Ok guys... I'm doing a paper for my Medical Law and Ethics class on Assisted Suicide--basically giving a terminally ill person the option IF they request it, to end their own life in a civilized, dignified manner.
Just curious what everyone's thoughts are on this.
THANKS!
See I am too.
DH disagrees with me. Haha we got into a VERY heated debate about it.
Honestly if I'm living like a vegetable, can't wipe my own arse, I would want the option. He argues and says that its still suicide and that you'd go to hell for it.
Isn't that illegal most places? I don't really have an opinion on it. I'm pro-life in pretty much every scenario so I lean toward I don't agree with it, but if I or someone I loved was in the situation I dunno.
Isn't that illegal most places?
They're looking to make it legal in some states... I believe in some it already is but I haven't done enough research just yet.
I think Jack Kevorkian should've been given a medal instead of being put on trial. That should let you know how I feel.
Agreed. I actually think it's RIDICULOUS to deny it to a terminally ill person. And for the "going to hell" argument, if the person WANTS to die, then they probably don't care about going to "hell". It's still their choice, so who gives a damn?
For people who just don't want to be alive (the boo hoo my BF broke up with me types) no.
True. I think "regular" suicide is incredibly selfish. But, sometimes people feel there is no other way out. :-(
For people who just don't want to be alive (the boo hoo my BF broke up with me types) no.
**Blank stare**
You didn't honestly think that was even part of the debate, did you?
**Hopes like hell she didn't seriously think that was being considered as an option anywhere by anyone**
**Hopes like hell she didn't seriously think that was being considered as an option anywhere by anyone**
No I didn't think that was part of this particular debate in this thread. I just through that out there sharing my opinion.
Ok good!
I'm glad I'm not the only one that agrees with it.
I think this paper is going to be fun to write. Its basically an all opinion paper so I'll get to put my 2 cents about it all. =)
Good topic choice! I wrote a paper about it a few years ago when I was in college. It was interesting to look up the different states laws, especially Oregon's Death with Dignity Act.
Really!? Was it a pretty easy topic to write about??
We had talked about it a little in class not too long ago. Seems like no matter what we talk about in that class, I believe the complete opposite of everyone else in there. *shrugs*
They were all boo hooing that its horrible and blah blah blah.
It was easy. People worry about their legacy, they don't want to be remembered as someone wasting away in bed...
Have you ever watched that one Renee Zellweger movie where her mom has cancer and kills herself with Morphine?
I think the government should stay out of people's private affairs.
The issue shouldn't even be on the "legal" radar. (We're talking about assisted suicide by choice here - not murder.)
I think the government should stay out of people's private affairs.
The issue shouldn't even be on the "legal" radar. (We're talking about assisted suicide by choice here - not murder.)
ditto this^^^^^
Dh's grandmother had a doctor assisted suicide. Now let me finish before you ring my neck girls. She was 69 yrs old, body riddled with cancer, too weak to undergo chemo, on oxygen 24/7, stayed in bed 23 of 24 hrs in a day. She also lived in Canada which makes this very different. The doctor gave her morhpine the day she died. It was sad to lose her but she got what she wanted. She was 39 when her husband had a heart attack and died. Her kiddos are grown and had families of their own. She was a fiesty (sp?) one but had great spirits right up until the end. I think it is ok if you live everyday with pain and you know your time is coming anyway.
I think it should be legal, without a doubt. If a terminally ill person wants to end their suffering their way, on their termsm who the f*ck are the rest of us to tell them they have to keep suffering?