I am having a convo with some peeps about something one of them read. Here is the conversation: What is your opinion?
What was posted: Not to start a whole religious debate but..... I just found out that BC for Historical Finds and so fourth is being changed to CE.(Christian Era) Why??? Because of so many that do not believe in God or Jesus, okay I completely support freedom to choose to believe in whatever you want, but after all of these years....WOW!!!
No. Not at all. I mean think about it. If this guy Jesus had basic ability to heal, not with "magic" or faith or anything like that but with primitive medicines ect he could easily pass a a divine being.
Here was the convo that took place (summary below):
PERSON A: I do{n't} understand what you are saying?
PERSON B: What will they do reprint every book that refers to BC and change it to CE just like Pluto is no longer a planet, how has that been going?? How many planets do we have in our solar system??? The common person probably doesn't even know how to respond any more.
ME: Christian Era wouldn't be accurate though because it was before Christ and therefore can not be Christian. It could be pre-Christian era but no the Christian Era. Christ would have had to be born for that.
PERSON A: so they are wanting to change BC ( before Christ) to. CE? what does CE even mean?
ME: Christian Era
PERSON B: yeah
PERSON B: Thank you very much, my son and I were just arguing that!
PERSON B: Makes no flipping sense!
PERSON B: I was wondering if anyone else was going to catch onto that! LOL
PERSON A: They are doing it to take the word 'Christ' out of everything.
PERSON A: It's happening alot, not just with this, but they are changing our (American) history in books, leaving huge, important chunks out. Its awful. My brother and his wife are home-schooling their boys because of stuff like this.
PERSON B: Well at least they were trying to keep it as Christian Era, but as Maureen pointed out it "wouldn't be accurate though because it was before Christ and therefore can not be Christian. It could be pre-Christian era but no the Christian Era. Christ would have had to be born for that." So they are also considering calling it the Common Era. LOL
ME: No that doesnt make since because they are still saying that is a CHRISTian Era. That has Christ in it and still points to a predominantly Christian world which it wasn't. But I have an uncommon view with text books and stuff like that. I think religion should be kept out of school 100% UNLESS they are going to teach all beliefs.
PERSON A: Yes, you make a good point, it cannot be the Christian Era if Christ has not been here yet. He is kind of important to all of that. Is this for Cullans class or what? Is he arguing with you about it
PERSON B: I mean the fact that they were keeping Christ in it and not taking it out entirely, I know that it makes no sense.
PERSON A: Well, I understand your points of view, but they are wrong to change BC to CE
PERSON B: No we were arguing the article we came upon, we were like how stupis are these people. So, I guess you can say we were arguing with an article. LOL
PERSON B: Just like we came upon an article I just posted about us having nine planets again.
PERSON A: Well thats just fine. If something promotes a good discussion over something, thats always good.
PERSON B: It infuriates me that people that are supposed to be so smart are so stupid at the same time. How could you refer to it as the Christian Era if it refers to Before Christ. LOL
ME: Wait I am wrong. I dont know why they call it before Christ because some was before Christ and some was during his life but AD refers to after death so in conclusion it's all freakin confusing.
PERSON A: And its the influence of our society that is in decline and more and more people don't believe in God, plus the liberal side is helping the situation also
PERSON B: What??? So we are wrong?? BC is during his life? HAHAHA Well don't I feel dumb!
ME: BC is both during and before. BC dates all the way back to prehistoric times
PERSON B: WOW, so then CE would be correct.
PERSON A: BC means before Christ came to earth to save us from our sins. Christian Era to me, dismisses all of that difference and just lumps it all together. There are difference
PERSON B: i guess your never too old to learn something new right
ME: No CE wouldn't be totally accurate either. BC although said "before Christ" refers to any time before his death. We have time measured in BC and AD nothing more. So there would either have to be yet a third measure to determine the time Christ was actually alive or no matter what, CE and BC are both inaccurate. CE would be inaccurate both because it leads one to believe that the world was predominatly Christian which is false. IN addition, Christ wasn't alive the entire time so it's still not right.
PERSON A: He was only dead for 3 days before he rose from the dead. For me it will always be BC and AD. I don't like this CE business. They start by changing this stuff, then they will start messing with our religions and on and on and on
ME: Yes, I understand he was only dead for 3 days but AD literally means after death so his resurrection is irrelevant to measuring time...
lol, I am so confused. Where did they read this nonsense?
It was on my friend FB.
Basically, the one chick is saying how so much of the Christian religion is being taken out of everything now and it's wrong for them to change BC to remove "Christ" from it.
I was saying that 1) neither BC nor CE (Christian Era) are an accurate representation of that time and they arent really taking Christ out if it still says Christ.
I don't really believe in God like he's supposed to be some spirit floating around somewhere and just decided to create everything one week? Seems like a bit much.
I always heard it as Common Era and Before Common Era. I don't think it's a new thing.
I'm reading and it's not. I have never heard it that way but I grew up in Texas in a religious community.
Also AD doesnt mean after death like I was taught it means anno Domini which means "in the year of the Lord" representing the time from when Christ was born. I never knew that.
Not that I care other than to be educated about it. I think it should be BCE and CE.
For the record, I think Jesus was a carpenter and an all around "nice" guy. He didn't turn water into wine, feed the masses, or walk on water. Oh no, he didn't.
WOW so do any of you believe the Bible? A lot of the women here do, but they must be busy right now.
I don't. I think it was a man made device used to keep other men in line and while some of the lessons are good, I don't believe the doom and gloom of it all.
I believe in God and Jesus... I dont jump down peoples throats and tell them that they are going to hell....but I know what i believe and i know that Im going to Heaven when I die.
TL;DR, but I can tell you that the "new" indicators for time are CE and BCE, which stand for COMMON ERA and BEFORE COMMON ERA. It's a way to get RID of the Christian connotations associated with "Before Christ" and "Anno Domini" (year of our Lord).
I don't think they should change it. It is part of religious history. I guess they are trying to be more politically correct. I know I wont switch, BC (Before Christ)/AD (Anno Domini) is what I'll continue to use.