatening risk to the child isn't the same as taking prenatals or folic acid. IMO. If it was a heart defect, or something like that, different story. I probably wouldn't get the test to begin with, if there were one. 

MrsH --- 14 years ago -

Shouldn't that be THEIR choice?

You make so many choices for your children that effect their lives in an effort to do what you think will be best for them. 

Krystal in NC --- 14 years ago -

No I wouldn't. I don't see anything wrong with it. 

Meee --- 14 years ago -

In psychoanalytical psychology there is the following theory:

a boys object of affection is his mother and the girls' is her father. Thats why little girls want to grow up and "marry their dads" (Electra complex) and little boys are over protective of their moms' (Edipo Complex)
It is believed that a little boy learns to be a man from him father (or father figure) ... if his father or father figure abuses, neglects or hurts his mother (the person he loves the most in the world) why would he want to be like him? he would choose (unconsciously) to emulate the person that gives him love and affection--in this case his mother.

It is important, in this school of psychology, to encourage a little boy to be friends with his father and not see him as his "adversary" or rival in competition for his mother's love, affection and attention. How can this be done? simple... encourage father and son time, bonding over a similar interest where there is no competition. ie; if dad does wood work or fishes have him teach his son (or father figure, uncle, grandfather). Sports can often turn into a competition.. have them both try something new TOGETHER. and when your little boy says he is going to marry his momma.. (as heartwarming as it sounds).. tell him you are already married to his daddy (stepfather) or if your not married tell him he will one day meet a wonderful woman and will fall in love and get married.. but that you are his mother). Establish your role as a MOTHER and friend..

Same goes for little girls.. yes it is cute when they say they are going to marry daddy... but inadvertently they are unconsciously turning mommy into a competitor/rival for daddy's affection. This is the reason why many women get along great with their dads and not so great with their moms and why some men seem to be at constant odds with their fathers and get along marvelously with their mothers.

this is just one theory.. like I said, its the Freudian/Jung conception. 

Champ --- 14 years ago -

I'm not a fan of freud he's a bit of a freak. (not related, just wanted to post my opinion of the man.) 

Meee --- 14 years ago -

Champ-- neither am i.. but his theory makes sense. why would u want to grow up and be like someone who has hurt u? or who has hurt the person u have loved the most? 

Meee --- 14 years ago -

LooNasty: not always.. i said one of the theories that TRIES to explain homosexuality. There are many variables to consider, environment, nature vs nurture.

Its pretty common for kids from abusive families to grow up to be abusive. So that pretty much blows that quack talk away.


Not really... if they are alcoholics they are in a "dependant" situation very common of the oral phase.. abusive personalities are in the second stage.. and have not entered the "sexual" stage. 

MrsH --- 14 years ago -

What?

My guess is someone took a semester or two of psychology and thinks she has a clue about why ppl are they way they are...RME. 

Champ --- 14 years ago -


Not really... if they are alcoholics they are in a "dependant" situation very common of the oral phase.. abusive personalities are in the second stage.. and have not entered the "sexual" stage.


What?


pretty much freud is a freak and literally all his theories involve some form of "sex" I mean taking a quick glimpse into his stages of child development leaves most people saying WTF--- of all the "psychologist" out there he's the last one I'd look into as a "reason why someone is homosexual" 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground