P.S. I Love You was a disappointment to me. Although I cried for 90% of the movie and as movies go yes I adore this one BUT as novel adaptations it can bite me. The book was SOOOO much better and very very different. Therefore, I was disappointed.
Anyone have any other book to movies they feel this way about?
It's very rare I'll see the movie before I read the book. There are some movies that are old and popular I've never seen because I haven't read the book yet. I don't want to think about the movie and actors while I'm reading because I prefer to make it up myself first in my head you know?
The Notebook was one of mine too. I thought the left alot out and changed it too much.
A Walk to Remember was one of the closest ones of seen.
East of Eden with James Dean bothered me too.
Any of Shakespeare's Plays. (Ok, not books, but ya know what I mean. lol)
1984, book waaaayy better.
Oh and Beowulf, Ok not a book either, but still epic poem was better. Movie sucked.
I liked the Notebook movie better than the book, but that's probably because I saw it before I read the book.
Memoirs of a Geisha was pretty close to the book... but that makes for a long and boring movie.
The only ones I can think of that I have seen without reading the book is the Bourne movies.
I haven't seen Da Vinci Code or Sixth Sense two of the big ones I can think of because I haven't read the book.
I'm starting to think I don't want to see SATC before I read the book.
Most versions of Dracula and Frankenstein. The novels are soooo different than the movie depictions of the stories.
Almost any John Grisham novel.
The Prince of Tides.
Primary Colors.
1984.
SATC I won't read the book. Because I have seen the entire series (missed a few shows here and there) but I can't read the book now, they're real to me, hahahahaha. I like Pride and Prejudice but I thought the main characters lacked the passion between them. I couldn't fit my mind around it because they didn't show and love or passion. Nothing. In the book it's very different.
but that makes for a long and boring movie.
That's a fact. I loved the novel, but could not watch the movie in one sitting. I actually had it on in the background while I was cleaning the house.
That's a fact. I loved the novel, but could not watch the movie in one sitting. I actually had it on in the background while I was cleaning the house.
I loved the book too... but the movie was just so long and... boring. I don't think they left out a single detail. LOL
The ONLY adaptation of The Phantom of the Opera by Gaston Leroux that I like is the newest one that was done by ALW for the big screen. The others have all sucked a$$
I like Pride and Prejudice but I thought the main characters lacked the passion between them. I couldn't fit my mind around it because they didn't show and love or passion. Nothing. In the book it's very different.
That's actually another one that I had not read the book. I didn't like the movie so maybe I'll give the book a try.
I haven't seen Da Vinci Code or Sixth Sense two of the big ones I can think of because I haven't read the book.
Call me stupid...Sixth Sense was based on a book? I had no idea.
I'm always disappointed in Stephen King books translated over to movies. (I've been in this conversation with someone here before! LOL!) I didn't read the book, but I saw The Mist last night and, WOW...talk about a DISTURBING ending.
Speaking of books..I will be getting rid of a ton of books for free (mostly paperback mysteries.) Anyone intersted..PM me! If not..they are going to the library.
I'm still trying to read The Cell by Stephen King. His newer stuff doesn't grab me like his earlier works.
I read about one chapter and put it down. They make that a movie?
if i read the book first, i won't watch the movie. and if i watch the movie first, i have a hard time getting into the book, or i'll be upset that they left stuff out of the movie that's in the book.
I wasn't too pleased with Cell either
It was definitely a weird read. I enjoyed it because it was sooo different than other books I tend to read. I'm not a huge Steven King fan..so I wanted to give it a try. LOL!