Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Testifying at a Court Marshall?

who's talking here?

stillkickin! 1
Jules 1
Skoochers 4
~allison~ 7
Tiki, Tikcuf, dirty old perv! 2
Cindy 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

~allison~ --- 17 years ago -

Question. In the Military..or at least the MC..can one be FORCED to testify in a Court Marshall hearing? 

Skoochers --- 17 years ago -

Active Duty can be forced to show. You can't force a person to speak, but there can be repercussions. (Ps, "martial") 

stillkickin! --- 17 years ago -

skooch hit it on the nose! 

Skoochers --- 17 years ago -

Unfortunately I have experience :/ 

~allison~ --- 17 years ago -

jw bc a guy at my husbands work showed up to another guys hearing but my dh's Msgt wanted this guy to physically speak against this other dude but he didnt want to so she had made that guy work 36 hours straight bc he wouldnt speak at the hearing 

Skoochers --- 17 years ago -

Like I said. Repercussions. If the guy knows something, and fails to report it (ie testify with his info) then he can be held legally responsible as well, just as in the civilian world. he should actually be thankful it was just 36 hours of working instead of brig time. 

~allison~ --- 17 years ago -

He wasnt holding back any info or anything like that. The guy plead guilty. The guy was caught smokin weed on base. retard. But the other guy just didnt feel the need to say anything since he plead guilty I guess? Im not sure the exact reason he didnt want to speak. But he plead guilty and the other guy didnt have any info that wasnt already out on the table 

Skoochers --- 17 years ago -

Well, see the thing is. If he had witnessed it and didn't report him to begin with, that could get him in trouble. Accessory? Soemthing like that? If it was already out on the table, then there shouldn't have been an issue of him saying "yeah, I knew about it". IMO he may have caused problems for himself by being stubborn, and they may think he has something to hide. Ya know? 

Tiki, Tikcuf, dirty old perv! --- 17 years ago -

A person can be forced to testify by the court itself, not by a MSgt who wants them to. Sounds like maybe the MSgt wanted this person to be character witness but the person didn't want to. That would be one of those, "You don't HAVE TO, but it would BEHOOVE YOU" situations. Obviously neither prosecution nor defense counsel thought it was necessary for the person to appear or he would have been called. 

~allison~ --- 17 years ago -

I guess. She has done stuff like this lately. Its like she has had something up her butt lol Well compared to how she use to be. I know there are alot of things that go on at my husbands work that she does that the Gunny has even told all the Marines is against MCO 

Tiki, Tikcuf, dirty old perv! --- 17 years ago -

I know there are alot of things that go on at my husbands work that she does that the Gunny has even told all the Marines is against MCO Sounds like someone needs to sack up and call her on it. Idiots like that only get away with it because people let them. 

~allison~ --- 17 years ago -

yeah Tiki, he was never actually called by the counsel. She told him she wanted him to i guess "volunteer" to go up there but he didnt want to. So he worked for 36 hours. Eh his issue not mine. I was just curious since my dh has never been in that situation himself 

~allison~ --- 17 years ago -

idk. its whatever. Im not the marine. my dh is. so thats his issue. but its just dumb stuff like everyone had to come in one evening at 6pm to clean and they didnt leave til a little after eleven and had work at 4 am. she was there at 6pm.. but left at i think they said 830pm bc "she was tired and if it was up to her they all would have been there cleaning until the shift started the following morning" 

Jules --- 17 years ago -

Suck it up. It's not the worst that can happen. My husband got tired of leading running formations for PT and he and all the other SGTs ended up having to clean the barracks because they didn't volunteer. Bullsh!t happens. Accept it! 

~allison~ --- 17 years ago -

Suck it up. It's not the worst that can happen Im not complaining. I know worst can happen. I was just saying that lately her attitude has been different and isnt the same towards everyone as she use to be. She use to be the "mom" type. Even when it came to me. And also was just asking a question I was curious about. 

Cindy --- 17 years ago -

but its just dumb stuff like everyone had to come in one evening at 6pm to clean and they didnt leave til a little after eleven and had work at 4 am. she was there at 6pm.. but left at i think they said 830pm bc "she was tired and if it was up to her they all would have been there cleaning until the shift started the following morning" Hey Allison, I think you've already gotten good answers about your court marshall question. I just wanted to say I'm sorry your husband is dealing with that crap. I don't think telling anyone to suck it up is appropriate. It's a legitimate complaint. If it wasn't such stupid BS, it wouldn't be so annoying to have to deal with. I know because I've been there. I was a civilian working with my husband and witnessed the unsurpassable stupidity every single day. Eventually the young Marines get worn down by it, especially when it happens regularly. Thus why the whine, thus why they complain, thus why they GET OUT. So yeah. But then I was raised by a Marine who believed in being "firm but fair" with his troops. Instead of trying to drag them down every single day, he looked out for them. That's what I grew up believing was the right way to be. He may not have been popular with his officers and other superiors, but you better believe he was well liked by his troops. He got treated like crap by his SNCOs when he was a LCpl, so he made sure not to forget about that when he became an NCO and then SNCO. You shouldn't forget where you came from. Bad SNCOs can really ruin good Marines who would've otherwise been motivated with a desire to stay in and do their 20 years. When you hear people complain, try to consider that it might just be for a reason! Anyway, I'm off my soap box now. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground