I did not mean to offend anyone at all! I do not think people are bad for spanking their children. As a matter of fact, I think it is okay to spank a child when it is called for. Personally, growing up...all my Mom had to do was take away something and that was the worst punishment. Spanking is a whole different thing that hitting repeatedly. I am NOT a mother yet and I am sure there are a lot of things I dont know but that doesnt make me an idiot! Anyway, if anyone was upset with what I said...I am sorry. Its sooo not even worth it to fight online with people I dont even know!
I must have missed the topic but the only one I found was the honest discussion one and I didn't see anything offensive by anyone, it was just people's opinions.
Never mind, I see where it was at now. I just had to do some catch up reading!!!
Yeah I can see though where it got sticky, and as a parent myself who also spanks her children I can see where Queen was coming from in her response.
Today on the Maury Show!
"My 13 year old daughter is TRYING to get PREGNANT!"
Case in point. Spank your children when it's necessary. It will be necessary at least once, so make it count.
Deborah, Queen is a very opinionated person and she doesn't bite her tongue, and from the way KatieA said what she said I could easily see why Queen reacted the way she did.
It can go both ways. It isn't saying KatieA is wrong, but just disagreeing with her opinion.
Both are entitled to their own opinions, however, a valid point that Queen had is that KatieA has no children, so trying to say someting about another person and them spanking their children is a bit off.
I used to say I would never touch my children ie spanking etc...yeah right! THat changed when I actually had kids. I don't beat my children in any manner but my parents spanked myself and my brothers and there is a reason why we all turned out so well. THe kids nowadays with these parents that want to "talk" to their kids and never touch them is a good pinpoint as to why kids walk all over their parents nowadays, as well as all these parents want to be their kids friends instead of their parents.
ANd as a sidenote, for those on here that are against any sort of physical reprimand, this isn't personally directed at you since I don't know you or your kids, this is a viewpoint I have on the parents and children I know and have met who have used the various methods of dealing with their children.
Everyone sees everything different.. that is what makes this cyberchat so interesting in great..
I think it is nothing to be upset about..it's just a matter of personal opinion
My parents spanked me and I didn't go around beating on people. My parents had 4 girls and none of us ever did drugs, got arrested or in trouble in school. Why? We knew what would happen when we got home. My parents didn't beat us they explained to us what we did wrong and why we were getting spanked. A couple swats on the rear and we were straight.
Spanking MUST be done out of love and not because you are angry. When you strike out because you're angry, then I believe you definitely are teaching your children to hit. If you remove your child from the situation, verbally teach them why what they did was wrong and why they are being spanked, and then spank them, I feel like you're doing it out of love.
I understand this doesn't work with little ones, but they certainly can understand if you're mad or if you're loving them. Then again, every child is different and can understand at other ages.
My parents used to tear me up when I was younger. With a belt, with a wooden spoon, with whatever was available really. What it taught me was that I DIDN'T want to treat my children that way. It definitely didn't teach me to hit. However, to a child with a different personality, it may have the opposite effect on them and they may want to hit. That's why each of your children should probably be handled in different ways.
Spanking MUST be done out of love and not because you are angry. When you strike out because you're angry, then I believe you definitely are teaching your children to hit. If you remove your child from the situation, verbally teach them why what they did was wrong and why they are being spanked, and then spank them, I feel like you're doing it out of love.
Thats exactly how my parents handled it. I'm not sure if it was the spanking we dreaded or listening to them yack at us but either way it worked.LOL
Hi everyone...
Well here I go with my two cents...I agree with those of you who don't spank. I just feel thats its wrong. I look at my daughter and all my nieces and nephews and I could never hit them. Its better to talk about what they did wrong, or take a toy or something away from them. Spanking only teaches children to mimic their parent's actions of turning to violence to solve a problem.
I'm not speaking to any particular person on here when I say this, but I was taught to not make absolute statements. Like saying something NEVER happens or you ALWAYS do it wrong...or whatever the case may be. This is great for couples to live by but I guess it could also apply to this discussion. I don't think we should say that it's NEVER wrong or right to spank or to punish or to put into time out or whatever. I believe that every situation is different.
Even the Bible mentions using a rod when it comes to discipline. I think very few people can discern the different between punishment and discipline. Punishment is spanking. Discipline is handling your children every minute of every day and can include spanking or whatever form it may take in your home.
Well I know for a fact that I will NEVER lay a hand on my child, not that I'm saying others are wrong if they choose to use spanking in discipline. Its just a personal choice of mine not to incorporate that into my parenting skills because I feel it could leave long lasting negative effects.
I think it depends on the child, I could spank my son and he would turn around and tell me "that did not hurt" but I would still spank him if he did something that deserved a spanking. When I was a kid I got spanked with a belt that had medal holes in it and with a wooden cutting board. I never got into trouble outside of normal teenage stuff when I was growning up. I would never spank my kids with anything other then my hand but god help me sometimes I would like to knock them the hell out! Anyway I agree with Deborah everyone has the right to their opinions..it does not make them wrong or right.
I commend you to take that personal stand and wish you the best in sticking to it! Please let me know where you learned your patience skills cuz I need a lesson or two. LOL My son's only 5 months, but after the temper tantrum he threw in Texas Steakhouse the other night...boy oh boy... He was mad and trying to kick everything off of the table!!!
When I was growing up my dad would spank my brother all the time. Not that I think he deserved it, but he was a really obnoxious, deliquent child. Anyway, when my dad would hit him he would just laugh in his face.
My brother was like that too...now he's a crack head, meth addict in Vegas.....guess it didn't work for him.
I'm a Christian college graduate who has been a Christian school teacher. We were both disciplined pretty much the same way.
I guess that's why I figure it's pretty much based on the person. As a parent, you have to be open minded and discover what is best for each child.
My daughter is almost five months and she is a very fussy baby,and I know it is really difficult to have patience. I also raised my four year old niece for about six months and she was a handful too.
I guess that's why I figure it's pretty much based on the person. As a parent, you have to be open minded and discover what is best for each child.
EXACTLY!! I have two daughters; for one spanking works, and for one loss of privledges does. It all depends on the individual child, and I think for ANYBODY to be pointing fingers at anybody else for their parenting style is just wrong.
My parents seem to think he's straightened himself out, but my hubby and I lived with him for a few months and it would take a miracle to fix him. I believe the Lord does work miracles, but you have to let the Lord do it and my brother is so far from God it's unbelievable. My parents are actually going to allow him to move back in with them for a while.
HE'S 37 YEARS OLD@!!!!! He's feeding them a bunch of lies and I hate to see it happen.
Well everyone faces different challenges in their lives, I guess his just so happens to be addiction and it is a shame how addictions are so powerful. Hopefully he will come around sooner or later, you just have to keep praying.
When we lived with him in Vegas, I had NOOOOO idea what was going on!!! I was soooo blinded. I new he was doing a little wacky weed, but good grief!!! He attacked my sis in law and I one day and I had him arrested. That's when I found out what was going on. All I can say is that God must have put the blinders on me because the stuff that was going on under our noses was unbelievable!!! He'd have women over after my sis in law would go to work. Our room was next to his and there were 2 dogs in the house. We NEVER heard anything!! Craziness!!!
Anyways....I wish you the best with your kids and I'd love to hear about some of your alternate ways of dealing with disobediece and temper tantrums....and...and...and...LOL There are a lot more "ands"