Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Obama's foreign languages comments...

who's talking here?

Ella Mafayo 2
Nay-Nay 1
Lisa6823 2
FlippyFloppies 3
Julianna 3
Sasha 6
SeriouslyInaneBabble 8

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Ella Mafayo --- 18 years ago -

So, I heard a news-reader (I don't call them journalists...they read from a prompter) say last night on Fox News, something to this effect (Just a paraphrase...I can't remember it word for word): "Obama said that he was embarrassed that Americans aren't bilingual. Nobody has spanked him for that yet....why hasn't anyone bothered to take him to task for that comment?" **DISCLAIMER: No, I'm not a rabid Obama fan...I'm not campaigning for him here in any way, shape or form. I'm looking at ALL candidates with an open mind at this point...like every good voter should. Here is part of a news article detailing what Obama said (Quoted directly): "Obama was answering a question on education when he said he doesn’t understand people who say “we need English only.” “I agree that immigrants should learn English,” Obama said. “But instead of worrying about whether immigrants can learn English — they’ll learn English — you need to make sure your child can speak Spanish. You should be thinking about how can your child become bilingual. We should have every child speaking more than one language.” He argued that the country should be emphasizing foreign language study in classrooms. “You know, it’s embarrassing when Europeans come over here, they all speak English, they speak French, they speak German. And then we go over to Europe and all we can say is ‘merci beaucoup!”‘ Obama said, laughing." So, without bringing out the usual, boring, non-sequitur comments like "Obama is the antichrist," can we discuss why those comments were / were not justified? My take: I'm right behind him. The US is one of the VERY FEW (if not the only...I don't know exact statistics) industrialized nations whose educational system does not include a rigorous foreign language curriculum. By the time they are my kids' age (almost 9), many European kids are speaking their native language AND English fluently. By the time they graduate high school, many students outside this country are tri-lingual. (Not all....but many). Why are we so adamant that we don't need to learn another language? Are we really THAT arrogant as to think that we are SO much better than the rest of the world? Aside from the very-easy target of our crappy education system, this is a discussion about American foolishness and ethnocentrism. We are laughing right in the faces of all the other nations of the world and giving them a big middle finger every time we denounce foreign language education and the concept of growing up bilingual. YES...people who live in America should learn English...I firmly believe that. And I don't agree that Spanish should be the sole focus of our foreign language efforts. But are we really happy with being the only nation of people who purposely tells its children "Don't bother learning to communicate with the rest of the world...f*ck them...let them learn English instead" ???? So I guess my beef with that reporter is: Are you that ignorant? Are you really angry with a man who says that he sees a better future for this country if we'd just make a little effort to communicate with the outside world? Ok, in the immortal words of Linda Richman...  

Julianna --- 18 years ago -

i agree...being from hungary, i know schools start teaching a foreign laguange in 1st grade...(sad to say i'm still confused by the proper names of the schools here, kindergarden, pre-k, elemntary school, middle school, why do they have to be named different?)anywhoo usually kids will start 1st grade by the time their 6, no later than 7. That is when foreign language begins.Sadly i had to take Dutch, i never liked the language, i always wanted to learn English, to which my father said i'd never need it..oh was he wrong. But i gotta agree that it would be very beneficial to students to start learning a foreign language early in school. i'm sorry, but a semester of foreign language does not mean anything. I'm teaching my daughter Hungarian, not only because it's a language i grew up speaking, but also because if she learns to speak 2 languages now, later in life it'll be that much easier for her to learn a 3rd one, and it'll be that much easier for her to learn other subjects as well. 

Sasha --- 18 years ago -

Sorry too much to read and promise to read it fully by Tuesday. Although the U.S.A. does not have an official language, Americans shouldn't be forced or looked down on for not being bilingual. I can side a bit with Obama when he says that 'everyone is so worried about immigrants learning English, instead they should worry about themselves' ... in a way he is right. But Americans already know English, live in the U.S.A so if they want to learn a new language or even become polyglots ... it is up to them and should not be looked down on. 

