Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Oh realllly!?

who's talking here?

Someone 2
Muse Heather 1
The Original LM 4
Snatch 1
Erin Marie 6
Susie Homemaker 2
QuickBlubbersMcGee 6
CivilianWife 1
Mary Katherine Gallagher 8
Maureenie 1
HiImKia 2
chatty cathy 3
Skoocharoo 2
Dinyell 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Erin Marie --- 15 years ago -

http://health.yahoo.net/articles/parenting/tv-watching-bad-babies-brains

Babies who watch TV are more likely to have delayed cognitive development and language at 14 months, especially if they're watching programs intended for adults and older children. We probably knew that 24 and Grey's Anatomy don't really qualify as educational content, but it's surprising that TV-watching made a difference at such a tender age.

Babies who watched 60 minutes of TV daily had developmental scores one-third lower at 14 months than babies who weren't watching that much TV. Though their developmental scores were still in the normal range, the discrepancy may be due to the fact that when kids and parents are watching TV, they're missing out on talking, playing, and interactions that are essential to learning and development.

This new study, which appeared in the Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine, followed 259 lower-income families in New York, most of whom spoke Spanish as their primary language at home. Other studies examining higher-income families have also come to the same conclusion: TV watching not only isn't educational, but it seems to stunt babies' development.

But what about "good" TV, like Sesame Street? The researchers didn't find any pluses or minuses when compared to non-educational programs designed for small children, like SpongeBob SquarePants. Earlier research by some of the same scientists, most of whom are at New York University School of Medicine-Bellevue Hospital Center, has found that parents whose children watch non-educational TV programs like Spongebob SquarePants spend less time reading to their children or teaching them.

At this point, parents reading this are probably saying D'oh! TV is so often a parent's good friend, keeping kids happily occupied so the grownups can cook dinner, answer the phone, or take a shower. But clearly that electronic babysitter is not an educational aid.

The bottom line: This latest study adds more fuel to a recommendation from the American Academy of Pediatrics that babies under age 2 watch no TV at all. If you've just got to watch Dexter, it's best to make sure the tots are fast asleep. 

Skoocharoo --- 15 years ago -

Oh well, they really don't come with manuals, lol. 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 15 years ago -

So dumb. So, so, so dumb! They've been saying this since JoJo was born.

Granted, JoJo did have a speech problem, but he was WAY beyond his age (and still is) for EVERYTHING else. And guess what? We watched the hell out of some TV! He was all about his Sesame Street, Barney and other stuff as an INFANT, and then Noggin as a toddler/PreKer. When they weren't on it was the news, GH, and sometimes a little Lost and Judge Mathis. Just sayin :)

JoJo's fav thing to play at 2 was "weather man" :) 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 15 years ago -

Oh well, they really don't come with manuals, lol.

Even if they did you know that shart would be recalled every year because most likely they'd be written in China with mega super lead and "keep the American fleshlings down" ink! :P 

Erin Marie --- 15 years ago -

K's doctor encourages her to watch some TV. LOL, she loooves The Wiggles and she dances with them. I think that article is b-o-l-o-g-n-a! And I think these "experts" overreact about a lot of things. 

Susie Homemaker --- 15 years ago -

Eh, I think a little TV won't hurt. As long as they're not in front of it for hours. 

Maureenie --- 15 years ago -

Well cadence watches and has watched a ton of nick jr and disney. She does have delayed speech BUT a lot of the shows are helping her now that we have been working with her so much. 

Snatch --- 15 years ago -

I always turn the TV on NickJr when K gets up, but she doesn't hardly ever WATCH it. Sometimes it might get her attention for a few minutes, but she never just sits and watches it. I would LOVE IT if she did though. 

Erin Marie --- 15 years ago -

Lol, Shelby. My cousin posted that article on FB and I actually told her that it might be true if they watched all day, but too bad a babies attention span lasts maybe 10 minutes! 

Mary Katherine Gallagher --- 15 years ago -

My kids don't really watch tv so this does seem like a no brainer to me. I won't say never, because television does have its place. But I'd much rather my kids were playing, reading books, thinking, etc. than vegetating. So if I don't really let my older kids watch much TV, my 14 month old definitely does not watch. 

The Original LM --- 15 years ago -

The only thing my 16 month old will sit and watch is Toy Story.

I think my 3 year old's vocabulary has been helped by tv. They don't sit and watch it much, it's background noise for their play. I taught L her colors, body parts, shapes, etc but PBS taught her what a T-Rex looked like and what magnifying glasses do. 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 15 years ago -

My kids don't really watch tv so this does seem like a no brainer to me. I won't say never, because television does have its place. But I'd much rather my kids were playing, reading books, thinking, etc. than vegetating. So if I don't really let my older kids watch much TV, my 14 month old definitely does not watch.


Yes, but if your 14 month old "vegetates" on something that teaches he/she isn't vegetating now are they? Vegetating equals mindless, zoned out BS. You don't come out of a vegetative state explaining what a carnivore and herbavore are. 

The Original LM --- 15 years ago -

My kids like Dinosaur Train, Sid the Science Kid, and Super Why. L was Princess Presto for Halloween. :) 

Mary Katherine Gallagher --- 15 years ago -

My 14 month old isn't capable of expounding on the differences between carnivores and herbavores. My kid is totally behind on that curve. He pretty much just smashes food into his hair. It must be all the tv he isn't watching. :( 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 15 years ago -

My 14 month old isn't capable of expounding on the differences between carnivores and herbavores. My kid is totally behind on that curve. He pretty much just smashes food into his hair. It must be all the tv he isn't watching. :(

Probably. At 14 months both my kids had insanely high levels of comprehension. You should probably expand the kids horizons. 

