I just saw on the news that a school district has used childrens BMI (body mass index) as a grading scale A-F. If their BMI is too high, the get an F. I agree that there are obsese children these days YET I know that this is just a shoe in for eating disorders. I find that this is to be discrimination and instead of grading a child, offer them assistance!!!! Whats your opinion?
i doubt that kids miss school cause their parents dont push them. i went to school with plenty of overweight and obese people any the were all book worms.. i dont know its crazy
I agree that they should be doing something along these lines, but I think the BMI sucks. I think that fat percentages are good though. But i also think the schools need to offer HEALTHY food if they're going to try to do this. And offer gym classes and also really in depth health classes.
i think it's sad that people view smoking cigarettes as some "horrible thing" but have no problem with people eating mcdonalds. back when that supersize me movie was made, cigarettes was close to being surpassed as the #1 "preventable" killer of people.
Doug I agree with you, I agree that there needs to be either more education to parents about how to feed children or more assistance at the schools for these kids. My son came home Friday and said "mom may I have a carrot so I can grow strong?" he got off the bus saying that so they are obviously saying it on day 2 of school!
lol, i think that eating healthy is one of the most important things parents can do so that their kids will eat healthy too. it saddens me to see kids eating fast food 2+ times a week. my nephews and nieces eat it more. argh.
I agree that they need a testing standard, but i don't think BMI should be it. Maybe do BMI and then if they fail that have an alternate testing method. I could never pass a BMI. I have a large frame. My whole dad's side of the family does. And i'm a "little guy" in comparison to most of my cousins and such.
but yeah. health should be part of education. along with finances. and not just an "economics" class in HS but serious personal finance classes.
yeah, in my school we had vending machines, but you couldn't use them till after school hours... nowadays, kids seem to get junk food whenever they want.
I'm glad you agree with me :-P
I think that some day i'd like to set up an organization that would work "alongside" schoools to teach the things that schools can't "afford" to teach that i really think they can't afford to NOT teach.
When I was in school(yes that was awhile ago) we had exercises we did for PE then we could play. My nephew starts 3rd grade this year and looked at me stupid when I was playing with him the other day and told him lets have a jumping jack competition. He had no clue what one was. I asked him what they do for PE and he said they played on the jungle gym.
haha, yep, they don't exercise now. because being fat is like being a color... you can't discriminate against someone for it. which, sorry fat people, i think is stupid.
Exactly! It didn't matter how good we did our exercise as long as we were trying. We had overweight kids,skinny kids,healthy kids,sick kids it didn't matter you just had to make an effort. Its easier I guess to just open the classroom door and tell them to go.
They have been doing that for a long time. I am pretty sure they did that when I was in elementary school.
It was a Satisfactory/unsat scale. It doesnt refelct their grades. Just lets some kids know that there is need for improvement.
I understand that it could potentially upset some children, but on the other hand...they may be more willing to go outside and ride their bikes instead of coming home and playing video games.
I think that this could be a good thing...our country has one of the most "overweight" populations. Plus, in the long run....a child will be much more healthy if they are within an average BMI.
yeah. i don't see anything wrong with video games as long as that's not ALL they're doing.
but kids can't play dodgeball anymore. it's too "mean." and God forbid you let your kid play with toy guns!
i don't see anything wrong with video games as long as that's not ALL they're doing.
Oh no I don't either its just all some kids do. We were allowed to play for X number of minutes before bedtime if we behaved. When we got home it was homework,outside to play til dinner,bath time and if there was anytime left we could play a video game. Kids just don't go outside anymore.