I showed this movie to my students today. I think they understand why I used to get mad at them for not pledging the flag or at least being reverent during the Pledge. It's sad that all the area schools were open on Memorial Day (MOnday).
My friend in the next classroom was in the front office last Friday and we were about to do the Pledge. There was a parent there and my friend asked her if she was going to do the Pledge. She said she had bad knees and proceeded to text during the Texas Pledge and moment of silence. My friend told her "my son is a Marine and he'd appreciate it if you'd stand." The parent said "whatever". UGH.
What if she really had bad knees? I mean she should have at least put her phone down though. I'd have to admit though if someone said that to me about the whole Marine thing I'd probably say something like, "I appreciate his service but do you wanna cookie?" It annoys me when that gets thrown around. goes for any situation though, Cop, Firefighter, Garbage man etc.
I'd have to admit though if someone said that to me about the whole Marine thing I'd probably say something like, "I appreciate his service but do you wanna cookie?" It annoys me when that gets thrown around. goes for any situation though, Cop, Firefighter, Garbage man etc.
I agree. :/
I don't say the Pledge, but I do stand to be respectful.
I don't believe using a movie like Taking Chance has anything to do with saying the pledge. Rote memorization and recitation has nothing to do with being a good citizen or having reverence for this country's fallen.
My point in showing the movie was to show them that people paid the ultimate price for them to even be in school. I was tying it in with Memorial Day as well. I couldn't show it Monday because of finals. Ironic thing is our school is named after a living veteran who volunteers at our school everyday. I'm sure it's immaturity. You're right about being good citizens and such. As teachers, we have our hands full because we have to teach them character ed too. Unfortunately, many times it's not taught at home.
There needs to be a list and if you don't do strictly everything on that list to the T, then you're un-American and you shall be stoned to death by those more patriotic than you.
The extreme patriotism and all this kind of crap in this country drives me crazy. Its ok to have it, but give it up already. Its ok if others aren't the same as you. Its entirely possible to be patriotic and feel a sense of pride and loyalty to your country without ramming it down each others throats every 3 seconds.
My husband is in the military and I'm offended. lol. Whatever.
Nope. I was raised Jehovah's Witness, and went to church there up til I was 15. I did the same thing I do now, just stand with my hands at my side.
REALLY? You were raised a witness? Were both your parents that? Did you not celebrate holidays? Are you that now? How has being raised a witnessed affected your outlook and life now?
My point in showing the movie was to show them that people paid the ultimate price for them to even be in school.
I don't really believe in all that when people say it. People died possibly protecting over all safety, but noit for the right to go to school or freedom of speech or any of that other stuff. That was all handled a LOOOOONG time ago. It's not like if the wars in Iraq and the stain didn't happen we would be all comminist and our kids wouldn't get educated.
There needs to be a list and if you don't do strictly everything on that list to the T, then you're un-American and you shall be stoned to death by those more patriotic than you.
The extreme patriotism and all this kind of crap in this country drives me crazy. Its ok to have it, but give it up already. Its ok if others aren't the same as you. Its entirely possible to be patriotic and feel a sense of pride and loyalty to your country without ramming it down each others throats every 3 seconds.
Eh. Whatever. It is pretty effed up to live in a country and reap all the benefits of being born here and then to pretty much spit on it.
I do understand NOT pledging the flag for religious reasons. Technically it's worshiping a false idol which is a sin.
What if you want your kids to understand what they are saying instead of just throwing out words? I don't encourage my older kids to say the pledge. They are nine and seven. How can they pledge allegiance to anything? It's almost like brainwashing.
REALLY? You were raised a witness? Were both your parents that? Did you not celebrate holidays? Are you that now? How has being raised a witnessed affected your outlook and life now?
Yep, I was. My mom and sister are Witnesses, my dad isn't. He goes to church with her on Sunday though. My mom started going to the church when I was 6 or 7. The only holiday we celebrated was Thanksgiving, my dad refused to give that one up. He still always gave me a present on my birthday, too, we just didn't have a party or anything.
The people who go to that church are honestly the nicest, most generous, people I've ever met. I think their religion is wacky, but other than that, they're okay. It felt like it took me forever to get their teachings out of my head though. I was still struggling with that when DH and I got married, and I hadn't been to church there in 4 years. A lot of their beliefs are just out there.
I did a lot of research on other religions, Judaism, Catholicism, etc., to see if one 'fit', and none really did. I consider myself a secular humanist, it's the closest to what I believe.
What if you want your kids to understand what they are saying instead of just throwing out words? I don't encourage my older kids to say the pledge. They are nine and seven. How can they pledge allegiance to anything? It's almost like brainwashing.
The extreme patriotism and all this kind of crap in this country drives me crazy. Its ok to have it, but give it up already. Its ok if others aren't the same as you. Its entirely possible to be patriotic and feel a sense of pride and loyalty to your country without ramming it down each others throats every 3 seconds.
Yes, but children who are barely 13/14 shouldn't be that cynical yet!
Yes, but children who are barely 13/14 shouldn't be that cynical yet!
But it doesn't matter if anyone says the pledge though. I think people put too much weight in things like that. I think there is an automatic sense of allegiance by birth and experience. Reciting mindless words won't ever provide that. So why ram it? Who cares? Allegience is already there.