Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

I highly doubt this will pass but...

who's talking here?

dbal 2
Susie Homemaker 2
CivilianWife 1
Mary Katherine Gallagher 1
Maureenie 2
Sjay 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

dbal --- 15 years ago -

WTF?

There are a bunch of articles on this.
Here is the proposed law. 

Sjay --- 15 years ago -

As Phillips points out, the law also basically radically redefines personhood back to the zygote stage. So remember, in America, the optimal way of exercising your legal rights as a "person," it is best that you go straight from the womb to being a multimillion dollar, rent-seeking corporation.

(Just to review, the way this game is played is that a legislator will conceive of an absolutely insane anti-woman law, stoke outrage, then make a big show of relenting on the crazy part of the law in order to get what they want -- making abortion illegal -- enacted. They will then aver that this is the result of "negotiations" in which "all sides" have been "heard out" resulting in a "compromise.") 

Susie Homemaker --- 15 years ago -

South Dakota is trying to pass something similar. Stupid. 

Mary Katherine Gallagher --- 15 years ago -

The thing that makes me highly uncomfortable with bills like this has nothing to do with abortion, actually but more with valuing the life of an embryo at the same level or greater than the mother carrying it. If an unborn child is considered a person, women who choose to VBAC or have homebirths or go against any of the standard entrenched obstetrical hogwash lose a lot of foothold legally. Unintended consequences = doctors making decisions for patients and court ordered cesareans. 

Maureenie --- 15 years ago -

I'm not understanding how it criminalizes miscarriage. Or is it saying its a crime to have a miscarriage and not try to "save" the baby? Do they really think that a 15week fetus is capable of baing saved? I saw it. Its gonee by the time it is expelled. what absurdity. 

Sjay --- 15 years ago -

So long as you don't "cause" the miscarriage:

'Prenatal murder' means the intentional removal of a fetus from a woman with an intention other than to produce a live birth or to remove a dead fetus; provided, however, that if a physician makes a medically justified effort to save the lives of both the mother and the fetus and the fetus does not survive, such action shall not be prenatal murder. Such term does not include a naturally occurring expulsion of a fetus known medically as a 'spontaneous abortion' and popularly as a 'miscarriage' so long as there is no human involvement whatsoever in the causation of such event. 

Susie Homemaker --- 15 years ago -

The thing that makes me highly uncomfortable with bills like this has nothing to do with abortion, actually but more with valuing the life of an embryo at the same level or greater than the mother carrying it.

Ditto.
Add this to the stuff going on with Planned Parenthood, and I'm getting nervous. 

Maureenie --- 15 years ago -

So my question now is, how do they determine if you caused the miscarriage or not? I fixed a car 2 days before I had mine. I fixed the serpentine belt which require putting force on one of the pullys to get the belt on there. It may have caused it. Or the stress of having the father in jail right before I found out I was pregnant ccould have done it. or it could have been devine interference bc I wasn't ready for another one in the retarded position I was in at the time. OR It could have been that something just wasn't right and my body knew that so it terminated the pregnancy. Either way, looking at the fetus isn't going to determine whose "fault" it was or what caused it. Ridiculous. 

Sjay --- 15 years ago -

So my question now is, how do they determine if you caused the miscarriage or not? I fixed a car 2 days before I had mine. I fixed the serpentine belt which require putting force on one of the pullys to get the belt on there. It may have caused it. Or the stress of having the father in jail right before I found out I was pregnant ccould have done it. or it could have been devine interference bc I wasn't ready for another one in the retarded position I was in at the time. OR It could have been that something just wasn't right and my body knew that so it terminated the pregnancy. Either way, looking at the fetus isn't going to determine whose "fault" it was or what caused it. Ridiculous. 



Murderer! To the guillotine!

JK, that is why it is ridic. 

CivilianWife --- 15 years ago -

It may have caused it. Or the stress of having the father in jail right before I found out I was pregnant ccould have done it. or it could have been devine interference bc I wasn't ready for another one in the retarded position I was in at the time. OR It could have been that something just wasn't right and my body knew that so it terminated the pregnancy.

Exactly! I had a sb @ 28 weeks and even with an autopsy, they could only narrow it down so much to what the actual cause of death was.

I think this bill should only apply to situations where there was direct trauma (physical or otherwise) caused to the mother-to-be by the "criminal", but there's a lot of stipulation(sp?) that can go on that way as well, so I dunno. My head hurts and I'm tired. That's my 2 cents on the subject. 

dbal --- 15 years ago -

So my question now is, how do they determine if you caused the miscarriage or not?


From what I understand they will investigate and if they find that it was anything other than a spontaneous miscarriage, you will be charged.

I'm almost positive this will not pass, it's too ridiculous. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground