My husband and I were separated for three weeks about two months ago. We had gone up to a different for a mini vacation before the separation. It was myself, my husband, his sister, and his brother. His sister and I had a physical fight and refused to ride back in the same vehicle with me. My husband of course stayed behing with her and his brother.
Here is were I need opinions..... MY husband bought all three of them plane tickets. One for himself to fly back here and the other two for his siblings to fly back home. He charged those tickets on my credit card because he is an authorized user. The charges are a little over a thousand dollars. Well, while we were separated I had gone to an attorney who advised me that my husband was responsible for those charges he had made them the day that we became separated. Ok heres the thing now..... We are back together and I feel that I should that be responsible for his sister's and brother's plane ticket. I feel that she should pay for them. My husband said that he would pay for them and even though we have separate accounts now from the separation, I feel that, that really doesn't make a difference.
What do you guys think?
I think if you have an account together, he is authorized to make any charges he deems necessary.
I think physical fighting is tacky.
I think if he's going to pay for them, what's the problem?
Let it go, it's not worth it trust me. Once you reconciled the past is the past, leave it there.
I agree with this, but I am the one now that is stuck paying for $130 payments because of those charges.
I think if you have an account together, he is authorized to make any charges he deems necessary.
I have to disagree there, I have a friend that is separated and her spoused used her card (she forgot she had him as a USER) to buy his new girlfriend's kids clothes, but yet he won't help her with their own children.
I agree with this, but I am the one now that is stuck paying for $130 payments because of those charges.
he said he would pay it didn't he? so what's the big deal?
i would just pay it and wash my hands clean of it...when J and i were having probs we both did retarded things with money. we fixed it and never spoke of it again
I think if you have an account together, he is authorized to make any charges he deems necessary.
Not according to the attorney that I consulted with.
think physical fighting is tacky.
I think so too, but it became a different story when she struck me twice. I wasn't going to stand there and let her hit me.
I think if he's going to pay for them, what's the problem?
The problem is that I feel that it is her problem not ours. But I guess if he pays for the charges then he can just deal with it and not me.
It's like this, he did something while you were separated, you decided to take reconcile, had you said I will reconcile if you pay this off or if your sister pays this blah blah, then I can see you wanting her to pay it, but if not, then IMO once you reconciled you made the choice to take him and all of his decisions/ actions back from the past. You're never going to get over the past if you keep wanting to bring it up.
he said he would pay it didn't he? so what's the big deal?
Yea, you are right. I guess in a way it bothers me because even though we have separate accounts still, we still have obligations together and because of his sister's immaturity "we" will be out of a thousand dollars.
If he said he'd pay for it, just let him pay for it. You're not paying $130/month if all your money is separate right now.
You can't expect her to pay you since you don't know what the agreement was between her and your husband.
If he wants the money back, that's his responsibility, again, since you weren't there to hear the agreement. You can't expect for her to pay if she never said she would, just because you and your husband did or did not get back together.
Just let him pay for it, like he said, and be done with it.
and because of his sister's immaturity "we" will be out of a thousand dollars.
could you not have flown home yourself, left them the car, and had a smaller debt?
It doesn't seem that she was the only one at fault here. Your BIL and your husband decided to stay.
could you not have flown home yourself, left them the car, and had a smaller debt?
It was my car that we were all in and at the time with all the chaos that was going on that option did not come up.
I think if you have an account together, he is authorized to make any charges he deems necessary.
I have to disagree there, I have a friend that is separated and her spoused used her card (she forgot she had him as a USER) to buy his new girlfriend's kids clothes, but yet he won't help her with their own children.
Your friend shouldn't have forgotten.
I think if you have an account together, he is authorized to make any charges he deems necessary.
Not according to the attorney that I consulted with.
I'm confused. You say that you went on a different vacation - it was you, your husband, inlaws.
Your husband made the charges the day you were separated? Maybe he made the charges moments before the separation.
Do you have a job?
I'm not an attorney and don't pretend to be one, but being the daughter of a lawyer and knowing what I know, I think the attorney you spoke with is full of sh!t.
I'm confused. You say that you went on a different vacation - it was you, your husband, inlaws.
We were all on the same vacation.
Your husband made the charges the day you were separated?
Yes
Maybe he made the charges moments before the separation.
No, the day he stayed which is the same day I left, it was already clear by him that he wasn't going to be coming back. I the whole time wanted to work things out. He did not. He abandoned the marriage. That same day he made the cahrges.
Do you have a job?
Yes
I'm not an attorney and don't pretend to be one, but being the daughter of a lawyer and knowing what I know, I think the attorney you spoke with is full of sh!t.
No, he was not. He made perfect sense. If I Can remember what it is called then I would type it out, but I can't remember. The attorney I consulted with is with base legal. I doubt that he would not know what he is talking about when he deals with hundreds of separation/divorces. That is JMO.
If all you're going to do is argue, why the fu*k did you even ask for opinions?
As has already been said, YOU RECONCILED. GET OVER IT IF YOU REALLY WANT TO STAY THAT WAY.
and because of his sister's immaturity "we" will be out of a thousand dollars.
But it wasn't his sister's immaturity. It was his decision to charge the card. No matter what he bought and for whom, it's his responsibility to pay for it because HE made the decision to charge the card.
That being said, if you're reconciled- lettigo. If it REALLY means that much to you then you have to do what you have to do. I do think that since you're back together, you need to suck it up. If he said he would make the payments then you need to trust him to do so.
It also sounds like (from your most recent post in response to Jules) you are holding alot of animosity towards him from the seperation. Let that go or it's not going to work.
If all you're going to do is argue, why the fu*k did you even ask for opinions?
First of all Tiki there is no need for cursing. Second of all I am not arguing. Third of all I did ask for opinions and I have the right to ask for them and in return give mine if I feel the need to.
As has already been said, YOU RECONCILED. GET OVER IT IF YOU REALLY WANT TO STAY THAT WAY.
Yes, I reconciled and certain issues were not discussed. Just because I am wanting to figure out the best way to handle this does not mean that I am not over it or that I am not trying to work on getting over it.
It also sounds like (from your most recent post in response to Jules) you are holding alot of animosity towards him from the seperation. Let that go or it's not going to work.
Not necessarily. Am I still hurt from everything? Yes, as that is natural. But things between my husband and I are going well so it is not like we are not getting along or anything like that.
If you are an authorized user on an account, you have the right to use that account until you are no longer an authorized user on said account.
That's just common sense.
If the attorney you consulted at base legal gave you the advice and you were content with that advice, why come ask us?