Nay-Nay --- 18 years ago -

I think that everyone should learn ASL so that they can communicate with those who are deaf and hard of hearing. :) 

Sasha --- 18 years ago -

I think that everyone should learn ASL so that they can communicate with those who are deaf and hard of hearing. :) Very true! Well 'typed'. 

SeriouslyInaneBabble --- 18 years ago -

Personally I think it is embarrassing as well, that Americans are not bilingual (and I don't particularly care WHICH language other than English.) I am not fluent in any language but English, however, I do speak quite a bit of Spanish, and a little bit of various other languages (probably not enough to get by in the country, just yet.) I guess I feel like, for the most part, Americans are lazy and arrogant, and expect the world to mold around them, and to their ways. 

FlippyFloppies --- 18 years ago -

I have a tit for tat kind of attitude regarding this. I am currently studying Spanish and my next language endeavor will be Arabic. Likewise, I would appreciate if the immigrants coming to this country would make an effort to learn the English language rather than just expecting businesses here to learn their language (primarily Spanish). I know English is one of the more difficult languages to learn, but I appreciate broken English over no effort at all.... And for the record, I understand that there is no official language in America, but to get your citizenship you have to be able to write and speak simple phrases during your interview.... 

SeriouslyInaneBabble --- 18 years ago -

I am currently studying Spanish and my next language endeavor will be Arabic. If you need anyone to study with, I'm up for it. I haven't spoken or written in awhile, but I would be more than happy to study with you. I could use a refresher anyway. :) Hah.... I mean for Arabic... I don't particularly care for Spanish enough anymore. ;) Likewise, I would appreciate if the immigrants coming to this country would make an effort to learn the English language rather than just expecting businesses here to learn their language (primarily Spanish). I didn't touch on this in my post, but I agree. I know English is one of the more difficult languages to learn, but I appreciate broken English over no effort at all.... Technically English is THE hardest language to learn. According to the DLI in Monterey Bay, English is THE ONLY Category 5 language, Category 4 contains languages such as Arabic and Mandarin Chinese. 

Sasha --- 18 years ago -

I guess I feel like, for the most part, Americans are lazy and arrogant, and expect the world to mold around them, and to their ways. That is what I've noticed and gets to me. I've experienced when Americans in foreign countries expect/get upset that signs are only in the countries official language and not in English. I've heard them say "you would think they would have things in English, they know Americans come here" In the U.S.A. some signs are in other languages due to the fact that there is no official language not because all Americans are trying to be nice to all foreigners. 

SeriouslyInaneBabble --- 18 years ago -

That is what I've noticed and gets to me. I've experienced when Americans in foreign countries expect/get upset that signs are only in the countries official language and not in English. I've heard them say "you would think they would have things in English, they know Americans come here" In the U.S.A. some signs are in other languages due to the fact that there is no official language not because all Americans are trying to be nice to all foreigners. Yes, and the way I look at it is this: If you are going to visit another country where the language is NOT English... take the time to learn the language, just a little bit... the locals will appreciate it, and respect you more for it, if you ask me. 

Julianna --- 18 years ago -

um...in my opinion English is the easiest language to learn. But i think you also gotta have love for a language in order to learn it. 

SeriouslyInaneBabble --- 18 years ago -

um...in my opinion English is the easiest language to learn. But i think you also gotta have love for a language in order to learn it. Just out of curiousity.... did you grow up learning English, or is it a second language for you? 

Lisa6823 --- 18 years ago -

Just wondering, does his kids speak another language. I grew up speaking English and Korean, but when my parents divorced my mother's side of family I didnt speak to, so I lost most of it, its in the back of my head, I can understand it but just cant speak it. argg 

Sasha --- 18 years ago -

but to get your citizenship you have to be able to write and speak simple phrases during your interview.... If the person applying for citizenship is over 60 years of age (don't quote me on the age) they have an option of taking the citizenship test on their native language. 

