Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Who would you say is at fault?

who's talking here?

IMSleepngbty 1
FarmerA 1
dmc21 7
Snatch 8
mrsroboto 1
a3015604uu 1
SusieH 1
Along For The Ride 2
Champ 4
Alias 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Snatch --- 14 years ago -

I was at a Mc Donald's parking lot getting ready to back out. I looked to my right to make sure no other cars were backing out, then looked to my left/rear to make sure no cars were coming in the one-way entrance. It was clear to go...or so I thought. I ended up backing into a car that was going down the wrong way.

So, I understand that I back into the guy. But shouldn't be have some fault in it for going down the wrong way? We're waiting on the insurance to figure it out. 

Alias --- 14 years ago -

Your Fault, U must keep your head like a swivel when backing up, you can make an argument about it and if it is a dueche he ain't going to give you no breathing space, if he a cool cat you should be good... 

FarmerA --- 14 years ago -

You'er at fault. 

Champ --- 14 years ago -

Should have called the cops. I know that makes things a PIA- but they would have probably put the blame on him. The insurance companies will probably just go back and forth, and who knows what would happen.
----------

If I was to vote: I'd say both of you, and each of your insurances should pay out. 

SusieH --- 14 years ago -

If I was to vote: I'd say both of you, and each of your insurances should pay out.

^^that 

mrsroboto --- 14 years ago -

I thought you had to have a police report to file that type of insurance claim in NC? I think that both of you are at fault, but I believe the law will say you are since you hit him. 

Snatch --- 14 years ago -

Should have called the cops. I know that makes things a PIA- but they would have probably put the blame on him. The insurance companies will probably just go back and forth, and who knows what would happen.


I did call the cops and we have a police report. 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

you, the part he was in is basically a thoroughfare and you backed into it.

did you get a police report that states he was going the wrong way? Did he admit he was going the wrong way (if not)? Because if there's no police report, he could change his story and say he wasn't going the wrong way.

Not that that matters, probably.


If you are making a left hand turn and someone goes to pass you and they hit you, it's still your fault. Laws are laws, and that's all they will tell you, no matter how much you argue and no matter how many witnesses you have (in this scenario).
As much as it sucks, it's how it is. 

Snatch --- 14 years ago -

The cop that came out said that the couldn't state fault since it was in a parking lot. He even admitted that he had Alzheimer's, which doesn't make me feel any better either. Plus the entrance had arrows painted on the road and signs showing the entrance and exit.

Either way the cars going to be fixed, I just think it's bullsh*t if no fault is placed on him for going the wrong way! 

Champ --- 14 years ago -

Did either of you receive a ticket? 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

so either you will pay for all the damages or you will split it or pay for your own.

You should check into the no-fault laws of your state, or ask your insurance company.

Was he ticketed for going the wrong way? If so, that might help you.


does your insurance have first accident forgiveness? If this is your first accident? 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Did either of you recieve a ticket?

hee heee great minds and all :) 

Snatch --- 14 years ago -

First accident. No tickets were given because it was in a parking lot. 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

No tickets were given because it was in a parking lot.

that's how it was when my son hit a parked car. ha ha

who do you have insurance through? I know USAA has first accident forgiveness. Know this from experience. ;) 

Champ --- 14 years ago -

I learned something new. I never knew you couldn't get a ticket in a parking lot (for accidents... I assume if I was doing donuts I could?) 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

She doesn't live in NC, and we weren't in NC when my son did it.

But it meant no points on his license, since he didn't get a ticket. 

Snatch --- 14 years ago -

I have GEICO and the guy has Progressive. It just ticks me off. 

Champ --- 14 years ago -

that's how it was when my son hit a parked car. ha ha

I made that mistake once in a parking garage and was a good citizen and left all my insurance information, and I paid for a tiny scrape on the underside of their bumper that they would have never noticed. The insurance inspector even said they couldn't believe they filed. 

Along For The Ride --- 14 years ago -

No tickets were given because it was in a parking lot.

Parking lots are considered private property, so the cops have no legal jurisdiction. That's why no tickets were given.

Since it happened on private property, you are at fault. Even though there were arrows pointing which way to go, they really don't mean anything.

It sucks, but that's how it is... Who know though, maybe you won't be held responsible for his damages. 

Snatch --- 14 years ago -

I've been looking on the internet, and it seems like the decisions vary on cases like this. I'm just hoping I'm not at fault, I've never been in an accident before. But even more, I hope they figure it out soon so I can get my car fixed! 

a3015604uu --- 14 years ago -

The guy that hit you said he had Alzheimers? WOW...my husb had the same
thing happen in an automotive parking
lot. He looked and looked, and some
guy came around the corner, had NO
steering, and they hit. He tried to
blame my husband. Cop said same thing..
he could not determine who was at fault. My husbands insurance company
did not put the blame on him. Also, I
was hit by an 80 year old woman who
slammed into me at a red light. Her
first words were.." I just can't tell
the brake from the gas pedal after this
hip surgery". I told her insurance
agent...and they paid all my medical
bills, plus gave me $5000. And they
cancelled her policy. Be sure to take
pictures if possible, of the arrows
and the entrance and exit. I would
fight his insurance company. You may
get stuck paying your deductible,
but just mention you are 'thinking' of
getting a lawyer...especially since
the driver has Alzheimers, and watch
how fast they settle. And try to
record all you conversations with his
agent if possible. Good luck. 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

the car my son hit, the owner was a complete butt. He tried to say there was way more damage then what there was. I let the adjuster know. lol We had the same insurance carrier.

My son was leaving work and the security guard heard it. He called the Sheriff and he made our son call us. lmbo The Sheriff left the document number, on his card, on the windshield. The guy even tried to say he didn't get any information to be able to file. He filed before he even called us about it. His son had parked in a private lot while he went to the movies.

Oh, and this *ahem* man, looked my husband up on global and called him at work. AYFKM? Our son hit his car, off base, driven by his son. WTH did that have to do with work? Oh yeah, our work number and all our cell numbers were on the card, too.

so yeah, some people are just arseholes. :(

We ended up getting the information from the security guard and calling the guy ourselves. Then he goes on about how he tried to file the claim with USAA, but couldn't because he didn't have the document number. So, he was an idiot, too. 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I would
fight his insurance company. You may
get stuck paying your deductible,


if they find the other guy at fault, they would be reimbursed for the deductible. My husband is a car magnet and we've never been liable for our deductible. 

Snatch --- 14 years ago -

I was looking like crazy, I just wasn't expecting a vehicle to be driving down the wrong way of the parking lot. I had already looked that way a couple times to see if any cars were backing up, and there weren't even any cars close to me so then I started looking towards the entrance. It was off of a interstate so I was making sure no cars were turning in and started backing out and BAM.

The whole situation just sucks. The cop said our insurances would have to fight it out. I just think it's bullsh*t that he was the one not going the right way but it might still be put on me. 

Along For The Ride --- 14 years ago -

I just think it's bullsh*t that he was the one not going the right way but it might still be put on me.

I completely agree with you but unfortunately you'll probably be the one at fault. Like I said in the other post, it was on private property so the arrows painted mean nothing. Those arrows were put there by the business and not DOT (or whoever). Totally sucks!!!! 

IMSleepngbty --- 14 years ago -

Sorry to say I did this, and was at fault. Per the cop: "In NC if you back into someone it is your fault. They have the right of way." I kid you not! 

Snatch --- 14 years ago -

I'm going to be ticked if the other guy is at least PARTIALLY at fault. I don't care if my insurance is the one that covers it all, I'm past that point. I just want him to get some percentage of fault, even if it really means nothing.

But still not word from either insurance company. So we're still just waiting... 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground