Quick recap of events:
With the knowledge that my child is not an angel or anywhere close to it, so I am not babying him, I write the following:
Children are lined up at the 'lunch line' my son says kids were pushing each other and he gets out of line. Long story short, a staff member says 'get back to the end of the line' My son is upset, says "oh my god!" This staff member follows him and tells him that he should only say 'oh my god" if he is praying and scolds him for it and if course his behavior.
What do you say about the staff member's comment?
Proper or improper???
Proper, but wrong place???
Improper any place???
I would say what she scolded him for was wrong...it should have been for his attitude, not what he said.
UNLESS, he is attending a religious school.
I agree with the above statement.
If your son said it with an attitude, she could've just wanted to get the last word in, no matter how.
I've had my parents tell me it's a sin to do blah blah blah even though they're not the least bit religious. Just because they wanted me to shut up most the time.
I would say what she scolded him for was wrong...it should have been for his attitude, not what he said.
UNLESS, he is attending a religious school.
I agree with the above statement.
I agree with this also.
If the lunch lady was as proficient at watching the kids in line as she was putting her unwelcome two cents in about what a child said, then she would have noticed that your son was pushed out of line and wouldnt have made him go to the end of the line anyway.
But I think it was entirely improper what she said. Now had he rolled his eyes or something that would be reason for a talking-to, but not because he said "oh my god"
I would say, that your child needs to know that he can not disrespect his elders on any occasion, no matter how wrong the person was, or how right he felt he was. I say this because it is times like these that he will "learn" that if he feels like he has been wronged (which they will MANY times as a teen) that it is ok to speak your mind.
Now if you feel like you should talk to someone about it, go to the principal. I mean really, life sucks. He didn't get suspended he just had to go to the back of the line. No biggie.
I say this because it is times like these that he will "learn" that if he feels like he has been wronged (which they will MANY times as a teen) that it is ok to speak your mind.
Are you saying that if someone has been wronged, it's not OK to speak their mind?
Keep religion out of schools!
That's what I say. The adult should have "let it go." So what? A kid said Oh, my God!
The lunch lady didn't need to push her views on your child and she certainly didn't need to follow him.
I would say that children should learn to have respect for authority figures. If there is a problem they should be able to come to you about it. Nothing pisses me off more than seeing a pre-teen smarting off. It is crude and improper.
not proper at all cause he has no right to push his religious belief on your child in any form .
I agree, by law. But morally, the teacher is right. Back in the day kids never took the Lord's name in vain. Now it's just commonplace. Doesn't make it right though.
Nothing pisses me off more than seeing a pre-teen smarting off. It is crude and improper.
Thats jsut about every preteen and teen. Its normal for a kid to be a smartass sometimes.
"oh my god"... I would say it is followed with a roll of the eyes and said with a smart ass tone. I have heard it several times, as I am sure you have. I am not saying the lunch lady was right. Like I said if she has a problem with it she can go to the principal. It is what you are teaching your children... you are teaching them that they can act disrespectful to others.
i just think its sad that you think its okay to say some of what you say including this
Saying "Oh my God" isn't what I could consider crude, improper, or disrespectful
Saying "Oh my God" isn't what I could consider crude, improper, or disrespectful.
I agree. At least he didn't say shutup or get right in her face and become completely out of control. I say Oh my god all the time. Its not something that is that big of a deal.
Keep religion out of schools!
That's what I say. The adult should have "let it go." So what? A kid said Oh, my God!
The lunch lady didn't need to push her views on your child and she certainly didn't need to follow him.
What she said! ;)
What if said child was actually praying to his God and said Oh, my God for direction and help with being a good, respectful young man?
OK, bad example - but you get the point.
If one is not supposed to take the Lord's name in vain, which basically means The third commandment forbids all profaning and abusing of anything whereby God makes Himself known.
This would include saying "God bless you" but I bet noone is up in arms when THAT happens!