Julianna --- 18 years ago -

Just out of curiousity.... did you grow up learning English, or is it a second language for you? it's a second language...i didn't start learning it until i moved to the US, when i was 15, 7 years ago..the only things i was able to say was hi, bye thank you, yes no 

FlippyFloppies --- 18 years ago -

Technically English is THE hardest language to learn. According to the DLI in Monterey Bay, English is THE ONLY Category 5 language, Category 4 contains languages such as Arabic and Mandarin Chinese. That's what I tried to tell my husband, but he insisted that Arabic and Mandarin were category V while English was IV. Thank you for confirming how I was, yet again, right and he was wrong! :) 

Sasha --- 18 years ago -

Just wondering, does his kids speak another language. 'hawaiian language' Joke (time for me to get ready to get put about 30 hours at the hospital, you guys behave!) 

Lisa6823 --- 18 years ago -

'hawaiian language' Hey Pigeon is pretty funny to listen too. Spent some time in Hawaii 

SeriouslyInaneBabble --- 18 years ago -

That's what I tried to tell my husband, but he insisted that Arabic and Mandarin were category V while English was IV. Thank you for confirming how I was, yet again, right and he was wrong! :) LOL no problem. If that is the ONLY thing I took away from the DLI, then so be it... but it was explained that there were just so many nuances to the language and that is what makes it so difficult to learn. 

SeriouslyInaneBabble --- 18 years ago -

it's a second language...i didn't start learning it until i moved to the US, when i was 15, 7 years ago..the only things i was able to say was hi, bye thank you, yes no Some people who have English as a second language have made the same comment, which surprises me. But I do agree with you that a love for languages tends to help learn a LOT. 

FlippyFloppies --- 18 years ago -

LOL no problem. If that is the ONLY thing I took away from the DLI, then so be it... but it was explained that there were just so many nuances to the language and that is what makes it so difficult to learn. Right. Like the different pronunciations of "ough" and the letter C sounding like K or S....and so on. 

SeriouslyInaneBabble --- 18 years ago -

Yup. Of course, for native English speakers.... they are going to disagree. Personally... the hardest language I have *tried* to study was Vietnamese. Look at the words and just TRY to see and understand how they get certain sounds out of certain combinations of letters. LOL 

SeriouslyInaneBabble --- 18 years ago -

I remember trying to prepare myself for the DLAB so long ago. I got a bunch of languages on tape and CD. German, Vietnamese, Latin, etc. I reasoned that if I could understand basic grammar in many different languages that I would be prepared for the DLAB. HAH! That is some funny sh*t. Nothing can prepare you for that test. 

Ella Mafayo --- 18 years ago -

English is only a tough language to learn because of all the borrowing of phraseology (yes, that's a word) and nuances from other languages. Slang and local dialectical differences also make it hard. But I was just reading "The Well Trained Mind" this week, and was enlightened. English is, essentially, a phonetic language. Each letter has an assigned sound. You put those sounds together in order to read the language. Many people think because of all the 'exceptions to the rules' that it is hard (like the -ough combinations someone mentioned) but in fact, only something like 13% of all words in the English language are 'rule-breakers.' The rest of it follows distinguishable patterns. The trouble with learning English, even for English speaking people, is that we did away with phonics teaching for the most part and went to 'whole language' strategies. It goes into detail in Well Trained Mind, but here's a basic way to put it: The phonics strategy is like learning to build a house by learning how to drive a nail, how to measure, how to cut lumber, how to count bricks, etc. Learn the parts first, and then learn the whole. Popular modern strategies are teaching how to build a house by showing you the house and saying 'off you go...build another one just like it.' You're having to wait until you stumble across a word and gather clues from the words around it, rather than reading it phonetically - the way it was built. So words like -ough words are hard because it is never taught as it's own 'brick.' Whole language teaching has contributed to skyrocketing illiteracy rates in this country. Thanks for all the cool input from non-native English speakers! Like I said, I agree that if you want to live in America, you should have to be able to speak the predominant language. If I were to go live in France, I'd make an effort to learn French. I just don't see the big deal being made in the media and by other political rabble-rousers in resistance to Americans learning other languages. 

Sasha --- 18 years ago -

hooked on phonics Hooked on Phonics The phonics strategy is like learning to build a house by learning how to drive a nail, how to measure, how to cut lumber, how to count bricks, etc. Learn the parts first, and then learn the whole. wa on wax off 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground