Ok so my daughter just turned 17months old. Up till now she has been the kind of child to play on the floor with her toys and she's fine, but lately she's really doing some things she shouldn't.
Climbing on her picnic table,and such. I have put her in timeout for one minute several times. Usually I sit there with her and when the minute is up let her go. My hubs thinks its pointless. He says she doesn't understand. So when did you start timeout?
no and when he was in daycare she held him down too! It is a learning thing, you have to show them something a couple of times before they fully get it!
Time out is stupid. All you're doing is building up anger and, at that age, it is not effective. They truly DON'T understand at that age. It is confusing, it pisses them off, and it starts them on the road to resentment of you. Parenting takes patience and creativity. Instead of making her stand there for a minute, move her somewhere and distract her with another activity. It's called redirection, and it is the only effective, appropriate course of action for kids this age.
capt-- my mother in law who has a PhD in child behavior and speech therapy told me that you have to sit them down and explain to them what they did wrong. It is not like we just sit them down and walk away. And sometimes redirection doesn't work!
my mother in law who has a PhD in child behavior and speech therapy told me that you have to sit them down and explain to them what they did wrong
At 18 months? They don't even know colors at that age. They certainly won't understand that you don't want them to climb the pinic table because they might hurt themselves.
everyone raises their kid their way, you know what is best for your kid!!
True...but explaining things to 17 month olds is like talking to a brick wall most of the time. Unless you keep it VERY simple, you're wasting your breath.
Time out IS sitting them down and leaving them, though, and that's what I was saying was inappropriate.
I'm not saying don't stop your child from dangerous behavior. I'm criticizing that whole time out 'fad' where you sit them in a special place for x amount of time and expect them to learn a lesson when all you're doing is pissing them off and escalating the situation.
Taking them down from the picnic table, saying "NO. you will get hurt." and putting them down in front of a new toy, asking their help with whatever you're busy with, etc...is NOT time out.
my son understood, but he knew colors and was talking by then. They don't know anything until you tell them, you can start teaching them right from wrong at the age YOU feel your child understands, if after one or two timeouts they still don't get it then try something else. Parenting is test and fail, there is no book that is 100% you live and you learn and hope the next time you keep what you learned with first one!
Don't forget it's 2 minutes for every year of their age. That's what is considered acceptable
I've always read/been told one minute per year. Doesn't matter, I don't stick to either. :)
My son 17 mo's old and does understand when i tell him to get down off of somthing before he gets hurt, i have not started timeout with him yet, I did start timeout with my daughter at around 2 1/2 and she picked it up right away, I have always heard put them in timeout 1 min per age
It really depends on your child, it's a learning thing for you and your child
good luck
my mom used fly swatters sometimes when I was a kid.
I only ever got the fly swatter once. It wasn't pretty. LOL We laugh about it now...how twisted are we?
Time out never worked for me either. I always sat my boys down at that age and TALKED to them and explained what could happen if they "touched the hot stove"....ommunication is the key..not screaming at them or putting them in a corner to stare at a wall and they have no idea why they are there.
I spank my kids with rolled up magazines and yell "BAD! BAD! BAD!" I don't think it effects them too much, bc they still misbehave ;)
LMAO Chelle....do you rub their noses in their 'mistakes' too?
LMAO Chelle....do you rub their noses in their 'mistakes' too?
No way! No accidents in the house for a long time!!! HORRAY! However, Cheyenne has found a new love for coffee grains, no idea why but she loves to pull the filter back out of the garbage.