Link to article The Defense Department should eliminate restrictions on women serving in combat units and end all gender restrictive policies, according to a blue-ribbon panel created by Congress.
The move would end the militarys long tradition of all-male combat units and open up career fields like infantry and armor to qualified women.
The recommendation by the Military Leadership Diversity Commission will be included in a formal report to Congress and the White House in March.
The commission met and discussed the combat exclusion policy for females at a meeting Dec. 3, said Erica Lewis, a commission spokeswoman.
Many of the longstanding reasons for keeping women out of combat units do not hold up under scrutiny, the commissions research found.
A five-page analysis prepared for the commission concluded that women do not lack the physical ability to perform combat roles; gender integration will not negatively affect unit cohesion; and women are not more likely than men to develop mental health problems.
However, keeping women out of combat units and combat-related job fields can reduce their career opportunities, particularly in the officer corps and in the Army and Marine Corps, according to the commissions research.
The recommendation could push the combat exclusion policy for women into the mainstream political debate, similar to the ban on gays serving openly that was the subject of congressional hearings in early December.
The recommendation will be one of many from the commission aimed at improving diversity in the military and opportunities for women and minorities. The panels work could result in changes in law, a directive from the White House or policy changes within the Pentagon.
The commission suggested a phased approach to allowing women into combat units, Lewis said.
For example, the services might start by assigning women in career fields currently open to them to combat units traditionally limited to men. A second phase could involve opening additional career fields involved in direct ground combat to qualified women.
The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have shown current policies and their references to forward units to be outdated. In some situations, women in non-combat jobs have faced more danger than male infantrymen.
The enemy is no longer clearly and consistently identifiable, and all units are essentially exposed to hostile fire, the commissions research paper concluded.
Additionally, the spatial concepts of forward and well-forward are inappropriate and lacking to convey the complexity of operations such as those in Iraq and Afghanistan.
I think they should base who should and shouldn't be in combat on something other than gender. There are males that shouldn't be in combact situations.
Additionally, there are already many countries that have (and had) female combatants in their ranks. It has not proven to be a hindrance to those troops.
My opinion on this matter is if a woman wants to be a in a male combat unit she should have to meet all the criteria the men do. I have female marine friends that are very motivated, ect but would not be able to meet the standards my husband has to do.
I think most of the combat situations our military encounters are similar to what SWAT teams encounter. *I don't think* we need a super strong ground force like we did in the past with all the advancements in modern warfare. Troops don't sit out in the field for months on end, like they did in the past, so the hygiene issue that they onced used is moot.
On the other hand, I think our society has emasculated men while masculinizing women, in the hopes of creating a more equal, Utopian society, that is causing a slew of other social problems, but I digress...
I am torn. I know there are women that would excel in combat just as men do but my husband has made good points on why it would be hard to have co-ed infintry units.
I think they should base who should and shouldn't be in combat on something other than gender. There are males that shouldn't be in combact situations.
My husband just said "they should be careful for what they ask for". lol
I know some very awesome female marines (I do know the odd total loser too lol), but the awesome ones I know still wouldn't stack up to the physical demands or mental demands or emotional stress. Before they know it infantry battalions will become a bunch of pansy's. But hey, have at it. He'll be retired before the Marine Corps goes to sh*t. lol
Honestly, if women started going into combat mos's, I would want my husband to get out. Or at least get out of an 03 mos. It has nothing to do with women not being able to the same things men can or anything like that. Other reasons.
My husband said that his only concern would be pregnancy or rape allegations. Just like on a MEU there will be ones that are sleeping around. He also said, "It's not like there are going to be tampons scattered across the battlefield!"
Some company sent pallets of them to Iraq and my husbands unit soaked them in kool aid and threw them at each other. Why would women want to be around guys like that all the time?
Honestly, if women started going into combat mos's, I would want my husband to get out. Or at least get out of an 03 mos. It has nothing to do with women not being able to the same things men can or anything like that. Other reasons.
Like what? If you are going to let a woman being in your husband MOS to affect his career then that is just sad IMO
Troops don't sit out in the field for months on end, like they did in the past, so the hygiene issue that they onced used is moot.
While I agree that it's not months at a time like wars of the past there are instances of combat units going weeks at a time without time and/or access to a proper shower (I.E. setting up a FOB from the ground up). As long as they don't mind baby wipes bathing, stirring the sh**, can shoot a gun, and have the mental capability to handle intense combat situations I'm okay with it.
Some company sent pallets of them to Iraq and my husbands unit soaked them in kool aid and threw them at each other. Why would women want to be around guys like that all the time?
My husband is very professional and wouldn't do something like that. He does see "the kids" do things like that though. He thinks most women are whiney and emotional and that drives him crazy. When he was out of the fleet on a B Billet his boss was a female and he couldn't stand it because she acted like "the worlds oldest sorority girl".
So, they'd have to add extra bathrooms at their FOBs. One for men, one for gays and one for females lol. Whatever. Maybe they should just all have a group hug and sing kumbaya or something.
I personally don't like working with a bunch of females either, even though I do. But females are so chatty all the time and its really unproductive to be around that constant talking.
He thinks most women are whiney and emotional and that drives him crazy.
I agree. A lot of women are whiny and emotional. My gosh, this girl that worked with dh at Lejeune would whine in her status updates all the friggin' time about work!
Honestly, if women started going into combat mos's, I would want my husband to get out. Or at least get out of an 03 mos. It has nothing to do with women not being able to the same things men can or anything like that. Other reasons.
What reasons?
I think a lot of wives would take issue because they don't trust their husbands, but that's a whole'nother discussion, I suppose.