Mary Katherine Gallagher --- 15 years ago -

You're right. I should totally sit him in front of the tele as a way of broadening his horizons. If he doesn't have Yo Gabba Gabba to tell him not to bite his friends, it would probably be like living with a zombie toddler. 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 15 years ago -

You're right. I should totally sit him in front of the tele as a way of broadening his horizons. If he doesn't have Yo Gabba Gabba to tell him not to bite his friends, it would probably be like living with a zombie toddler.

Nah, I doubt it. But different ways of getting points across are great for kids. It's all about fun and variety. 10 minutes here and there do them great. 

The Original LM --- 15 years ago -

Each parent has to do what is right for them. I've been having a hard time explaining Christmas to my kids and since we're not religious and L is terrified of Santa, I wanted something to let her know he was a safe character. So I borrowed Frosty the Snowman, Barney Christmas, and Beauty and the Beast Christmas VHS's from a friend. 

Mary Katherine Gallagher --- 15 years ago -

As I said, I think there is a time and a place for television. I don't care what anyone does. My life as a parent is infinitely richer than it was when we watched often, so that's what works for me. 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 15 years ago -

As I said, I think there is a time and a place for television. I don't care what anyone does. My life as a parent is infinitely richer than it was when we watched often, so that's what works for me.

Good. 

Dinyell --- 15 years ago -

Since my son was born, I have pretty much kept it on Nick Jr for background noise during the day... he started paying attention to TV around 10 months, and though he only watches around an hour and a half or two scattered throughout the day, he is ahead of the developmental stage for his age (now 2), and has always been. He talks a LOT. Oh, and he speaks Spanish and counts to 11 as well. Thanks Dora! 

Erin Marie --- 15 years ago -

K prefers books way more over TV. She is almost 16 months old. The only thing she will sit and watch are Wiggles, but most of the time she will get up and dance or just listen to them as background noise. Books are her most favorite thing though. She has a bookcase in her playroom and she takes them all and looks through them for hours a day. LOL she's getting more for Christmas, too. 

chatty cathy --- 15 years ago -

My youngest loves Dora. We were baking yesterday and as soon as he heard her come on, he was out! It was Dora time.

The kid loves Dora. And he counts in Spanish and practices his shapes out loud. There is nothing wrong with that, but I get what the article.

Common sense says babies learn more from mommy than Spongebob. I've witnessed what the article states first hand with my nephew. He was raised by the TV and he barely talks, and has an array of speech and developmental problems. It's sad. And by raised, I mean it. His parents would put him in a highchair or bouncer in front of the TV with lots of snacks to keep him entertained, so they could continue to sleep or play video games. 

chatty cathy --- 15 years ago -

K prefers books way more over TV.

My kids too. As much as it drives me crazy to read to them at times, I still do it. I just can't bring myself to turn them down when they ask to read. 

Mary Katherine Gallagher --- 15 years ago -

Erin, my son loves books too. :)

I want to add that I don't think people who let their kids watch are badbparenta or anything. My first child had the Baby Einstein crap that was all the rage when he was born. My husband and I used to watch copious amounts of television and before TiVo we would even schedule activities around shows we liked. I let my older two watch tons of TV when they were preschoolers. I got to a point where I didn't like how much TV all of us were watching so I turned the cable off. I think our family dynamic is much better without the TV on all the time. We do still get Netflix so my older two are allowed to put things in the queue but that's a very deliberate sort of planning that we didn't do when I could just flick the box on. I don't order programs for the 14 month old because I've already been down the TV road with my older two and I am holding out with this one. 

Mary Katherine Gallagher --- 15 years ago -

Ha ha. Excuse my iPhone-ification of the above post. LOL 

Someone --- 15 years ago -

Canceling cable certainly helps more than just kids. We did and it was hard at first but has been great for us. My husband downloads the shows that are our favorites so the only TV we watch are the shows we really want instead of just sitting in front of the TV for hours everyday.

It's forced me to do some of the other stuff I've been needing/wanting to do. 

HiImKia --- 15 years ago -

I'm canceling cable when DH deploys. Everything that I watch, I can get online.

I put Nick Jr. ondemand on every morning for A. It MAYBE holds her attention for 2 minutes at a time. She likes shows with lots of music, she loves dancing. When we're in the car, she watches "Milo and Otis." She gets pissed after 10 minutes if I put a cartoon in. Puppies and kittens seem to do the trick.

In the afternoon, I put one of the toddler music channels on. I'll miss those channels most when I cancel cable! 

Erin Marie --- 15 years ago -

Our cable is GONE. We have Netflix and Hulu Plus and watch that on the PS3. Cable is a waste of money. At least, for us. We never watched TV. Netflix has a bunch of stuff K likes and she's not even old enough to understand about the cable thing. Best decision ever! 

HiImKia --- 15 years ago -

DH is convinced he couldn't live without it. We pay out the @ss for EVERY premium channel, have netflix, and he still comes home 5 nights a week with a redbox dvd. It'd be fine if we actually made it through a movie, but by the time we're relaxed enough to throw a movie in, we're ready for bed. Such a waste of money! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground