Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Do you think?

who's talking here?

Q♠ 1
ces1 1
~Rebel Angel~ 1
justme5775 1
The Original LM 1
~Bea~ 1
Muse 4
mrs. p 1
Cinde-freakin-rella 3
Boobsy McNiceass 1
No Apologies♥No Regrets 1
littleduck90 2
Susie Homemakerღ 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Do you think?

A child who is about to be 11 is old enough to give input on whether or not he needs ADHD medication?

Yes Vote
 
 48.8% (20)
No Vote
 
 36.6% (15)
Maybe Vote
 
 14.6% (6)
Muse --- 17 years ago -

A child who is about to be 11 is old enough to give input on whether or not he needs ADHD medication?  

No Apologies♥No Regrets --- 17 years ago -

I don't know. I honestly think SOME 11 year olds are capable of knowing their situation well enough to ask for that kind medication, but I think the parents themselves should know their child well enough to decide. 

Susie Homemakerღ --- 17 years ago -

11 seems a little young to make that kind of decision. The medication should definitely be discussed with the kid, but the decision should be left up to the parents. 

Cinde-freakin-rella --- 17 years ago -

11 seems a little young to make that kind of decision. She didn't say MAKE the decision, she said give input.. I'd say absolutely yes. 

Susie Homemakerღ --- 17 years ago -

11 seems a little young to make that kind of decision. She didn't say MAKE the decision, she said give input.. I'd say absolutely yes. Ah, I read it wrong. :) 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

Yeah, NO WAY would I allow him to make the decision on his own. Ultimately, it's up to me but I want to take his opinion into consideration. I feel it's only fair. My husband says no. A kid is a kid. 

The Original LM --- 17 years ago -

I'd say yes... I was 13 and was put on it... I told them over and over that I didn't have ADHD, just a lot of anger about them forcing me to go to counseling. They put me on it anyway... I dropped 30lbs, became a zombie, and "grew out of" ADHD that year. 

Boobsy McNiceass --- 17 years ago -

I'm on the fence. It would depend on the childs maturity level and what infomation they had on the medication. If they knew the pros and cons and we both sat down and discussed it the family and the doctor, I *might* let them make the choice. 

~Bea~ --- 17 years ago -

Nope. 

Q♠ --- 17 years ago -

No. 

littleduck90 --- 17 years ago -

I think they are old enough to have their opinion taken seriously. Maybe not leave it just up to them but take into consideration how they feel about it, and if they are put on it how it makes them feel. 

Cinde-freakin-rella --- 17 years ago -

Yeah, NO WAY would I allow him to make the decision on his own. Ultimately, it's up to me but I want to take his opinion into consideration. I feel it's only fair. My husband says no. A kid is a kid.  Obviously I have no idea what's going on, but from past experience I have to say.. make sure the problem is really with your kid, and not with the teacher (or their teaching style/whatever).. My 11 yr old was medicated in 4th grade because she was constantly in trouble at school, missing assignments, etc (and we'd never had trouble with her before 4th grade, other than talking when she shouldn't).. so we medicated her.. her grades came up, but I could definitely tell when her meds would wear off. SHE was back (her 'spark'). Kept her off the meds over the summer to give her a break (at the advice of her doctor) and realized she wasn't an out of control child.. haven't medicated her since, and have had no problems. That teacher however.. no longer works at the school she went to. NOT saying that the teacher was completely at fault.. but I wish I'd tried every avenue (including switching teachers) before I medicated her. 

~Rebel Angel~ --- 17 years ago -

growing up tons of kids would lie just so they could get the meds...just saying... 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

growing up tons of kids would lie just so they could get the meds...just saying... Mine isn't like that. 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

I'm dead serious. My son was on Concerta from the time he was 4 (because I was told that I HAD to put him on it and being young and him my only child at the time, I did what they told me to do) until this past June (he's 10). We took him off of it by mistake- the dr had forgotten to sign the script and we were unable to get it filled on that Friday. Saturday was a TERROR. Sunday almost as bad. Come Monday- he was fine. Right now, he's a little more reckless and doesn't make the RIGHT decisions sometimes but he doesn't appear to be needing the medicine (to me). Well since he came off of it we have caught him cursing, stealing and now trying to smoke. He is asking to go back on it. He said it's calmer when he's on it. He doesn't need to always be doing something. *I* think that the medicine SCREWS up a kid and that his bad choices are just that- bad choices. want to leave him off because when he's on it, he's so serious. He doesn't ever get silly. I know it sounds stupid but once he was off of it, now he dances and sings and hugs me ALL the time. He's a kid again. It's like I gave him his childhood back when I took him off of it. 

littleduck90 --- 17 years ago -

Right now, he's a little more reckless and doesn't make the RIGHT decisions sometimes but he doesn't appear to be needing the medicine (to me). Well since he came off of it we have caught him cursing, stealing and now trying to smoke. He is asking to go back on it. He said it's calmer when he's on it. He doesn't need to always be doing something. *I* think that the medicine SCREWS up a kid and that his bad choices are just that- bad choices. I think you are absolutely right. He does not need to be dependant on meds at that age. Look into the background of ADHD meds and studies on ADHD itself. A lot of psychologists and doctors don't agree with ADHD or ADD as diagnoses at all. Most of the time it's just a kid being a kid. They aren't supposed to be calm and perfect. I don't remember what studies we looked at but in both my public speaking class and psychology classes we looked into that. 

Cinde-freakin-rella --- 17 years ago -

I know it sounds stupid but once he was off of it, now he dances and sings and hugs me ALL the time. He's a kid again. It's like I gave him his childhood back when I took him off of it.  not stupid at all.. like I said, when it was wearing off at the end of the day for my daughter, I had HER back. In your situation, I wouldn't put him back on it either. When my daughter was on concerta, she actually got physical with others (she slapped a kid at school, they were fighting over a jump rope.. yes, a jump rope... she got suspended for that.) On adderall xr, we didn't have the aggression that we did on concerta, but like I said, she's no longer on any meds and is doing just fine. doesn't appear to be needing the medicine (to me) I'd say trust your gut on this one.. 

ces1 --- 17 years ago -

I think an 11 year old is old enough for his input, however doesn't mean that he has the last say so in what parents decide to do. 

mrs. p --- 17 years ago -

honestly i think EVERYONE is able to give input. but, to make his/her own desicion... he!! no 

justme5775 --- 17 years ago -

I haven't been on here in a long, long time, and stopped by with a completely different purpose in mind, but after reading this I felt I had to comment. As someone who has dealt with ADD for most of my life, the decision to medicate or not medicate is something my parents argued about constantly. If your child truly has ADD/ADHD (and I'm the first to admit that it's WAY over diagnosed), medication can be useful as a PART of any management program. I'm grateful that my parents involved me early on in the decision to take medication. The choice wasn't mine to make until I was 16, but they always solicited my input as to how I felt. They also worked hard to create a very structured lifestyle for me, and helped me find ways to cope without medication. For the person who said that her son was making bad choices, obviously you know your son better than anyone, but you might want to consider doing some research on ADD/ADHD and decision making. It's been shown that people who have this disorder use different neural pathways when making decisions and are less likely to weigh the long term consequences against immediate reward. I can truly sympathize with the statements you attributed to him. I'm not saying medication is the answer, or that it's always the right choice. But there are cases where it helps. My advice to anyone who chooses to medicate their child is to use it as a tool in the overall lifestyle management. You may have to experiment with different meds and dosages but no medication should make you feel like your child is a completely different person. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground