ok, so im doing a online art class and need others opinions. so, if your up for it can you give me your opinion. lol i know, sounds crazy im asking on the loo but, i figured its worth a try. lol
In 1953, Robert Rauschenberg ( a young, unimportant artist) took a drawing by Willem de Kooning (with his permission) and erased it. He entitled it Erased de Kooning Drawing, signed his name and claimed it as his own. Because the drawing was difficult to erase, the process took several months. He said I had been working at some time at erasing, with the idea that I wanted to create a work of art by that method. Not just deleting certain lines, you understand, but by erasing the whole thing. Using my own work wasnt satisfactory .I realized it had to be by someone who everyone agreed was great, and the most logical person for that was de Kooning .finally he gave me a drawing, and I took it home. It wasnt easy by any means. The drawing was done with a hard line, and it was greasy too, so I had to work very hard on it, using every sort of eraser. But in the end it worked. I liked the result. I felt it was a legitimate work of art, created by the technique of erasing.
Part I: What do you think? Did he create a work of art, or not? Write no less than one paragraph with your opinion.
I would have to say no because to me art is a way to physically express creativity or emotions. I don't see how erasing someone elses work really expressed his creativity or emotions. But they say everything is a form of art one way or another so IDK.
Are you asking people to do your homework?
NO! i thought i posted its a survery. i was asking for ppl who WANT TO, to post their own opinion. i was asked to take a survery on others opinion.
Yes, I think it is a work of art. Art can be made from anything. In this case he took a picture and completely changed the meaning of it. He created a new picture (or lack of), therefore a new piece of art.
Did he create a work of art, or not?
Of course its ART. Actually its very original and could really look neat in my opinion. Anything you create is basically a form of art in my mind....including and not limited to painting, drawing,clay, crafts, photography, tattoos, etc :-)
Some people are VERY talented!
Sorry, I'm not doing your homework for you. Survey my a$$. If you were doing a class on anything OTHER than art history, where it involved taking surveys, putting together stats, etc etc, then I might answer your question.
If you want to type up your own original thoughts and post them here for critique, I'll help you with that. Other than that, think for yourself.
Actually I'm in a great mood. I just think this is bullsh*t. I can throw bullsh*t flags in any mood.
If you're a college student you should try making a habit of typing properly at all times. Capital letters come to mind. Proofreading (iNput not iMput) too. But don't tell me, I can guess. It's "only a chat site," right?
If you're a college student you should try making a habit of typing properly at all times.
My thoughts exactly.
im sorry i didnt realize i was being graded on this. Is this better?
if you dont like it put your bullsh*t flag where the sun dont shine.
argue with someone else, dont waste my time.
Chill out guys. Mrs P is a great person, I don't think she'd lie about it and even if she did need help she's certainly not the first regular to come here asking for it! Maybe she needed someone to bounce thoughts off of to get her creative thoughts brewing. Who does it really hurt?
im sorry i didnt realize i was being graded on this. Is this better?
if you dont like it put your bullsh*t flag where the sun dont shine.
argue with someone else, dont waste my time.
How about this?
FU*K YOU.
LM- I would give her the benefit of the doubt if she hadn't posted this:
PART 1
and this:
Write no less than one paragraph with your opinion.
If it's a survey, perhaps she should lock this and start a POLL where a yes or no vote would be required
im sorry i didnt realize i was being graded on this. Is this better?
if you dont like it put your bullsh*t flag where the sun dont shine.
argue with someone else, dont waste my time.
I didn't realize saying someone in college should spell better was arguing.
MN, that's what raised a red flag with me, too.
I'm all for asking opinions on a subject, but don't ask everyone to do your homework for you!
Write no less than one paragraph with your opinion.
That's why I wrote only a little bit.
Honestly though mrs p. if you need help I don't mind helping. I think it helps to get outside opinions with homework. That's why people make study groups.
If you want to type up your own original thoughts and post them here for critique, I'll help you with that.
Keep this in mind. I bounce my craziness off of this guy...meaning I AM priority! =P jk to the last part of that. He did just get an extremely lengthy email from me with my work though...yes, the work I just finished but originally lost. **just keep smiling...**
Part I: What do you think? Did he create a work of art, or not? Write no less than one paragraph with your opinion.
Yes, he did create a work of art. Art is subjective and can be anything from a beautiful painting to a pile of trash to an "erased" piece.
i really didnt feel the need to copy and paste the second part that asked me to do a survery. that was the first part that asked my opinion first. i dont need anyone to tell me my opinion. i was asking if anyone WANTED to share with me their point of view.
i really didnt feel the need to copy and paste the second part that asked me to do a survery. that was the first part that asked my opinion first. i dont need anyone to tell me my opinion. i was asking if anyone WANTED to share with me their point of view. if you dont want to then dont. i really didnt see this as something to start nasty comments on.
Just ignore the comments you don't like and take the opinions. I gave you mine.
Honestly though mrs p. if you need help I don't mind helping. I think it helps to get outside opinions with homework. That's why people make study groups.
thanks. dont need a study group on something like this.
now, if this was a math, then maybe.
Keep this in mind. I bounce my craziness off of this guy...meaning I AM priority! =P
And I ain't even gettin' anything for my effort! I must be a helluva guy! :p
here you go... no to make everyone happy. ill copy and paste the rest....
Part II
Ok. Now that you have written your paragraph with your opinion, I would like you to survey at least five people about what they think. Read the piece to them, or print it out, or tell it to them. Ask them what they think without influencing them in any way. (In my face to face class they have to collect 10 opinions....you can get more than 5 if you want!) Jot notes down about what people say.
After you have completed your informal survey, summarize what your friends/family/teachers think. Do they all agree, do they have differing opinions, etc. Summarize your experiences (" I had some fascinating conversations" "They thought I was crazy" "We talked about art for hours....!") and explain how people felt etc. This should be as long as you need it to be, but no shorter than two-three paragraphs. Add it on to your saved Word document and then save it again.
When that is done, go to the next folder.
Now, see how easy that was? Had you done so in the first place I'd have been all for giving my opinion, because I DAMN SURE have one on this.
However, since you told me to shove it up my a$$, no thanks.
Now, see how easy that was? Had you done so in the first place I'd have been all for giving my opinion, because I DAMN SURE have one on this.
I know, you have a opinion on everything. lol