Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Do you believe that a slight form of "hazing" should be allowed in the military?

who's talking here?

do you really care who i am 6
*~LittleMissPerfect~* 1
Boomer 8
dmc... 3
♥ 1
truthiness 3
Hippie_Momma(Sharon) 1
MacSays_ShutUrCockGarage 4
A-Fish-Called-Wanda 6
Mermaid 1
♀ KrYsTaL♀ 3
Blue 1
FarmDogsWife 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Do you believe that a slight form of "hazing" should be allowed in the military?

Some people believe hazing is a form of unifying people.

Yes Vote
 
 45.5% (15)
No Vote
 
 48.5% (16)
Undecided Vote
 
 3.0% (1)
Other Vote
 
 3.0% (1)
A-Fish-Called-Wanda --- 18 years ago -

Some people believe hazing is a form of unifying people. 

A-Fish-Called-Wanda --- 18 years ago -

C'mon people, I want to see some educated answers. 

do you really care who i am --- 18 years ago -

yes .... 

A-Fish-Called-Wanda --- 18 years ago -

Thanks for your educated answer, do you ;) 

♀ KrYsTaL♀ --- 18 years ago -

Whether we say yes or no, we all know that people still do it even though they aren't supposed to. lol 

A-Fish-Called-Wanda --- 18 years ago -

Whethee we say yes or no, we all know that people still do it even though they aren't supposed to. lol But, what do YOU think? I think your answer is important, because you were in as well, Krys. 

do you really care who i am --- 18 years ago -

it really depends on the type and extent of hazing but there is forms and reason that some shoulw be allowed 

Boomer --- 18 years ago -

Here is my take on this! When I came in the Marine Corps, there was no such word, however, the act itself was being conducted. I believe that certain people, units, what have you, take what is to be an initiation of sorts, and distort it to the point of physical harm. In this instance, it is not okay, not acceptable, and should be punished. In the spirit of comraderie and tradition, certain things I believe should stay in tact, shell-back, and a few others, but not to the extreme of physical paralysis or serious unchangeable harm. Does that make sense? 

♀ KrYsTaL♀ --- 18 years ago -

Whethee we say yes or no, we all know that people still do it even though they aren't supposed to. lol But, what do YOU think? I think your answer is important, because you were in as well, Krys. I would say no. I say this b/c half of the time it deosn't work anyway. The military members usually end up getting worse than they were before. I think that it makes things end up being worse than they already were before. 

Hippie_Momma(Sharon) --- 18 years ago -

I think as long as it's not physically hurting them like a beating then ok. 

♀ KrYsTaL♀ --- 18 years ago -

Here is my take on this! When I came in the Marine Corps, there was no such word, however, the act itself was being conducted. I believe that certain people, units, what have you, take what is to be an initiation of sorts, and distort it to the point of physical harm. In this instance, it is not okay, not acceptable, and should be punished. In the spirit of comraderie and tradition, certain things I believe should stay in tact, shell-back, and a few others, but not to the extreme of physical paralysis or serious unchangeable harm. Does that make sense? I agree with you. I remember when my CPL got promoted in Oki. They did the "Blood Stripe" thing to him. yeah the next day he was being rushed to the hospital b/c he couldn't walk. also his collar bone was fractured b/c of the pinning thing that they do too 

do you really care who i am --- 18 years ago -

"shell-back" I myself and a golden shell-back i agree but i also agree that the term hazing is mistreated to like some good old labor for dicipline has been blown all out up and labled as such , i hate doing paper work on a marine and i feel like myself if they had a choice some swet over paper work is good anyday giving the situation that is . if we cant do some things the old way why not reinstate CCU 

Boomer --- 18 years ago -

I too had to go through "the gauntlet" upon being promoted to Corporal, and remember the pain endured, but no permanent damage, I will leave it at that, however, I come from a different time though! 

A-Fish-Called-Wanda --- 18 years ago -

Hee hee.... I'm a shellback, too. 

do you really care who i am --- 18 years ago -

im wiht Pimpin , i to took alot and yes some take it to far yes but not all of us 

♥ --- 18 years ago -

I think to a certain degre it should be allowed. 

A-Fish-Called-Wanda --- 18 years ago -

Pimpin, you never answered. Where are you from, and when did you join the beloved Corps, lol? 

Boomer --- 18 years ago -

Wanda, it is entirely possible that we have met, just not sure when or where! 

Boomer --- 18 years ago -

PM me Wanda! 

do you really care who i am --- 18 years ago -

aside from beating hte hell or injuring someone i think it should be more open the the idea.I know i was tought in both the old and new ways of the jedi and i turned out ok 

*~LittleMissPerfect~* --- 18 years ago -

No matter what, it is always going to happen, and it is totally unprofessional, but whatever. 

FarmDogsWife --- 18 years ago -

It is hard to give a definitive answer. Hazing is a word that speaks volumes to many. Hazing to the extreme (humiliating, oppressive, demeaning, or harmful) is where “I” have a problem. Many of us have seen how it can go from innocent humiliation (college/crossing the equator or tacking/pinning rank/stripes to NCO) and rights of passage to others but many can and have lead to death. Hazing is done by most of us - it is human nature. Hazing doesn't just have to be physical abuse, it can and is verbal or psychological in nature. I think that if most Marines are asked about the rank of Cpl being tacked on or the blood stripe being pinned, you will find that most will say; "Darn proud to participate in that tradition - I took it in the manner that it was intended - "Welcome to the brotherhood of NCO Leadership." Just my opinion of course. http://www.cruelmilitary.com/us-marines-hazing.mov 

do you really care who i am --- 18 years ago -

So let me get this ok... you have a kid he or she is being totaly out of hand at the table for supper so your fed up you take thier food and send them to bed. (hungry) Is that punishment or hazing , what is the diferance in that than if a Marine lost his mind threw trash out his car window so you made him police the side of the road for a hour during his lunch time taking up his time and not the others that work around or wiht him? 

Boomer --- 18 years ago -

Is that punishment or hazing , what is the diferance in that than if a Marine lost his mind threw trash out his car window so you made him police the side of the road for a hour during his lunch time taking up his time and not the others that work around or wiht him? This would be a form of EMI (Extra Military Instruction), to which the Marine is being held accountable for his/her actions, and is receiving remedial training to correct a deficiency! 

dmc... --- 18 years ago -

Pimpin, my dh just told me he had to do the Gauntlet on ship. He said that sucks worse then being on land! lol 

Boomer --- 18 years ago -

OH! The stories I could tell........... 

dmc... --- 18 years ago -

I had to ask him what a shell back was. hee hee 

Boomer --- 18 years ago -

HAHAHA! So, I take it he has been there, done that, got the t-shirt? 

MacSays_ShutUrCockGarage --- 18 years ago -

I agree with Pimpin. A little "hazing" all in good fun is ok. Frats and sororities do it every day. But when you have scars because someone "pinned" you so hard, that's a problem. 

dmc... --- 18 years ago -

HAHAHA! So, I take it he has been there, done that, got the t-shirt? yeah, he said something about eating something out of a fat chief's belly button???? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground