Jordan in the Circuit Court of Cook County, Ill., imposed a 30-day restraining order forbidding Joseph Reyes from, according to the document, "exposing his daughter to any other religion than the Jewish religion. "
That's what I don't agree with. HOWEVER, there is a religious dispute in their divorce and custody hearings so he should not have violated it.
I don't think he should have baptized that child against the mothers wishes. I also don't think he should have taken the child to church after he was ordered not to by the courts. It sounds like he's using the kid AND religon to get at the wife. He converted to Jewism when they were married saying it wasn't voluntary is BS. No one can force a grown arse man to be a Jew or a Christian.
Well, there was a court order saying the child could not be taken to a Catholic church. For him to randomly get her baptized is pretty sh!tty, especially since he knew she was being raised according to Jewish protocol.
"Number one, it wasn't just a religious thing per se, it was the idea that he would suddenly, out of nowhere without any discussion have the girl baptized," Lake said. "She looked at it as basically an assault on her little girl."
But I'm against children being baptized anyway. Also, I'm pretty sure this guy's not the brightest crayon in the box for saying this:
"Going to church, I don't think I violated the order," he told "Good Morning America." "In terms of Judaism, based on the information I was given, Catholicism falls right under the umbrella of Judaism."
Hahahaha. So being BAPTIZED is right under the umbrella of Judaism? Riiiight.
I just don't think the aspect of religion should be in divorce/custody battle.
I think it NEEDS to be. Imagine if the court had no part, those parents would rip that babys mind apart with conflicting religous views.
I just don't think the aspect of religion should be in divorce/custody battle. It's not fair to either parent or to that little girl.
Why not?
It makes sense to me.
What needs to be realized is that the charge against him is contempt of court. He's not being "charged with" taking his daughter to church or having her baptized. He violated a court order. It's no different than violating a court order not to take a child out of state or the country. Well, other than the fact that it can be enforced, whereas as soon as you leave the jurisdiction of the family court it can't be unless and until you return to said jurisdiction.
He didnt take her out of state or to a strip club.even if he did it for spite he evidently is catholic and even if your child or you chooses not to cont with the catholic faith the initial batism is something that means alot to catholics its a way to pure that baby from the "original sin". He might have been a douche but when you end up in dual religious relationships there should be give a take... its stupid that its going this far it seems like they both have grudges against eachother and that while trying to make eachother pay they are hurting that child...
He didnt take her out of state or to a strip club.
Thanks for clarifying that one for us, Sparky.
We all know what he did. He violated a court order. The topic of the order is irrelevant.
Wait, maybe I am just tired... are some of you suggesting that it is ok to violate a court order as long as it is religiously driven? The only one who is "hurting that child" is the parent who is breaking the law. They have these orders in the custody agreements for a reason.
Wait, maybe I am just tired... are some of you suggesting that it is ok to violate a court order as long as it is religiously driven? The only one who is "hurting that child" is the parent who is breaking the law. They have these orders in the custody agreements for a reason.
Agree here, the only harm is the bad example set by the law breaking parent, and the additional created conflict that this will now cause between both parents.
it is ok to violate a court order as long as it is religiously driven?
But of COURSE it is, Heather! You can't question any action motivated by religion, remember?
What needs to be realized is that the charge against him is contempt of court. He's not being "charged with" taking his daughter to church or having her baptized. He violated a court order. It's no different than violating a court order not to take a child out of state or the country. Well, other than the fact that it can be enforced, whereas as soon as you leave the jurisdiction of the family court it can't be unless and until you return to said jurisdiction.
Totally agree with this. He wouldn't be being thrown in jail for taking his daughter to church.
However I don't think the court has any place at all to decide what religion a child be brought up in. She can experience both faiths and not be screwed up. I know quite a few people who were brought up in a Christian/Jewish household. I don't see it as anything that a court should be able to order.
Omfg, the court is not "deciding" what religion that child is growing up in. The court is telling the parents that THEY can't decide what religion the child will grow up in without consent from the other parent. OH THE TRAVESTY TO EXPECT TWO PARENTS NOT TO ACT LIKE COMPLETE TOOLS!!!
I wouldn't be p*ssed if my ex took my daughter to a different church unless it was some kinda animal sacrificing crazy sh*t.
I have full power to make all decisions with me daughter without his consent and I am so glad for that but I'm not a b*tch about it.