So my MIL mentoined to me that one of the family friends is having a bday party for her 4yr old daughter. She didn't know if she should invite us though because she didn't want us to be insulted by expecting us to bring a gift for the birthday kid. This is all because we choose to donate our kids gifts to a charity...we have 3 kids that all celebrate their bdays right before Christmas..they get plenty..why not share?!?!
We don't push that on anyone else though and we ALWAYS get a nice gift for the bday kid. It is just a thoughful gesture that we enjoy doing (including my kids).
Do you think she is being a little ridiculous? Or am I reading into it all wrong?
Do you think she is being a little ridiculous? Or am I reading into it all wrong?
I would see it like not wanting to invite a vegan to a bbq where there will be no salad. KWIM? I know that sound weird. She might not mean to offend you by it.
Or she could just be a b&tch.
I refer to her as the "Texas Cheerleading Mom." Her kids are top notch and no one else comes close.
I will say this though..if her son claws at my legs again like he did last time (mom just laughed) I am going to donkey kick his little butt into the birthday cake!
IDK. I would never "expect" someone to bring my kids a gift in the first place. I'm too busy making sure they have fun at my kids party. I'm a cool parent like that though.
I am not offended...just the fact that she had her mom email my mother in law about it was a little much to me.
Maybe she didn't want to offend you and figured they wouldn't tell you? Idk. It might irk me for a second but at least she was considering how you would feel.
think you're weird for making your kids give up their gifts, IMO
I would agree, but she said her kids enjoy it too. As long as they don't mind I see nothing wrong with it.
I dont "make" my kids give up their gifts. I mentioned it to them one year and they were all for it.
They still get gifts from their 7 great grandparents, 6 grand parents, aunts and uncles and us (which is plenty). Plus Christmas is right around the corner. :)
Why? Her kids feel like they're doing a good thing by helping other kids. I don't get why that's wierd. I think it's sweet and rare in today's society to have an unselfish, or less selfish than normal, child.
Why? Her kids feel like they're doing a good thing by helping other kids. I don't get why that's wierd. I think it's sweet and rare in today's society to have an unselfish, or less selfish than normal, child
I agree.
I would agree with that for some people, but not everyone. It's not really fair to assume that about somebody when they're being generous. Even those who are doing it for themselves in a way are helping other people.
I don't really think kids think about themselves when they do that stuff most of the time.
None of my kids would give up their gifts. They will give up gifts at MY expense, but they aren't giving and not receiving!! HAHA! Such heathens I've raised.
I would agree with that for some people, but not everyone. It's not really fair to assume that about somebody when they're being generous.
Its also not fair to assume that, I do think, that about everyone...
TR, you ARE weird, but it has nothing to do with your gifting practices with your children. :p
As others have said, I think maybe she didn't know you only do that within your family, and she didn't want to offend you/put you on the spot for a gift.
We request books instead of toys when my daughter has a birthday. I think it's really cool that you do that with your kids. They are learning something really great with you doing it.
Alucky, I think that is cool too! We ask for books at holiday time also.
Honestly, they get SO much stuff that the kids don't even play with half of it. I came across presents that were still in packages almost a year after one of their bdays...why hold on to it when we can give it away? In a matter of 2 1/2 months we go through 3 birthdays, Halloween, Thanksgiving and Christmas. My house becomes a toy store..it is nuts!
We haven't yet done the "new gift charity" thing, however, when I sort through the boys' toys every so often, they help me choose a few things to bring to Goodwill or to churches for their nurseries/playrooms.