My 2 yr old has been having BAD tantrums since she was bout 18 months old...Its partially my fault because i spoiled her beyone no recognition...but its also the typical terrible 2's. Well my hubby was talking to his father and he said to throw water on her face and she'll stop the tantrum and think about it next time before she starts. I told my hubby there was NO WAY IN GODS GREEN EARTH he'd do that to my baby...Well she had a tantrum today because she wanted her dora cup and he said no...sure enough he threw water in her face. Does anyone think it was wrong for me getting ticked off and "raising" my voice at him telling him not to do that again...?
I don't think it was wrong of you to get upset, because you'd already voiced your disapproval of that method. However, it's just water (altho I am on your side, I wouldn't do it.) Also, tantrums ARE normal at her age. In my experience, tantrums are quicker to go away if you ignore them than if you address them....
I've gotta ask though, did it work?
For a few mins...
If it worked, the water isn't hurting her.
Thats not the point though. My daughter isnt a wild animal. There is no need for something like that. There are alot of other things you can do besides something like that, JMO
In my experience, tantrums are quicker to go away if you ignore them than if you address them....
i've tried ignoring and it didnt work she just got more mad...now its gotten to i just tune her out and its so funny b/c she looks at me to see if im looking then starts screaming again...lol. It's just something that comes along with babies...and im fine with that...It'll pass eventually...HOPEFULLY:)
SHe's not a dog.
My aunt is from Sweden and she would use a spray bottle on her kids. If they acted up she would spray them in the face. I think its wierd .
water? she's not a dog
that was my point to my hubby...He doesnt get it...He's just like it worked for me and my siblings...but that was back in the DAYYYYYY...lol
In my experience you ignore them....and if they continue you put them in their room until they calm down...if they mess up the room in a fit you and her both pick it up. Just a thought
I think its disrespectful.
IT is. There are alot better ways to discipline. Believe me my youngest is a hellion! Timeouts work the best for her. And just ignoring. Spankings and all that never ever worked with her. SHe didn't care. But put her in her room or in a chair for 5 minutes and she hates it.
if they mess up the room in a fit you and her both pick it up. Just a thought
oh yea we've been that route too...but her train of anything is like 2 seconds long...so i always end up picking everything up. I've closed her door...but she 98% of the time finds something else to do...When she does help me though...shes the best helper in the world...and at the end i get a big hug and a kiss!!!
Well, if it worked and you have yet to find any other way to control your child, I'd say go for it.
so your saying go for it and if we're in public to just find a water fountain and throw water on her??? i think not. Thanks for you thoughts on it though.
Lol, if a child that young doesn't "care" about a spanking, you probably aren't doing it right.
Theres certain degrees you go to when spanking a child. You dont wanna end up "beating" them...I do admit to loosing my temper with her one time and spanking her a little too hard...didnt work though. Its a 2 yr old. shes gonna be like that
Lol, if a child that young doesn't "care" about a spanking, you probably aren't doing it right.
SHe's 3. Timeouts have ALWAYS worked better than a spanking with her. IF she got a pop on the butt and talked to she would be right back at whatever she was doing within 5 minutes. Give her a timeout and you would think the world is ending.
so your saying go for it and if we're in public to just find a water fountain and throw water on her???
No. The situation you described seemed to be one that happened at home. I don't discipline in public if it's avoidable.
It may get her attention enough to work
it does the 1st time it happens...but if it were to happen again it wouldnt phase her...she loves water anyways...except the shower...LOL shes a bath baby
I think its disrespectful.
i think my kid screaming at me is more disrespectful.
i dunno, it's unusual, but i don't think it's wrong. i can't see it being very effective, other than getting the kid's attention.
Its a 2 yr old. shes gonna be like that
It's not an age thing, or else every 2 year old would behave the same way.
IF she got a pop on the butt and talked to she would be right back at whatever she was doing within 5 minutes.
Exactly.
Lol, if a child that young doesn't "care" about a spanking, you probably aren't doing it right.
I spanked my oldest with the belt once when she was three. She laughed at me. It was the first time for the belt and the last time I ever spanked. Believe me I did it right! I know there are better ways to discipline than spankings ect.. What do you think the daycare teachers do? Your kids don't turn into angels the minute they go to school.
except the shower...LOL shes a bath baby
ughh my 3 year old could stay i nthe shower ALL DAY! lol My 5 year old you think is getting beat the way she freaks out in the shower. SHe has to get over it though because all we have is a shower . lol no tub.
Next time he's yelling at you over something throw water in his face and see how he likes it. There are better ways to discipline and tantrums are common for 2 year olds. I find it very disrespectful and just because she is small and can't speak up it doesn't make it ok. I would be livid if I were you since you already told him you didn't approve of it.
Your kids don't turn into angels the minute they go to school.
my daughter is ALWAYS good for others...when she sees me all heck breaks loose...lol
My 5 year old you think is getting beat the way she freaks out in the shower.
I would laugh so hard...my baby even hates it when we put water on her hair to wash it!!!
Believe me I did it right! I know there are better ways to discipline than spankings ect.. What do you think the daycare teachers do?
I'm sure you did. Everyone does. There are other way of discipline, I'll give you that. Outside of beatings and neglect, there is no one way that is "better" or "worse"... just different ways. Teachers do not discipline, they correct and redirect. Not the same thing.