yes, we have a Caravan, and although it is spacious and roomy, the way my DH likes to gun the peddle, the gas mileage sucks. Why he likes to drive fast in a family car is beyond me.
I like the Jetta. I think I'm just comfortable with the van kwim. I've had a van for so long. It will be a big change going from something big to something small.
VAN... only because I'm a minivan driver myself. I love mine and I'll never drive any other make/model. Comfortable, lots of room, very versitale, great gas milage... even though my hubs also likes to be heavy on the petal (he says she needs a cleaning out every once in a while and my grandma drivin' doesn't do it!).