Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

What do you think?

who's talking here?

MrsH 2
Someone 1
KΛΤIΞ♥™ 1
Stephanie 4
•°oAshley★ 7
SAonaSM 1
dmc... 1
truthiness 7
~*Jolene*~ 1
~lue~ 2
~*LM*~ 9
Muse Heather 12
Ella Mafayo 1
A-Fish-Called-Wanda 6
MsZ v 1
FlippyFloppies 2
Kappy 2
*tara* 1
Malice in Wonderland♠ 4
♠ Manson's Mistress 1
*MustangSallie* 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

•°oAshley★ --- 18 years ago -

Background: A 19 year old woman is charged with statutory rape for having sex with a 15 year old. The 19 year old has a baby as a result of the unlawful sexual conduct. The woman then takes the boy to court and he is ordered to pay $50 a month in child support and receive 7 hours a week in vistation. Do you agree that the boy (who is 16 now) should have to pay child support? *This was a discussion that took place on a different site, just wondering what LU's opinion on the topic is* I guess this is where the question comes from. 

A-Fish-Called-Wanda --- 18 years ago -

This is a very good question. Very good, actually. No, I don't believe he should pay child support. 

dmc... --- 18 years ago -

I would have to wonder why he's not paying it to the state since she should be in jail. 

FlippyFloppies --- 18 years ago -

Bah he can earn that mowing lawns. :P 

Stephanie --- 18 years ago -

I think he should. I understand it was considered statutory rape, but you can't convince me that a 15 year old boy didn't know sex can produce a baby. 

~*LM*~ --- 18 years ago -

I have to agree with Stephanie although at this point I think that the amount is a little excessive... 

Muse Heather --- 18 years ago -

If they could prove that the statutory rape wasn't a sexual assault, than heck yeah he should. 

*tara* --- 18 years ago -

i think you can't have it both ways .. if he was"raped" he shouldnt have to pay.. and if you want him to pay she shouldnt have been charged with "rape" 

A-Fish-Called-Wanda --- 18 years ago -

I think he should. I understand it was considered statutory rape, but you can't convince me that a 15 year old boy didn't know sex can produce a baby. This is good, but this is where it gets hazy. If the girl was found guilty, then you are basically saying that the boy was at no fault. Rememebr, you have to prove without a reasonable doubt. You cannot charge one, and the one is found guilty, only to turn around and charge the other. I do believe MORALLY, he should help. But, I wouldn't expect anything, until he was legally an adult. 

•°oAshley★ --- 18 years ago -

On the other forum this was posted on, there were varying opinions, basically everyone was split about how they felt. One side argued that statutory rape is far different than "regular" rape so he knew what he was getting into, therefore should pay child support. The other side argued that no matter what, the boy shouldn't have to pay his attacker (offender? I don't know what word to use). 

Muse Heather --- 18 years ago -

and if you want him to pay she shouldnt have been charged with "rape" Statutory rape and rape as a sexual assault has different legal definitions. 

Malice in Wonderland♠ --- 18 years ago -

He should have to pay once he turns 18 and from then on. 

~*LM*~ --- 18 years ago -

I think the baby should be put up for adoption because sexual offenders shouldn't be able to keep their kids. JMO. 

Stephanie --- 18 years ago -

The other side argued that no matter what, the boy shouldn't have to pay his attacker If it was actual rape, I would agree, but since it was only statutory, which only deals with the age difference, I think he should pay. He wasn't forced into it. Could he have been taken advantage of? Maybe.. but I still see him as being a willing participant. 

truthiness --- 18 years ago -

She raped him. He is a child. He should not have to pay b/c 18 is the age a person is "supposed" to have the mental capacity to make adult decisions. 

Malice in Wonderland♠ --- 18 years ago -

I thought in some states the age of consent is 16? 

Stephanie --- 18 years ago -

So if a 15 year old and a 16 year old had a kid together, the one shouldn't have to pay the other child support because they aren't legally adults? I know this particular case carries the statutory rape element, but in the above example, they're both considered children by this definition He should not have to pay b/c 18 is the age a person is "supposed" to have the mental capacity to make adult decisions. 

•°oAshley★ --- 18 years ago -

I think the baby should be put up for adoption because sexual offenders shouldn't be able to keep their kids. JMO In the link I posted the boy's parents want custody of the baby. thought in some states the age of consent is 16? The article says it happened in Ohio, and states he was 15 at time of conception. 

~*LM*~ --- 18 years ago -

I thought in some states the age of consent is 16? In most it is 17 I believe. However, he was 15 at the time. I think $200 a month would be hard for a boy to come up with when he is in school too. 

truthiness --- 18 years ago -

Teenagers should keep their mouth and legs shut. It's not hard..the concept is not equivalent to physics 

~*LM*~ --- 18 years ago -

I hadn't read the article... $50 a month, not week 

•°oAshley★ --- 18 years ago -

Statutory rape and rape as a sexual assault has different legal definitions. Springboarding off this... If they are different, and we don't view the younger person as a "victim" of statutory "rape", then why does the older party have to register as a sex offender? 

Muse Heather --- 18 years ago -

and we don't view the younger person as a "victim" of statutory "rape", then why does the older party have to register as a sex offender? Cuz it's the law, and it's better to err on the side of caution. 

•°oAshley★ --- 18 years ago -

I hadn't read the article... $50 a month, not week Oh I didn't catch that it was a month, I just copy and pasted what someone else wrote, maybe I should change the first comment in the thread. 

MsZ v --- 18 years ago -

i dont believe he should when in his case, if she never raped him, this would not be the result, it's not his fault this act happened..just my opinion 

Muse Heather --- 18 years ago -

if she never raped him, this would not be the result, it's not his fault this act happened.. It was statutory rape. Does the article say if it was charged as a sexual assault or lewd acts against a minor? Or if it was a one time thing or not? I can't get to the site for some reason. 

~*LM*~ --- 18 years ago -

Says they had sex twice... I'll copy and paste it for you Heather. 

~*LM*~ --- 18 years ago -

Boy's parents sue to get his baby from mom, 21 Saturday, August 16, 2008 3:12 AM By Mary Beth Lane THE COLUMBUS DISPATCH LANCASTER, Ohio --- A Pickerington couple and their son are fighting for custody of a baby born to a Lancaster woman charged with having unlawful sex with the boy, who was 15 at the time of conception. A paternity test shows that the teen is the father of the baby born April 7 to Jane C. Crane, who was 19 when she became pregnant. Now, a judge has ordered him to pay $50 a month in child support and set visitation at seven hours a week. Crane, meanwhile, faces criminal charges. A Fairfield County grand jury indicted her last month on two counts of unlawful sexual conduct with a minor, a fourth-degree felony. Conviction carries a maximum sentence of 18 months in prison and a requirement to register as a sex offender for 25 years. Crane is living with the baby and her family in Lancaster. The boy's parents say they can provide a better upbringing for the baby than Crane can. Her household includes her stepfather, David L. Jacobs, who was convicted of domestic violence last year for hitting, choking and pointing a gun at Crane's 17-year-old sister and was placed on two years' probation, court records show. "We don't want to have our granddaughter abused by these people," the boy's father said. "We are trying to do the right thing. "The child support was the icing on the cake. I couldn't believe that our son has to pay child support to his abuser." The Dispatch does not identify victims of sexual abuse. Crane is scheduled for a pretrial conference before Common Pleas Judge Richard E. Berens on Aug. 21. A hearing and a status conference in the custody dispute are scheduled for next month before Domestic Relations Judge Kathy S. Mowry. Crane, now 21, is not a suitable custodial parent in part because she may have committed a felony by having sexual intercourse with a minor younger than 16, the boy's parents argue in court papers seeking custody. Crane declined to comment. She is free on a $5,000 recognizance bond pending trial. Her attorney, Sandra Davis, did not return calls. Lawyer Jennifer Strunk, the court-appointed guardian ad litem representing the baby's interests, said through a spokesman that she could not comment. That a 19-year-old woman had sex with a 15-year-old boy might seem like no big deal to some, but it is a serious charge, said Assistant Prosecutor Julia Dillon. It makes no difference that it is an adult female charged with unlawful sexual conduct with a minor boy rather than the more common instance of an adult male charged with unlawful sexual conduct with a minor girl. "It is an age and maturity issue, not a gender issue," Dillon said. "He's a young boy coming into his own, being taken advantage of by an adult." There could yet be a plea agreement. "I have made what I consider to be a reasonable offer, but I have not received a response," she said. The incident has had lasting affects on the boy, now 16, his mother said. "He has nightmares, he is stressed out," she said. "He is a father, even though it was a crime for him to be a father. His life is changed forever." Crane got to know the family while she worked at a local movie theater with the boy's older sister. When Crane said that her stepfather was abusive, his family allowed her to move in with them. The boy's sister later bought her own home and Crane moved in with her. It was there last summer that Crane had sex with their son at least twice, his parents said. mlane@dispatch.com 

Someone --- 18 years ago -

Statutory rape is not plain rape. If she raped him against his will it would just be rape, statutory is just that one person is too old to be considered ok. My biological 1/2 brother is a sexual offender because him and his girlfriend had sex and she was 16 and him 19 or something like that. He didn't rape her against her will, and had he been the younger one, and she got pregnant he absolutely should have had to pay, he choose to have sex. I had sex at 15, and if I got pregnant or got an STD it would be 100% my fault for willingly having sex. 

SAonaSM --- 18 years ago -

She raped him. He is a child. He should not have to pay b/c 18 is the age a person is "supposed" to have the mental capacity to make adult decisions. Ditto! 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground