Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

metal roof ?

who's talking here?

~lue~ 2
Mermaid 3
Marie88 2
Monkey Manners 6
brandy88512 3
ncnative 3
newbernbears 6
RainMan 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

RainMan --- 15 years ago -

How much you pay ? How many square feet ?
Any companies to avoid, bad experiences ? 

brandy88512 --- 15 years ago -

I don't have one so I can't say but my neighbor got one about 6 months ago...

here is what he told me...

it would cost him 10,000 for a regular roof... with 5 year warranty

it cost him $12,000 for the metal roof with a lifetime warranty x2 meaning if he sells or dies then the next owner would also have a lifetime warranty.

this is for a standard 1600 sq ft ranch style home in Mallard Creek.

it looks nice... 

Monkey Manners --- 15 years ago -

I know someone that does them if you want a reference.

He does a lot of our work on base and for my boss. 

~lue~ --- 15 years ago -

We almost got one but it was over $10,000, so we opted for shingles. Way cheaper, we actually did some of the work ourselves for no where near that price 

ncnative --- 15 years ago -

it would cost him 10,000 for a regular roof... with 5 year warranty

That's insane. It shouldn't be over 5 thousand bucks. 

~lue~ --- 15 years ago -

it would cost him 10,000 for a regular roof... with 5 year warranty

That's insane. It shouldn't be over 5 thousand bucks. 

That's what I thought too. I think we spent less than 2000, but that's with doing some ourselves and hiring someone to help finish 

brandy88512 --- 15 years ago -

they told him they would have to redo some of his supports for a traditional roof...

maybe that was why...
I am not sure... I just repeated what he told me =) 

ncnative --- 15 years ago -

Supports? What? Ha ha, let me guess, it was the metal roofing company that gave him the quote for shingles, right? 

newbernbears --- 15 years ago -

Metal looks silly on most homes, unless you have a farm style house. They push it at you because it's easier and cheaper for the installers and more profit. Many will put it on top of your old shingles, bad plan. Get 35 year dimensional shingles, get them in black........... 

newbernbears --- 15 years ago -

This is a man thing ladies, no offense, ask a lot of dudes first, get a consensus from them, ask carpenters, builders, not dweebs at LOWE's, HOME DEPOT. Metal sucks. 

Monkey Manners --- 15 years ago -

newbernbears, why are you so adamate against metal?

I always thought it was better and lasted longer, does it not? 

Marie88 --- 15 years ago -

I was told metal lasts much longer and it's fine to put over the shingles, it's just added insulation, basically. Plus, I prefer the look of them and not having to replace shingles after every hurricane. We are putting one on our house next year. It's $2,500 for 2,000sq foot home, but that's with a friend of ours doing the labor for cheap. 

ncnative --- 15 years ago -

Well yeah, for 2500 it's a good value. For 12K it's an absolute ripoff. 

Monkey Manners --- 15 years ago -

I was told metal lasts much longer and it's fine to put over the shingles, it's just added insulation, basically. Plus, I prefer the look of them and not having to replace shingles after every hurricane. We are putting one on our house next year. It's $2,500 for 2,000sq foot home, but that's with a friend of ours doing the labor for cheap.



Can I get this friend's # lol 

Mermaid --- 15 years ago -

Metal lasts much longer & is much better in a hurricane than a traditional shingle roof. 

Marie88 --- 15 years ago -

Can I get this friend's # lol 

Sorry! Lol. He is a great guy and a good friend of my husband's so he does work for us for cheap, but he also pushes us to the back burner quite often. When other jobs come up he obviously makes more from them, so we are kind of left hanging sometimes. We had him lay the carpet, hardwood floors, hang drywall, install cabinets, and paint our house and the price was awesome, everything looks great... but it took a LONG time to get it done. 

Monkey Manners --- 15 years ago -

SO Marie, if he does this on the side anyways, does he advertise. I mean if you're not going to give me his info where can I get it from lol 

brandy88512 --- 15 years ago -

Like I said it isn't my roof and I was passing on the information he told me... I don't know where he got the numbers or quotes or who did the work...

just trying to contribute to the conversation 

newbernbears --- 15 years ago -

Metal lasts much longer & is much better in a hurricane than a traditional shingle roof.

LOOKS like DODO on 98% of homes 

newbernbears --- 15 years ago -

newbernbears, why are you so adamate against metal?

Mainly the appearance. Two doctors across the street remodeled their home, did a wonderful job, stuck a silver metal roof on, looks horrible. From a construction viewpoint, all my friends in the business recommend 35 year dimensional asphalt. Guys want to put metal on top of your asphalt shingles without regard to issues you may have with your plywood underneath, this is a big, quick, money making job for roofers. A good, experienced roofer will sell you metal, but if you ask, they will tell you they have asphalt on their homes and overall, more pros than cons to asphalt. Metal roofs look fantastic on farm style homes, but how many farm homes are out there? 

newbernbears --- 15 years ago -

I got a new roof 10 months ago, almost went with metal, but did my homework, asked a lot of pros in the field, not just the guys pushing metal, who can make a good arguement for metal. 

Mermaid --- 15 years ago -

LOOKS like DODO on 98% of homes 


This was my parents home before my dad passed away & mom sold it. It has a metal roof & looks awesome. It's CB construction w/ stucco; which is the majority of FL homes.



 
My inlaws have a FL Keys style of home w/ a metal roof & it looks beautiful too. But I don't have a pic of their house on this netbook.

Homes in FL are mostly being built with either metal roofs or italian barrel tile roofs (what we have) because of their longevity. Shingle roofs are ok, but sustain more damage in areas hit by hurricanes. 

Monkey Manners --- 15 years ago -

I don't think metal roofs look bad at all You just have to pick the right dang color. DUR 

newbernbears --- 15 years ago -

Nice home, but this is NC. Forgive me for wanting to help someone making a big mistake, potentially, I'll stick to things I know more about. Buy whatever you guys want, I'm good if you are good. 

Monkey Manners --- 15 years ago -

oh get the stick outta ur butt, we don't all agree all the time. We are just saying we don't think they look bad, they tend to last longer and whatever else 

Mermaid --- 15 years ago -

Yep. It's all about the color. There are plenty of vinyl sided homes in the center of the state that have metal roofs and most look really good. I do agree that it looks like crud if you pick the wrong color but functionality, safety & how long they last outweighs a poor color choice to me any day. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground