Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

So I already know MY answer...but....

who's talking here?

Jules 3
Nay-Nay 4
Jingle Bell Rockin 1
SarahR 4
♥♥♥ 1
Maureen 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Nay-Nay --- 17 years ago -

But I'd like to hear everyones: Here's my HW question. On July 5, 1884, Dudley, Stephens, and Brooks - "all able-bodied seamen" and a teenage English boy were cast adrift in a lifeboat following a storm at sea. They had no water with them in the boat, and all they had for sustenance were two one-pound tins of turnips. On July 24, Dudley proposed that one of the four in the lifeboat be sacrificed to save the others. Stephens agreed with Dudley, but Brooks refused to consent- and the boy was never asked for his opinion. On July 25, Dudley killed the boy, and the three men then fed on the boy's body and blood. Four days later, the men were rescued by a passing vessel. They were taken to England and tried for the murder of the boy. If the men had not fed on the boy's body, they would have probably died of starvation within the four-day period. The boy, who was in a much weaker condition, would have likely died before the rest. So, the question in this case is whether the survivors should be subject to penalties under English criminal law, given the men's unusual circumstances. you be the judge and decide the issue. Give reasons. 

SarahR --- 17 years ago -

I think they were right to have been tried AND convicted. Its not their right to decide who should be sacrificed. Murder is murder unless its in self defense. I know it was a bad situation but its not their place to decide the outcome and regardless, that boy could have also ended up being the only survivor...sometimes the weak prevail and come out as victors. You never truly know what would have happened. 

Maureen --- 17 years ago -

I think they were right to have been tried AND convicted. Its not their right to decide who should be sacrificed. Murder is murder unless its in self defense. I know it was a bad situation but its not their place to decide the outcome I agree with this. 

Jules --- 17 years ago -

Only the strong survive. 

Nay-Nay --- 17 years ago -

And I feel like there's a better way to word this sentence right? There is no justifiable reasoning, ethically or morally, to sacrifice one human life to save another. 

Jules --- 17 years ago -

I think there is justifiable reasoning. It's cruel, animalistic, tragic. But the desire to continue existing is very strong in humans. 

Jules --- 17 years ago -

to sacrifice one human life to save another. We do it in the military all the time. We send our men and women to war and sacrifice them. I know that's a whole 'nother can of worms, but... 

Maureen --- 17 years ago -

I think it's worse because it was a minor. If anything one of the adults should sacrificed themselves. IMO they are cowards to kill the kid. 

Nay-Nay --- 17 years ago -

But the desire to continue existing is very strong in humans. Very true, but I have to think of the more legal aspect. Murder is murder, they should have waited for the boy to die, since he was in a weakened state. As the judge I would be lenient, because of the situation, and the men could plead temporary insanity. I just don't like that they didn't even ask the boy first, or kill one of themselves first. 

♥♥♥ --- 17 years ago -

As the judge I would be lenient, because of the situation, and the men could plead temporary insanity.  ITA! 

SarahR --- 17 years ago -

As the judge I would be lenient, because of the situation, and the men could plead temporary insanity. Did they have temporary insanity pleas in 1884? 

Nay-Nay --- 17 years ago -

Did they have temporary insanity pleas in 1884? Probably not lol! In 1884 they would have probably been set free considering the circumstances. 

Maureen --- 17 years ago -

In 1884 they would have probably been set free considering the circumstances. Very true. In all honesty if it happened today I think that they could easily cover it up. Just dump the body in the ocean and claim a miracle of survival. They could say he fell overboard or something. 

SarahR --- 17 years ago -

Probably not lol! In 1884 they would have probably been set free considering the circumstances. Found this on it: Trial 

Jingle Bell Rockin --- 17 years ago -

Okay, from a Mothers stand point...if that was YOUR son that was eaten, how would you feel then? Should these men get a slap on the wrist or should they be charged? (just adding some fun to this) 

SarahR --- 17 years ago -

R v. Dudley and Stephens, (1884) England 14 Q.B.D 273 Facts: The English yacht Mignonette set sail for Sydney, Australia from Southampton, England on May 19, 1884 with a crew of four. The crew consisted of Tom Dudley, the captain; Edwin Stephens; Edmund Brooks; and Richard Parker, the cabin boy. On July 5, the yacht sank due to bad weather off the Cape of Good Hope (South Africa). Dudley, Stephens, Brooks, and Parker were cast away, forcing the four men to abandon the ship and escape in an open boat (13 feet) that belonged to that yacht. They had no supply of food and water except for two tins of turnips that the captain saved before they abandoned ship. On the fourth day they were able to catch a small turtle, which they completely consumed by the twelfth day. After twenty days, after eating only the turnips and the small turtle and being over 1,000 miles from land, Stephens and Dudley decided, without the consent of Brooks that they would kill and eat Parker. He was the youngest and weakest of them all. Parker did not consent to his killing, but he was too weak to resist. Dudley offered a prayer for forgiveness and then put a knife to Parker's throat and killed him. Dudley, Stephens, and Brooks all fed upon Parker's body for four days. On the fourth day they were rescued, but were not in good health. If the three remaining men had not fed upon Parker's body, they probably would have died of famine before they were eventually rescued. Parker would likely have died before them, because he was in a much weaker state. Upon returning to land, Dudley and Stephens were arrested and brought to trial. Note: See Text: All About Law, page 35. R v. Dudley and Stephens, (1884) England 14 Q.B.D 273 Procedure: The jury issued a special verdict. They found that there was no greater necessity to kill Parker, than there was to kill any of the others. However, the jury was unable to decide whether the killing of Parker was indeed a felony. Issue: Are Dudley and Stephens guilty of murder for killing Richard Parker? Holding: Yes. Where a private person, acting on his own judgment, takes the life of another, he is guilty of murder, unless his act can be justified by selfdefense. The defendants were not protecting themselves against any act of Parker. Reasoning: The defendants were subject to terrible temptation and sufferings that may break down the bodily power of the strongest man and try his conscience, but nevertheless the defendants put a weak, innocent boy to death in order to preserve their own lives. They denied the boy any possible chance of survival. The record shows that the defendants were rescued four days after the killing of the boy, but they were not to know that they would not be rescued within hours or the next day, giving all four a decent chance to survive. If they were rescued the next day, the killing would have been unnecessary and profitless. The counsel for the defendants urges that they killed out of necessity; however, necessity of a private nature pertains to self-defense, which allows a man to take another's life in his own defense. Parker was not a threat to the defendants' lives; in fact, he was weak and could not offer any resistance. While it may have been necessary to kill Parker for their own survival, it is not an excusable or justifiable killing. This would mean that if a man was poor and without clothes, he would be permitted to steal another man's money and clothes in order to save himself. The only justifiable homicide of a private nature is the defense against the force of a man's person, house, or goods. This necessity must be inevitable. While the court in this case did not deem the acts of the defendants devilish, they still constitute murder. 

Maureen --- 17 years ago -

NM you got to it first Sarah. I agree with the outcome. Under the law it was murder. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground